Taliban per se not our enemy: Joe Biden
Biden suggested the Taliban only represented an inherent threat if it allowed al Qaeda to strike against the US. “That’s critical. There is not a single statement that the president has ever made in any of our policy assertions that the Taliban is our enemy because it threatens US interests,” he said.
Even after a surge in US troops in Afghanistan has pushed Taliban militants out of much of their southern stronghold, the group’s intentions regarding peace talks remain unclear.
A senior Taliban commander, speaking after US officials’ description of the peace process was published on Sunday, denied the movement was engaged in talks with the US.
“Our position on talks remains the same. All occupying forces have to leave Afghanistan. Then we can talk,” the commander told Reuters from an undisclosed location.
The Taliban might be denying taking part in initial discussions to shore up morale among fighters on the ground.
Meanwhile, a key Republican US senator warned against negotiating with the Taliban, illustrating the risk the Obama administration is taking by considering a prisoner transfer as part of a bid to end the Afghan war. US officials told Reuters a transfer of Taliban prisoners from the Guantanamo Bay could be one confidence-building measure.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 21st, 2011.
COMMENTS (69)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1732105641-0/BeFunky-collage-(78)1732105641-0-270x192.webp "bill clinton claims trump s cabinet picks demonise those with a good education")
1732518687-0/Copy-of-Untitled-(78)1732518687-0-270x192.webp "human impact causes 31 5 inch shift in earth s axis")
So when is Joe Biden joining Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf ? IK was right all along ...
What truly is in your mind,Mr.Biden?
Biden's right. If anyone of the people commenting here had read up on how and why the war started, it started because Mullah Omar's government was refusing to hand over Osama bin Laden. Al-Qaeda was US's enemy, NOT the Taliban. It was NEVER the Taliban. The Taliban only came into the picture because they were defending Al-Qaeda.
For those of you who actually want to find out how the war started, read Mullah Zaeef's "My Life with the Taliban". This guy was the Afghanistan's ambassador to Pakistan and almost all Pak-US-Afghan communication happened through him.
USA or USAMA...no difference !!!!!!
This is an attack on Taliban's identity...one can ask to his boss...who the hell I'm? whom Biden is talking about?
@Hu Jintao: Shock for what exactly ? You get so easily entertained and as you prove again and again, instead of focusing on what the Afghan feels about this news you are worrying about what Indians feel about this news ......haha....dude your life revolves around what Indians feel. Rest assured your life is seriously boring.
Indeed, a transfer of the Taliban prisoners from Guantanamo back to Afghanistan could be seen as extending an olive branch to the Taliban and a way to win their confidence. It's time for a pragmatic solution to end the war there.
This is only a game of words. US presidential elections are across the corner and the Obama team wants to accumulate some credits under its belt on the last moment. The Iraqi withdrawal "apparently" went very well and "seems promising" for Iraq's future. The Obama team wants to use the Iraqi strategy in Afghanistan, essentially, by isolating the "good enemy" from the "bad enemy". In Iraq, they made a strategy of separating the Sunni militia and the Sunni population by making them side with the US and dropping their support for Al Qaeda, which worked out. They now want to do the same in Afghanistan by separating the Taliban from AlQaeda and turning the two against each other. Its a smart strategy. However, I am not sure if it will work in the case of breaking the Taliban-AlQaeda relationship.
@M omar: Those Taliban blow themselves up in their own homeland, I wonder what was a US soldier doing near him.
@Syed: They are around , just in a REALITY SHOCK. I heard It takes a while to recover if one is not used to it.
@vasan: Your comments belie the fact....the double standards of US. Now keep justifying the US ...the truth has come out.
There's no such thing as Pakistani 'liberal' commenters here. All the so-called Pakistani 'liberals' who usually pass comments are Indians posing as Pakistanis. It's funny to see how they've all disappeared.
Wow! I am just stunned now. If I was a Taliban commander, i would be the most happiest person alive. No matter what is your perspective - the truth is, Taliban has not only survived American onslaught but has also become a government in waiting in Afghanistan
well guys , 'po-let-ticks' is the name of the game. There is no enemy and for that sake, no firends in politcs. Things change overtime. So, yerterday
s enemey is todays friend. yuppie. We may be the next target. Enjoy the US drop scene.I am gobsmacked..flabbergasted..and speechless!!
No they are not enemies but actually Talibans are a new variety of very cuddly teddy bears. American kids would love to own one ;-)
Too late, Mr. Biden...too late to finally realize that. For the past decade the Americans kept sticking to their rhetoric that they are not gonna negotiate with the TERRORISTS....and now all of a sudden the terrorists turned out to be 'not-their-enemy'.
word with no meanings
confusing. maybe USA and Taliban are ganging up on Pakistan?
must be april fools, even though its not april, strange americans.
Joe Biden is pro-taliban. They should call him Joe Talibiden.
@Syed: My previous response was to show the falsehood of claims on both instances.
If you want to see Bharati reaction go to Times of India site. It is really fun read. Half of them have gone mad.
Indian trolls are hitting their head against the wall. MarkH, cautious,FAraz, RS JOhar and other Pakistani so-called liberals, we wish to see your comments here.
I think many commentators are confused. US declared AQ and OBL as the enemy and went to war against them. The taliban came on the firing line because they did not want to handover OBL & AQ and protected them. Once OBL is taken out, AQ is weakened, US is not concerned with Taliban at all because the Talibans oppose US only because US is in Afganistan. What is the problem with Biden's stmt ??
The Bharatis must be in shock now
"Taliban is not an enemy of America"......well,what should I say? But United States is not a friend of anyone.
Although USA will not commit, but this is their far more disgracing defeat then Vietnam. What do you expect when you interfere in an uninvited territory ? Congratulations to Afghan people soon you will see the foreign boots off your land.
Who is the new enemy Joe?
If blowing up american soldiers by taliban suicide bomber is friendship act then yes . .
What an early realization
Pro-America Pakistani liberals are now thrown into a state of deep confusion.
Another Taliban Khan
Certainly has to be the Joke of the year2012 ..
Yeah, and the Japanese were our friends in WWII, that whole Pearl Harbor thing was a mistake. The Japanese thought they were bombing China. How this man ever got elected to ANY office is beyond me.
wow.......amazing
Why the helll have you been yelling on Pakistan to act against haqqani network. Yesterday they were threat to your security. Today they are NOT. Tomorrow you will acknowledge you were defeated.
It took decade,thousands innocent lives,around US$3 trillion to know that Taliban is not enemy of US.What a joke by the lone super power of the world? Sane voices of the world need to unite to harness the bull by horns.
uh oh ! Where thy indian trolls be ? :O
Bharatis like cautious got to say anything now?
We are fighting the Taliban because (1) they sheltered and still support al Qaeda, which launched attacks on us killing 3,000 people; (2) they continue to make terrorist attacks on our forces, NATO forces, the Afghan government, and thousands of innocent Afghan and Pakistani people; (3) they demolish culture and education; (4) they enslave women; and (5) they refuse to stop any of these activities. Under the circumstances, we must and should fight them. We will stop when they stop and agree to stay stopped.
If Taliban and US are not enemies of one another, why is Pakistan invollving itself on US side ? Joe Biden's statement is a clear indication that Karzai will be cut loose and Taliban will be free to fight the current regime which will be without American support. The mighty US has learned the lessons that technology or hubirs is not going to help it in Afghanistan. Now is the time for Pakistan to play her cards wiselly in Afghanistan.Americans will be gone soon but Taliban will be there for along time.
@Roflcopter: oh I don't know, how about not skipping things out of convenience? The US isn't Pakistan. They don't bend over and take it when people try to kill them and be counter productive to their goals. You never do say much of anything intelligent. I usually ignore you but this one was just way too easy.
Same like Iraqi were not American Enemies... they left over 1.5 Million civilian + 15000 military death.Just imagine If they were real enemies :)
now i really don't know if Rebecca Black and Justin Bieber remain on my list of the top 3 most idiotic people. This guys deserves all the spots! :P
During a seminar at Arizona States University, USA, participants; both students and the think tanks around, were shocked when I said that the only solution to war in Afghanistan was an unconditional apology of the US and it's allies to the people of Afghanistan, especially Taliban, who were punished for no crime. US is coming to it sooner than I had anticipated. Good news: Pashtuns are extremely generous in forgiving it's worst enemy, when the enemy concedes defeat and apologies :)
But you are their enemy now so good luck!
What a confused world we live in. The Taleban are no friend of Pakistan that's for sure. Perhaps, Biden remembers that the West had a big hand in creating the elements that became the Taleban when they used these people to defeat the Soviets in Afghanistan. They like to dump them on Pakistan whereas in reality the region was abandoned by the West after the Soviets were ousted and the world left Pakistan to clean up the mess. The US now understands they have to deal with all players in the region but imagine the flak if such a statement had come from Pakistan.
I hope Musharraf and other pro-war pakistanis read this and LEARN how the biggest superpower of the modern World deals with an enemy it has been fighting for over a decade! This is how goals are achieved and not by fighting a war that kills over 34000 of your people! We joined this war with the fear of a conflict with Mighty USA and now the Mighty USA is tactfully escaping from this war leaving us in a mess! Imran Khan... You better end this war please! We trust u with it!
now friends?
It seems that they are setting the pretext for moving into the next phase of negotiations with Taliban.
If you can't defeat your enemy in a decade, make it your friend.
ET you have been holding back this item, TOI had this out yesterday and Bhartis are crying their heart out at that site. I'm waiting for the reaction of that crowed on this site!!!
Truth Can’t Be Hidden, thats what Pak is saying
U turn hoo tou Aisa!!!
Say what??
hahahahhahaah after ten years enemy is friend and friend..............................
Mr Biden you had the whole world fooled, but happy to hear that you are willing to reach out
so Mr. Biden, would you mind telling us what the whole war against Taliban thing is about then?
Well I guess all those canards about Pakistan 'running with the hares and hunting with the hounds' stand debunked ...
Time for the Pakistani 'liberals' and our Indian visitors to start screeching at the US for once, instead of constantly berating Pakistan's military and intelligence service.
hahahahaha this a joke right? so why have they been fighting Taliban? and in the process are also responsible for the deaths of thousands of innocent people.