But our deep state’s love for the Taliban belies logic. They are a self-propelled doomsday machine with a coy mind of its own. And then there is the worry about the Taliban’s contagious ideology, the actual pound of flesh.
Every faith has a code of ethics and permitted methods to achieve them. Most faiths actually forbid the use of barbaric methods, no matter how much their followers try to justify them. And the Taliban have erased that distinct fine line. When ends start justifying the means, the means get meaner by the day and eventually ends, too, more crooked. This freneticism has been inflicted on the Pakistani nation by this band of thugs as even Ziaul Haq’s 11 years couldn’t.
They have struck again and again, intellectually, emotionally, socially, subliminally and exacted many pounds of flesh. First, they collected our deep state, then religious political parties, then clergy and now mainstream media and political parties too. And since then, our deep state’s central conceit and plot device has been that they are god-fearing people who just want a free Afghanistan (obviously serving as our strategic depth). And while they removed pound after pound of living tissue from our body, blood was also being spilled, innocent blood on which no one has any right. And our Portia is already dead.
This time, the threat is not territorial and they are not coming on horseback from abroad. They want their ideology to rise within us and eclipse our better senses. And by the looks of it, the scheme is working. Why, I ask you, within a few short years, has our parliament become so weak-kneed that offering fatiha for Salmaan Taseer is forbidden and yet someone can get away with doing the same for Osama bin Laden? Why is it that when the Abbottabad Commission seems all set to declare that the man killed by the US marines was not Osama, our intelligence’s head honcho quietly visits Doha? Why is it that the two main political parties vying to replace the current government are coming out of the closet as Taliban apologists? Why is it that Jamaatud Dawa and Jamaat-e-Islami rallies are taking place with an increased frequency? And finally, why is it that while terrorists responsible for the deaths of countless fellow citizens are set free by our courts, our honourable judges cannot overcome their fixation with memogate? Something sinister is afoot.
One does not need to be pernickety to gauge the loss of our brave soldiers at the hands of these barbarians. All you need to do is to travel to Rawalpindi and visit the Armed Forces Institute of Rehabilitation Medicine and meet some war victims there. It is not time to fuss, but to stand up and reclaim Quaid’s Pakistan.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 3rd, 2012.
COMMENTS (30)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Excellent analysis, to say the least.
@faraz My feeling exactly.I am surprised that your comment saw the light of the day. Never the less commend the plain speak.
There is only one way to "talk" to the Taliban and that is with a gun pointed between their eyes. I know the mindset well enough that we would not be able to change their minds. In the good old days when muslim empires ruled do you think people like Sultan Suleiman, the magnificent, tried to "talk" to people who took up arms against the State? No sir, the Janissaries were dispatched and the rest is history.
Indeed a brilliant piece of writing. The topic selected is really an issue which has surprised us all. But only few have the capability to highlight it & Mr. Farrukh Khan Pitafi has done it beautifully. Hats off to u sir! & congratulations to Tribune for such a renowned anchor & writer as contributor on their panel.
@pasha: Why not? He is a very talented young-man with excellent critical skills and a sharp eye on the events. I always found him precise, objective, and analytical. Keep up the good job Farrukh.
@Concerned: The Afghan Taliban is seeking "strategic depth" in Pakistan from the Tajiks.
If talks can resolve why not but only worry one could have is are the people of pak aware of the content of the talks and ready to accept it.Collective decision by all the political parties and intellectuals of Pakistan will do the trick.
Collision is inevitable, jump out or where helmets and seat belts...
A very logical and true commentary about Taleban by the writer for whom I have a lot of respect since I have read many of his well penned articles in Daily Times. Well, talking to Taleban may not be a very bad idea if they could be persuaded to shun violence and join the main stream. However, the worst part is that nobody knows the agenda of talks between the deep state and TTP and what all compromises are being made to sign the peace accord since this outfit has declared that they would want the whole country to come under Sharia as their only condition.
@Roflcopter:
Well, begin with the very first thing that's wrong and then proceed to the second and so forth.
@Roflcopter: Agree 100%. @Mirza: Do you do this to tick us off or what?
Patafi....i never could imagine you to write such great piece...its worthy of all praise and the questions raised therein must be responded.......u hit the nail at its head...sahee...
Very factual article you have written a good piece of writing , in todays world media can change the ideology but problem is that even in media these type of view are propagated I wont name But look at news channels night discussion some anchors who support the belief of well reputed channels n meet with taliban leaders, secondly the opinion of those who rr against taliban is not aired , thnks to tribune for publishing this article , moreover pak agencies have similar state of mind bcoz of general zia era therefore still extremist elements are still get protection and moving in cites freely
@Roflcopter: So You say "so much wrong in this article I don’t know where to begin." That's it!, nothing more to add! If you want to comment about this artilcle, then please tell us "whats wrong" or we may all think you really have nothing constructive to say!
I am afraid there is no hope - if all Pakistanis want to live in a Sharia ruled country then so be it. Only please for heaven's sake do not take your neighbours with you - though even that is a vain hope.
All the taliban apologists quote that while US has decided to talk to Taliban, why cant we. They basically forget that the US has decided to talk after killing OBL, has decided to talk to get out ot Taliban land, lock stock and barrel, has decided to talk so that they can keep away from the monsters, has decided to talk after giving Pakistan as a prize to the Taliban. But Pakistani wisemen have decided to talk so that the monsters can come home and take over the country in the name of peace to make Pakistan into pieces.
It was the vice president that said the controversial Taliban lines you reference. It's very different in terms of what it means as far as the course of actual political action. Not better/worse/insignificant. Different.
thank you for bringing out the truth to us who still believe in what media feeds us day in day out.
It is true that the mainstream narrative in Pakistan is that the Taleban are liberating Afghanistan from foreign occupation. And I agree, the blowback from supporting religiously-motivated militancy is the radicalization of the Pakistani masses the effects of which are very apparent today. Nevertheless, the rationale for resolving the Afghan conflict through dialogue aims to counter this trend, to remove the need for the 'Afghan Jihad'. The Taleban's ideology was never popular in isolation, they took Kabul with our help, not through popular support - (read up on the rise of the Taleban). In the context of war and conflict they are freedom fighters. Extremism always arises through conflict, resolve the conflict and the problems with their irrational ideology can be exposed - this will happen, history is a testament to this fact. The current strategy appears to appease the extremists, at great cost to the nation, I perhaps in the hope that once the conflict is resolved, corrective measures can be taken to address this problem. People find solace in extremism as a result of war, oppression, poverty et al. Education, jobs, justice for the Pakistani populace and a complete review of Pakistan's misguided strategic policies are required once the Afghan chapter is closed. And I think that is the prevailing view in the sharply-rising 'alternative' political force in Pakistan. A sound one, if you ask me. No one likes self-righteous gunmen.
Can you please explain more about the claim you made about the Abbotabad Commission? Do you mean it was not Osama and that all these claims by USA, the guilty silence of Pakistan Army, and the verification by Zawahiri and other Al-Qaeda leaders was a circus?
@Falcon: There is a better way to escape the inevitable. Leave this country if you can and as fast as possible. The slide to militancy in our country is now irreversible.
Very true, cannot thank you enough for being logical and truthful. A rare commodity in Pakistani media.
Until and unless credible Muslim scholars thoroughly and publically refute the Taliban/Al Qeada ideology of hatred, intolerance, and endless religious war, extremism will continue to flourish and find disasterous expression in Islam.
State policy dictated by security concerns, exploited by defense industry promoting religious extremism funded by obscurantist mindsets pushing their regional agenda. Basically, we have made so many compromises, slept with so many demons that it is now become part of our fabric and it's difficult to differentiate between fact and fiction. Well said sir, please keep writing.
Sir Ji. You can write such op-eds 365 days a week for next 10 years, but it won't solve our problems. What our brightest folks need to do is look at the systematic factors that are creating vaccum for extremist influence to grow in the society and propose solutions instead.
so much wrong in this article I don't know where to begin.
Very good, Sir.
Talibanization of Pakistan is the true culmination point of two nation theory which discouraged diversity and promoted intolerance. How can you tame the mullahs by invoking Jinnah’s Pakistan which itself was born out of communal massacres and migrations of millions motivated by religion