KARACHI:
The Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) has deferred all talks of an electoral alliance for now, but the party is confident it will be able to give political parties a headache by challenging key constituencies, especially in Karachi.
PTI officials say influential tribal leaders in Sindh are supporting the party, and it has a presence in Hyderabad and Jacobabad as well. The party plans to field candidates from all constituencies in Sindh, including Badin, a stronghold of ex-Sindh home minister Dr Zulfiqar Mirza. This could potentially make for an interesting competition, as the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) also plans to contest the Badin constituency. “We have to give people a choice,” party spokesperson Dawa Khan Sabir said, when asked if it would not be easier for the party to concentrate on a few constituencies.
But it is the provincial capital of Karachi where it claims it can already smell success. Sabir says the party expects to win at least three National Assembly (NA) seats and nine Sindh Assembly (PS) seats in areas where they have pockets of support or believe that the competition won’t be that strong.
The majority of these constituencies are currently held by the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) and the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM). One of these is NA 250, currently held by the MQM’s Khushbakht Shujaat, which covers the Defence and Clifton areas. The PTI recently held a celebratory rally of sorts in Clifton and managed to bring out at least 400 to 500 people.
In 2002, for NA 250 the Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal (MMA) beat the MQM’s Nasreen Jalil and the PPP’s Mirza Ikhtiar Baig. In 2008, Baig ran for the seat again, but was beaten by Shujaat.
The PTI also plans to win in a related constituency, PS 113, which is held by the MQM’s Askari Taqvi. This back-and-forth indicates that the PTI may be able to get a foot in the door, but that depends on the kind of candidate fielded by the Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) or the five other parties that formed the MMA. While the MMA has not been recreated as yet, the JI has said that it will form an alliance to contest the next elections.
The other seat the PTI is eying is NA 251, held by the MQM’s Waseem Akhtar and its corresponding provincial assembly seat PS 114, held by the MQM’s Rauf Siddiqui. These constituencies include PECHS and Lines Area. The MQM won NA 251 in 2002 as well but PS 114 went to Irfanullah Khan Marwat of the National Alliance, now of the Punjabi Pakhtun Ittehad.
PTI does not have a visible presence on the constituency level right now - or any experience of contesting local body elections. While PTI could shake things up in several areas of Karachi, it may be overestimating its chances. It also does not have a well known candidate as yet in Karachi who could potentially bring more voters on board.
NA 239 is one of the Karachi seats that the PTI believes is up for grabs. Currently held by PPP veteran Abdul Qadir Patel, it was won by Hakim Qari Gul Rehman of the MMA in 2002. Patel has served in the provincial assembly in the 1993-1996 period. The constituency includes Golimaar, Keamari and Baldia and parts of Lyari. The related provincial assembly seat (PS 89) has been held by the PPP’s Akhtar Hussain Jadoon since 2002. Defeating two experienced candidates - Patel and Jadoon - may be a challenge for the PTI, particularly because the vote bank of Lyari and the surrounding areas is split between the PPP and the MQM.
PS 91, which comprises Baldia Town, is currently held by the MQM’s Hanif Shaikh. It was also won by the MMA in 2002. Additionally, PS 116, won by the MQM’s Syed Sardar Ahmed in 2008, also went to the MMA in 2002. Thus, the religious party vote bank exists in some form here.
And indeed, even though there were widespread allegations of rigging in the 2002 elections, the success of the religious parties then may still filter down into the 2013 elections. The JI boycotted the 2008 polls as a result of which its vote bank split between the PPP and the Awami National Party.
For now, the Imran Khan-led party says its focus is on ensuring voter registration and encouraging people to go out and vote. It prefers to expend its energies here as it admits that it does not have the resources to transport voters to polling stations unlike other parties. Traditionally they arrange buses and even provide refreshments to voters. Whether the PTI’s legwork now translates into results on the ground will only be seen in 2013, when general elections are scheduled.
List of seats that the PTI is eyeing:
NA 239 Abdul Qadir Patel (PPP)
PS 129 Haji Muzafar Ali Shujra (PPP)
PS 89 Akhtar Hussain Jadoon (PPP)
NA 250 Khushbakht Shujaat (MQM)
NA 251 Waseem Akhtar (MQM)
PS 112 Mouqeem Alam (MQM)
PS 113 Askari Taqvi (MQM)
PS 114 MA Rauf Siddiqui (MQM)
PS 116 Syed Sardar Ahmed (MQM)
PS 124 M Alimur Rehman (MQM)
PS 91 M Hanif Shaikh (MQM)
PS 93 Ameer Nawab (ANP)
PS 128 Amanullah K Masood (ANP)
SOURCE: ELECTION COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN WEBSITE
Published in The Express Tribune, November 29th, 2011.
COMMENTS (53)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
No one can split MQM vote Rock MQM Jiye Mutahida , We are with you
I support MQM because of people like Mustafa Kamal!
@mansour: PTI is full of lotaas! I think you havent read that SMQ soft stance towards PMLN, he is vying to get the best price in the house. PTI is really Lota Tehreek Insaaf now!
@mansour:
People said PTI is full of Old Lottaaaass . Yes . They do. PTI will take more Lotttaaas on the instruction of their Masters.
@babar:
People of Pakistan like change but not change of faces .
@shaid-fss:
The people of Karachi is literate and politically awared. The biased attitude of IK towards Karachi Cricketers - Karachites will not forget.
@Starboy:
My Korangi - Friend . IK with the help of Establishment - Ex IJI - Tokra - Lota Party is dreaming to snatch the MQM constituencies. MQM is a political force backed up by Haq Parast Awam and has taken and passed the challenges in past and will be succesful in future. MQM is a movement, a philosophy and an idealogy.
PTI has proved to be the Latest Tokra of opportunist , feudal and Herarchical politicians gathered to snatch the power by force, money and loot.
Stay Tuned !
@Hassan: Pakistani, just watch how much more political garbage will be collected by Khan.....You already lost Tehmina doltana.Becouse of ur leadership.
Yes, becouse you people made my Birth city an ethinic war Zone..... @Pakistani:
@Syed: I think whatever ANP/PAC did in last 8 years was exact same as MQM has been doing for last 25 years. Ethnic sympathies and Terror are the most lethal combination of "love and hate" in Karachi politics and its very very effective if you see it from parties point of view. thats why its been adopted by these groups in recent times.
and If PTI grabs even 1 provincial or National seat from Karachi that must be appreciated bc in this Dirtiest mode of politics where almost 3500 people were killed just in the name of (maintaining Party Control on the areas) in last 4 years its very tough to beat such parties without having terrorist wing.
@ pakistani
I often wonder the same thing. I mean Karachi is not a conquered province of Pakistan, is it? I wonder this because Karachi is pretty much the only place on Pakistan that is ruled by everyone but people living in it
What I said is based on what I have seen in Lahore. First it was only 'Vote Bhutto ka' or vote 'Sher ka vote' now theres also Imran Khan. People dont give a tuppence about their candidate which I think needs to change. No disrespect to anyone from Lahore but they should look at their candidates before voting
My view is that PTI will manage provincial seat from Karachi, which is currently held by ANP, and that would really be a good Omen for people of Karachi in general and Pakhtuns of Karachi in particular because ANP for last 8 years has been trying to provocate a ethnic divide in Karachi in order to lure Pukhtuns to vote for them, This can be reversed by PTI, And i look forward to it. Another thing I am looking fwd to is the Seat of Liyari going out of PPP and Mirza, it may require seat adjustment between MQM and PTI but this thing can be achieved if MQM decides not to contest from there and support PTIs candidate.
@Usman Toronto: Good thing you're in Toronto.
@Hassan: I don't know why some karachites are so hostile towards lahore. Last I checked its part of the same country. I know you guys love your MQM with all your heart but even die hard fans have to see how they have blinded their constituency by placing a selfish precedent. Time now is for the betterment of Pakistan not karachi, not lahore, but Pakistan.
I am a Karachite and I would support MQM. Period.
Balochistan is still waiting for you Imran..
@Adeel Ahmed: Let me clarify here it is Mohajirs and not Karachiites who have always voted on ethnic lines. The Mohajir votes that went to the religious parties were on the basis of ethnicity as the leadership of these parties is predominantly Mohajir. It is these same votes that were cast in favor of MQM. Mohajirs are mostly lower middle class and by definition are conservative. Therefore it is highly unlikely that they would vote for liberal secular candidates.
The PTI is confused; the crowds that they pull to their rallies are young liberal and upper middle class, while Imran Khan positions himself as a moderate fundamentalist.
@Hawk
If MQM claims to be the largest mandate holding party of Urban Sindh it says on the bases of ground realities and historical facts. MQM has won 8 elections straight in last 30 years while Khan is dreaming to replace MQM by doing nothing except "Big Promises and Golden Dreams". Yes, the leader is in London but the roots exist in Pakistan....and that makes the whole difference. If Khan needs to replace MQM, he must have to show some roots and party structure in Karachi...
P.T.I, so far is zero in Karachi against the Mountain of work M.Q.M has provided to their voters and supporters without any discrimination.And for educated voters of Karachi it is very easy to undestand what is cooking behind the curtain. If, I.S.I forcely push PTI for victory then My suggestion for Karachi people is to help each other P.P.P. And M.Q.M verses PTI (I.S.I).
So writers and Imran Khan supporters are sure they can only hit those seats on the bases of ethnicity .... Long live change than where is Party for Pakistani thing gone, best of luck with your racist attitudes, Pakistan Zindabad.
The naivety of PTI leaders and supporters is quite amusing. I dont understand how you can win without a party structure on the ground.
Karachi is not Lahore where people vote on the name of the leader of a particular party. Nearly everyone I know looks at the candidate a particular party has for the seat and most need to meet the candidate to vote for him.
I also do not understand how getting 400 people out for a rally assures someone of that seat and that seat all consists of the areas of PNT Colony, Hijrat Colony, Railway Colony, Dehli Colony, Arambagh all the way to Pakistan Chowk and even area around Electronic Market.
@ M.Bilal voter turnout was 40% last election and even 50% in certain seats. So kindly dont patronize us.
@shaid-fss:
You should be ashamed of calling yourself pakistani, just call yourself karachite or mohajir. But dont embarass Miandad he wasnt karachite he was Pakistani and so are rest of us. This ethnic divide is breaking up country. After 64 years are u still mohajir or pakistani. Pakistan was choice which your forefathers made so try to make this land pure and be united
Winning any seats from Karachi is definitely a very tough ask! With very strong loyalties, mainly based on ethnic grounds, it is virtually impossible to change the voting patterns. Even a party like PPP had to live with the fact that with all their dominance in Sind, they stand no chance of making any inroads in Karachi. Having said that, PTI has embarked upon a journey to re-ignite 'Pakistaniat'. Message to all is to please think of Pakistan before you vote and not only for your mohallah, street or city. Our survival and revival hinges on national reform and not on strengthening the small pockets based on ethnicity. If you have an option that guarantees this other than PTI, please go ahead and do it as democracy respects difference of opinion. However, this difference should be based on the larger good of the nation. Best of luck everyone and Pakistan Zindabad.
@shaid-fss:
So this is how MQM captures votes of literate Kharachites...
i agree with mr mustafa. emergence of pti will help mqm as it will split its adversarys vote bank. Karachis votebank for MQM is rock solid. im saying this on stats
@"I only want to be PM": Perhaps the same Altaf bhai who himself has not entered Karachi since last 20 odd years!
@shaid-fss: Mr. Racist, Keep all your ill thoughts till yourself. Do not spread that. Any ways, any thing can be expected from those, who fill complete M. A Jinnah Road Karachi in support of our honorable president, Mr. Asif Zardari.
@Mazhar Abbas: yeah i can see that sense of maturity being driven from corridors of london !
@Bilal: will have to see 25 December Jalsa which will decide to which extent PTI has got its support in Karachi and the best fruits that PTI can get is those voters who never voted so this can be a Surprise !!! and to some extent UPSET for MQM.
MQM will be a very tough nut to crack, should focus on seats held by PPP and ANP
@Adeel Ahmed: Please ask your imran khan first to literate students of Punjab university, ofcourse if he is brave enough. By the way, If you remember (we know pti fan club has memory issue) imran khan has asked permission to enter karachi of Altaf by calling him few month ago.
Next step should be in Balochistan.
Come on IMRAN.... carry on striving for the better Pakistan... We are with you this time... plz forgive us for neglecting you so many years
Is it possible to contest elections in Karachi without a militant wing that has the ability to absorb hundreds of casualties?
InshaAllah truth will win, oppression will perish.
MQM voters are loyalist to their party and it won’t be easy to break that. It might help MQM in getting more seats specially in Suburbs ok Karachi where votes are divided between MQM/PPP & MMA. At the end of the day PTI will be helpful for MQM. Moreover there are no possible candidates of PTI in Karachi (as of now) which the people might look upto. My assumptions PTI will win a total of 15-20 NA seats , 8-10 from Punjab Urban Areas (mainly defeating PML-n) and 10 – 12 from KP (mainly defeating ANP and PPP).
Best of Luck PTI…..
@ Adeel Ahmed .literate Karachiites waiting for Imran ? ahem...........and where do you count us in buddy ?
The people of karachi is fed up with these militant parties. Imran u have a very good chance to win from karachi, because most of the people in karachi r educated & politically well aware. I am from korangi & i will be there for ur jalsa on the 25th of dec. Good luck.
There is no parameter of day dreaming. Who cares even if Khan sights 1000 seats in Pakistan. As for Karachi seats, I bet Khan with his feudal blended squad will never be able to win a single seat. Karachi's voter is the most mature and educated voter and he knows the value of a vote. To win Karachiites heart, one needs to deliver. Only promises wont make any difference.
IK have no chance .we know how he treated javed miandad . miandad is karachis hero .we didnot forget that .
People said Imran cannot make the hospital. He did. Then people said he will not be able to run the hospital. He did. Then people said he cannot make a world class private university. He did. Then people said there is no way PTI can fill up Minto Park at Lahore's rally. He did. People said PTI has no known candidates. PTI does now. People said SMQ will not join PTI. He did. Now people are saying he cannot break MQM's stronghold in Karachi. Just you wait and see-- he WILL Inshallah!
If all Karachite come out to vote.. I am sure PTI is going to win overwhelming no. of seats. The only reason that both MMA & MQM won in 2002 & 2008 elections respectively, was no interest by middle & upper middle class in electoral process. Guys pls. caste your vote by yourself, or else its gonna be casted in favor of KARACHI Party anyways and we need to stop that!
Election results of 2002 shows that there is "potential" to beat MQM in these constituencies. However, now its upto PTI that how to make in-roads. As Karachiite, this is sure that Literate Karachiite is just waiting for reasonable alternate.
Best of Luck Imran Khan............!
no chance to break mqm vote!
PTI is being naive. They are not going to shake up MQM that easily. Infact, they might be able to divide the votes of ANP, JI, JUI & PPI which may help MQM in some provincial assembly constituencies like PECHS, Golimar & Baldia areas. PTI effecting any NA seat in Karachi is completely out of question. Expecting to win a NA seat just b'coz they took out a 'celebratory rally' of 400-500 people (that included non-voting kids as well) is funny.
Would Love to see PTI getting these seates we need change now its essential for our survival as a nation and we need people to come out and vote to help get rid of these traitor and mafia type politicians !!
lolz....... Now mqm will say that "PTI is on the agenda of establishment, to break our "vote bank"...
iI think Imran Khan will have to field himself in any of constituency in Karachi Specially in Clifton/Defence Constituency if possible. in the ethnic politics of Karachi people despirately vote to their ethnic representative party bc the other candidates do not belong to their race/ethinicity or they don't cast their vote which ultimately goes into the basket of local powerful group who has strong hold on the polling station in the name of rigging (not every polling station) .and in recent years karachi has seen gang wars bw linguistic terrorist groups. So IMRAN KHAN has got good chances to grab massive votes as he is too far from ethnic politics and majority of literate people are fed up of this Ethnic cum terrorist type of politics.and if candidate is himself "IMRAN KHAN" that will also have great pressure to his opponent parties to find a player of same weightage.
If fair elections are held with army providing security to polling boths and voters..then imran would win even more seats.People are fed up of terrorist parties.The karachites also want change and Imran is the only guy whole nation is prepared and trust and back.
At least they admit they don't have the intent or the funds to buy out votes. That by itself is respectable!