Medicine crisis: who is to blame?

Published: January 30, 2012
Email
A heart patient lies on a bed while seeking treatment at the Mayo hospital in Lahore on January 26, 2012. PHOTO: REUTERS

A heart patient lies on a bed while seeking treatment at the Mayo hospital in Lahore on January 26, 2012. PHOTO: REUTERS

As more patients continue to die after consuming medicines given out by the Punjab Institute of Cardiology, things have been prevented from growing more chaotic as a strike by the Young Doctor’s Association (YDA) was called off, following successful talks with the Punjab Health Department. The doctors has struck after the Medical Superintendant (MS) of the concerned cardiac centre, was suspended and later arrested by the FIA — on the orders of Interior Minister Rehman Malik, and ended their protest after he was released . The protest would, of course, have meant more misery for patients who are in no way responsible for the crisis or the events that brought it about, with the death toll now standing at 112.

The YDA holds, with some logic, that the Punjab government— and not hospital heads — are responsible for ensuring the quality of medicines manufactured and provided to health institutes. The Pakistan Medical Association had also demanded the release of the arrested MS and threatened to call a countrywide strike if this did not happen. Successful talks have averted catastrophe; this obviously is good news. But it does not change the fact that what has happened is terrible. The deaths should never have occurred. But suspending or jailing doctors will not help, especially as there is no evidence of foul play on their part. As the testing of suspect drugs continues, there appears to be some doubt over the control of drug manufacturing following the devolution of health to the provinces. The prime minister has said that unlike the other three provinces, Punjab has declined to set up a drug control authority of its own. This matter needs to be looked into. We also wonder if the holding of multiple portfolios by the provincial chief minister, including health, is affecting performance. There is, after all, a limit to how much one man can do. Rather than making arrests, it is these issues that need to be explored, to ensure that a tragedy of this kind, or the events that have followed it, never occur again.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 31st, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (2)

  • Falcon
    Jan 31, 2012 - 4:31AM

    Doctors make for an easy scapegoat, that’s why Govt. will choose to go for their arrests rather than taking up the responsibility of governance problems.

    Recommend

  • Grace
    Feb 1, 2012 - 1:24AM

    Everyone has a role to play: the doctors, the pharmacists, the drug manufacturues in Punjab and Karachi, Sind, the provincial government as well as the Federal government that allowed importation of drug raw materials. The people don’t want cheap point scoring by politicians; They want an inquiry as is done in western countries when there are similar incidents over there. Then they want the different levels of government to act on the recommendations so it doesn’t happen again.

    Recommend

More in Editorial