Already a month past the deadline, the Abbottabad Commission braces for further delay in releasing its report as it struggles to determine how and with whose help al Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden had been living in Abbottabad for years.
The government formed the high-powered inquiry commission last year to investigate the killing of Bin Laden by American commandos in a secret raid on May 2, 2011.
Its mandate also includes finding out whether the terror leader was aided by elements from within the secret agencies, as alleged by the West.
However, insiders told The Express Tribune on Wednesday that the commission is in a fix over the question of fixing responsibility.
“It looks like they can’t and won’t name anybody,” said an official, who is aware of the proceedings.
Chief of the commission Justice (retd) Javed Iqbal told the media last December that the report, encompassing all the aspects of the matter, will be completed by the end of the year. However, this is yet to happen.
Officials privy to the inquiry attributed the delay to the explosive question of naming and blaming those who were at the helm of affairs in secret agencies during the years Bin Laden was living in his safe house – which is literally in the backyard of the military’s top training facility.
At least four generals, including incumbent military chief Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, served as head of the country’s premier spy agency, the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), from 2003 and 2011 -- during Bin Laden’s years in Abbottabad.
There are suspicions in the West that the mastermind of the 9/11 terror attacks had a ‘support network’ within Pakistani spy agencies.
“Of course, somebody was responsible and the commission is responsible for identifying that somebody,” said an official. “But it seems the probe body is not going to do that,” he added.
Beating about the bush
An official, who claimed to have had a discussion with one of the commission’s members, said the probe had almost been completed by the end of last year, and what is being done now is nothing but wasting time.
“They are beating about the bush now,” the insider said, after the commission summoned Interior Minister Rehman Malik for questioning but he refused due to other ‘pressing’ engagements.
According to an announcement by the commission’s secretariat, a new date will soon be decided to have a session with the minister.
There wasn’t any word what the probe body wanted to question Malik about.
Details of illegal immigrants sought
The Abbottabad Commission has also sought details of arrests of illegal immigrants in the last 10 years by the interior ministry and the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), The Express Tribune has learnt.
The commission has written a letter to the interior ministry, in this regard, asking for a detailed report.
(With additional reporting by Asad Kharal in Lahore)
Published in The Express Tribune, February 16th, 2012.
COMMENTS (35)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1730806656-0/BeFunky-collage-(23)1730806656-0-405x300.webp "article")
1730806490-0/New-Project-(2)1730806490-0-270x192.webp "jcp names justice amin ud din khan as constitutional bench head")
1730802981-0/Untitled-design-(53)1730802981-0-270x192.webp "fakhar imam set to rejoin pakistan squad for south africa tour")
1730799445-0/Untitled-design-(52)1730799445-0-270x192.webp "pakistan iran agree to jointly tackle border security challenges")
1730800230-0/Copy-of-Untitled-(5)1730800230-0-270x192.webp "electricity becomes more expensive for karachiites")
1730706072-0/Copy-of-Untitled-(2)1730706072-0-270x192.webp "influence of pop culture on marketing")
@Harry Stone: Dear Harry, My apologies. I mixed you up with Cautious. A senior moment maybe. Perhaps I am wrong and we should just blame Pakistan for the whole mess. Maybe we could also blame Pakistan for Iraq and Libya being bombed into the stone age. Best wishes.
The best option for commission to save those responsible for OBL fiasco is to opine that due to insufficient evidence presented before it, the findings were inconclusive to pinpoint blame on anybody and leave it to the judicary to decide, who would most likely ignore this issue.
@Harry Stone: Dear Harry, Which of the fairy tales dreamed up by by Washington such as 9/11 and taking out Osama Bin Laden would you like to discuss? If the Tribune will allow us we could write a 50,000 word dissertation on the problem. However, before we start on this I should point out that I did not say that Osama Bin Laden was alive, and as for the rest I thought everything I wrote was also factual. Think about it and let me know in a reasonably precise manner where I went wrong in your opinion. Regards, Tony C. P.S. : we have to stop meeting like this.
Totally agreed with Yuri Kondratyuk! They really are pretending like they are sleeping. Real question is can anybody dare naming that organisation and personnel openly.
It is being said that in case of OBL killing, ISI has suffered a colossal setback but No sane person may believe that this well-guarded compound was not a CIA safe house where OBL and his family were being kept to spring them up as a joint Pak-US victory Trophy on WOT, which may be done sometimes closer to withdrawal date to be announced by Obama (July last year) but somehow at last minute; Pentagon saw it un workable as it will be seen very compromising.
US decided to betray its ally and declared a sole victory by killing and hijacking OBL…and at the same times alleging ISI for her accomplices too.
Whereas this is a colossal betrayal by US of its ally but this was joint Pak-US venture and it is strange that rather than high lighting the betrayal of US and move on; Pakistani media is beating about the bushes and like to see the ISI or the military isolated and fixing a blame on them of some kind of ill doing. There is nothing evil here as this was joint US venture; which from Pakistan point of view met a collosal failure.
@Sandip:
Did Tony C write this for you.........? Sounds much like him
@Pakistan politics: Blockquote
Blockquote> Wonder if the commission report says Osama was not killed in Abotabbad Operation :p
Methinks it will go like this: He was bred in India, indoctrinated in Israel, used to bring down WTC and then sent to Abbottabad via Fedex (by the US) and then killed there. All of this done to frame Pakistan by US, Israel, India axis. :)
@Cautious: there was never a person called OBL.even claim of his existense is a conspiracy
The whole saga of Osama Bin Laden appears to be like a futuristic fantasy novel with little twists and turns designed to entertain readers on a cold winter night, and any resemblance to reality is purely coincidental. I had never heard of Osama Bin Laden until U.S. intelligence accused him of perpetrating 9/11 with the help of a few Saudi Arabians, within 24 hours of it happening. We know that the Americans were familiar with Osama Bin Laden because they admitted training him, with a view to making life difficult for the Russians. We know that some Saudis were in America, because they went for pilot training on single engine aircraft, and the trainer has made the remark that they were so inept he would not allow them to drive his car. Never-the-less we have been led to understand that they commandeered a few of the largest aircraft in the world and knew how to navigate and control them for several hours until they flew them into three buildings. Additionally, a fourth building then conveniently collapsed without any help. Up until now there has not been a satisfactory explanation about what really happened, but for reasons best know to President Bush he blamed the Taliban for allowing Osama Bin Laden to hole out in the mountains, and declared war on Afghanistan. With the largest intelligence network in the world America could not find Osama Bin Laden for ten years, but then a Doctor told them he was in Abbottabad. Subsequently, President Obama gleefully proclaimed that U.S. forces had captured him, but could not provide proof because they had disposed of the body. Now the Abbottabad Commission have to come up with an explanation about what really happened in Abbottabad. Best of luck to Justice Javed Iqbal. I hope your crystal ball is in good working order.
@Pakistan politics:
the best of both worlds.........OBL was not killed in Abotabbad ..........because he was never there.........
Ask Ziauddin Butt - he seems to know everything.
Wonder if the commission report says Osama was not killed in Abotabbad Operation :p
Who other than our army can be so foolish to take on a super power. Although i dont like this super power they certainly were right in killing Osama who gave a bad name to Islam.
The rest of the World already knows everything they need to know about Abbottabad and Pakistan has decided to come down with a a convenient case of selective amnesia. The Commission has devolved into an embarrassment for Pakistan - I keep expecting someone on the Commission to fake an illness which may provide the Commission an excuse to go into an indefinite recess.
Oh, we lost Muhammad Bin Qasim II. If someone has doubts, pl ask those who passionately participated in bin Laden's Namaz-e-Janaza held at chauburgi Lahore. Those who provided Bin Laden safe heaven, definitely had same passion in their hearts. How long we will look for new Muhammad bin Qasim, Ghaznavi or others to heal our self-imposed wounds.
Very difficult to blame youself
It is about time (though 60+ years late) to finally name the institution that has brought down Pakistan and shamed it and to FULLY come into the command of the elected Govt. I want to see BRIC+P (Brazil/Russia/India/China+Pakistan) to be the next world powers.
Just like Saleem Shahzad commission were unable to find the kidnappers and murderers similarly they will be unable to pin the blame. These commissions are just a waste of time and money and protect the REAL CULPRITS
So much about the independence of judges!
The way no one killed Saleem Shahzad, no one helped OBL build that house, fortify it, finance it, install security arrangements for it, buy land for it,etc.
I wont even be surprised if they hang that poor Doctor who conducted Polio vaccinations, which ultimately led to OBLs death.
The people who helped a mass murderer go scot free, but life saving, innocent Doctors who unknowingly help to nab a killer get the noose.
@Waqt-ka-Taqaaza:
Thats a good idea. The report should state. Osama was never in Abbottabad and all the Americans did was a story cooked up for Hollywood movie. So there is no question of blaming any one.
BTW, pls suggest some reason why that Doctor is behind bars.
Who is responsible? Its written on the wall. Real question is can anybody dare naming that organisation and personnel openly. Do,'t think so.
OBL traveled deep in to Pakistan, made a base in a Military town - walkable distance from a Major military institute, lived there for 6 years with his entire family, having bought a home there!!
Surely no one in Pakistan establishment knew or can be blamed!! It was a Indian/Israel/US conspiracy to have planted him there! Or perhaps he was never there, it was just a claim..
As saying goes - you can't fool all the people all the time. Pakistan Army is running out of people whom it can fool.
@Waqt-ka-Taqaaza: Just because a majority is a little on the slow side it doesn't mean the world should have to dumb itself down to match it. It's more like an embarrassing aspect of the situation that people try not to draw attention to publicly. Too many cousins, too little standards.
Nusrat Javed in Bolta Pakistan Talk show said that the Commission is delaying releasing the report on purpose and intends to release the report after the retirement of Gen. Pasha.
It's easy to wake up someone from sleep, but, it's very difficult to wake up someone who pretends to sleep.
The powerful protectors of OBL would be protected at all costs. They would come out with a whole lot of nothing without focussing the real issue the presence of OBL and his harem in the custom made safe house for 6 years. If it could be made the civilian's fault the SC and its judges would try the case on an emergency basis and would go to any extent to seek the evidence but they are not going to anything against the failure and complicity of army. Not now and never. This kind of using resources and protecting the terrorists is the worst form of corruption and treason.
While their at it, maybe this commission can also find out who killed Liaquat Ali Khan? who lost half my country? who completely fabricated the modern history of my country? who killed zia? who killed BB? who attacked Mehran Base? who attacked the GHQ? May 12th? and who in their right mind is stupid enough to believe we will ever get the answers to these trivial questions........
hahaha, I told you so!!
This Commission will waste time and money without anything of consequence showing up in its report. Everybody and their mother in law knows that it is impossible to live in a garrison town in a huge structure with 12 feet walls unnoticed by the relevant Powers in the area. The issue is whether the sugar coating will be honey based, molasses based or merely colorful icing.
More than 60% of Pakistani citizens do not believe OBL was killed by the Americans. So what is this commission all about?
This certainly shows that a high profile military figure is the culprit. Had this been fault of any civilian, the commission would have given their findings at once.
The Goals of this "Investigation" were determined long ago, so no one should be surprised at the lack of any substance to the findings! With the probable lack of "cooperation" from all the interested parties, I doubt if the commission could even report on what the weather was like in Abbottabad back on May 2nd! One thing I would bet on is that the final "report" will be similar to that issued over the death of SALEEM SHAZAD, (and maybe even implicate HRW in helping the Americans find OBL)!!! All in all though, after seeing the "report" think of that famous cartoon showing those three monkeys (See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil)!!! I just smile and image those first few words of the report to be 'OSAMA bin WHO??