SC terms new judges appointment procedure as not workable

Supreme Court Monday said the procedure prescribed for appointment of judges in the 18th amendment is not workable.


Express August 02, 2010

ISLAMABAD:

The Supreme Court on Monday said the procedure prescribed for the appointment of judges in the 18th amendment is above the constitution and it is not workable.


During the hearing of petitions against certain clauses of the 18th amendment, the court said that setting up of a committee for the appointment of judges is not fit for the parliamentary system.


The court said that over-a-century-old method for the appointment of judges was changed by the Parliamentary Committee on Constitutional Reforms in just nine hours.


The SC bench also said that the defection clause in the 18th Amendment is an insult to parliamentarians.


However, the counsel for the government defended the clause, saying that it will help to stop horse trading in the country.


The Supreme court will resume hearing of the 18th amendment case tomorrow.

COMMENTS (5)

Asad | 13 years ago | Reply "The court said that over-a-century-old method for the appointment of judges was changed by the Parliamentary Committee on Constitutional Reforms in just nine hours." What an absolutely ridiculous comment to make. In trying to prove their independence, the judiciary is now playing to the galleries.
Hammad Masood | 13 years ago | Reply Accurate comment about parlimentarians, becauz that clause will encourage dictatorship in parties, which is already dominant in political systm. For the appointment of judges US system should be considered.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ