Anna Hazare is the latest Indian icon after he staged a genuine hunger strike against corruption and brought the Manmohan Singh government to its knees. Pakistan, itself haunted by corruption, was impressed and looked around for its own Anna Hazare and found none. So, why not borrow?
There are jokes too. Since ‘anna’ sounded like a Punjabi word meaning ‘blind’ and ‘hazare’ meant ‘thousand’, some wags coined the phrase, ‘In Pakistan, hazaron annay’ (In Pakistan there are thousands of blind men).
But ‘anna’ in Marathi means ‘elder brother’. In Indian comedy movies ‘anna’ is also applied to the local mafia thugs, just as ‘bhai(log)’ (brother) in Urdu is applied in Mumbai to the underworld dons. But when applied to Altaf Hussain, it is meant to show respect.
But Kisan Baburao Hazare was not originally a Maratha. He was born in 1937 in Gujarat and follows the teachings of the great Gujarati leader Mahatama Gandhi. For his social services, he got the Padma Bhushan — the third-highest civilian award — for establishing a model village in Maharashtra.
Anna Hazare had a zigzag career. He got into the army and fought the India-China war in 1962. Three years later, he also fought the 1965 war with Pakistan and was ‘born again’ in the battlefield of Khem Karan. He decided to devote the rest of his life to serving people rather than the army.
The name Hazare stumps me. It has no etymology except that it is related to the Urdu word ‘hazar’ meaning ‘thousand’. There are a number of places named Hazara in South Asia. A whole region in Central Afghanistan is named Hazara.
The word is Persian and is a translation of the Mongol word ‘ming’ or ‘minggan’ applied by the Mongols to Central Afghanistan. First, this was the name applied to the military unit the Mongols stationed there. This military unit comprised a thousand troops.
Not far from Afghanistan, a part of Pakistan in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa is called Hazara, where people want their own province these days. In Punjab, too, a region used to be called Hazara, differentiated by its prefix, ‘Takht’.
The Mughals were half Mongols and followed Mongol practices, including creating army units of one thousand. No surprise, therefore, that India has a lot of Hazara-like place-names. Hindu names like Hazare and Hazarika are actually indicative of places of origin.
There is a Hazara in Chittagong in Bangladesh. And there is a Hazaribagh district in Jharkhand in India which people think means a thousand gardens. It could originally be a kind of camping ground for ‘thousands’ of troops.
If the word is ‘hazar’ (thousand) in Persian, it is ‘sahasar’ in Hindi.
We have the city of Sahasram in Bihar where the great Pathan ruler Sher Shah Suri was born and finally buried. Sahasram even has a Rohtas fort, which Suri duplicated in what is now Pakistan, near Rawalpindi.
How did Sahasram get its name? It is believed that a demon named Sahastrabahu (with thousand arms) lived near here from the age of Ramayana. This puts paid to our theory that it could come from the ‘thousand troop’ origin.
I am willing to accept that Sahasram and ‘hazar’ are cognate. And the great etymologist Shipley says the word thousand, itself is simply ‘swollen hundred’, just as thumb is ‘swollen finger’ and thigh is ‘swollen leg’.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 13th, 2011.
COMMENTS (69)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Anna Hazare and Hazar Dastaan and all about Balma & Selma....
Some interesting stuff on the topic of archeogenetics of south asia:
Recent work involving the reconstruction of an Ancestral North Indian chromosome indicates that the ANI population may have been more closely related to people from central and northern Europe than to people from the caucuses. Evidence is also emerging of indo-europeans moving out of indian subcontinent in prehistoric times as the Y-dna R1a1a*(M-173 and M-420) is found to be native in india while most of the eurasian indo-european sites shows the presence of relatively new R1a1a7 (M-458) [43]. However, genetic evidence has no bearing on the languages that these early groups might have spoken. Stephen Oppenheimer believes that it is highly suggestive that India is the origin of the Eurasian mtDNA haplogroups which he calls the "Eurasian Eves". According to Oppenheimer it is highly probable that nearly all human maternal lineages in Central Asia, the Middle East and Europe descended from only four mtDNA lines that originated in South Asia 50,000-100,000 years ago.
@Balma: Yes, you are right about that. I also feel the same way. Devngri channels the soul of our south asian languages most naturally.
Homa: I will certainly keep your advise in mind. On devnagri script, I have noticed it is more natural to write Urdu in Devngari script than in the current script.
Jeckyll and Hyde, lol
@Ali Tanoli: Okie dokie. I know there are some good quailty yoga teachers in PK who teach authentic yoga and meditation but dont know if they are trained to teach sanskrit as well. In usa, sometimes yoga instructors also go in for training in sanskrit, so the yoga peope would be your best lead i think. I know for sure they have sanskrit as a subject in dhaka university, so maybe karachi universities also offer it as a subject? You may want to check there. Also, if there is an indian cultural center or a bharatiya vidya bhavan branch run by the indian consulate in karachi, they may also have a class.
@ Balma, Thats a sad true u just said even last year in france they deported to Romania but one problem is here they dont wanna changed themself i have seen they more like to lived Niger life.
@ Homa ji, If Balma get some Sanskrit teacher in karachi PK, please let me know my adress is also from karachi so i can join him too,.
@Balma: When you start learning sanskrit, try to find yourself a good teacher who can guide you and can properly communicate the concepts and the conceptual connections. If you have a good quality teacher, sanskrit concepts become really easy because of its logical and geometric structural symmetry. The whole language is basically a sophisticated and systematic mathematical expansion of about 2000 primordial core etymons. The name Sanskrit comes from its definition: "samyak kritam samskritam," which translates as "that which has been created with consummate perfection is sanskrit," which hints at sanskrit being a "created" language. Mastery of the devanagari script would also be a very useful prerequisite for success in learning sanskrit.
By the way the hindi/urdu verb "karna" (to do, to make) and the english verb "create" also come from the same sanskrit etymon/root "kri" which is represented in "samyak kritam samskritam."
@Ranjit: The dravidian languages of today also have a claim to sanskrit as one of their co-substrata.
Mughals of India and Othman of Tukey both roots are in central asia both belong to Great house of Temour or called in Europe Timberland. and thats a reason in Ottoman time of rule they brought indian or Gypsies to work in there home and farms and they stays there.
@Ranjit: Thanks, Ranjit. Awesome input about Turkey, and very true how they are anomalous in the region. The turkish zone belongs to an aryran past.
@Ali Tanoli: Well, thank you Ali Tanoli. Thats very magnanimus of you.
Modern day Turkey (Anatolia) is an anomaly in the whole swath of the Indo-European language territory from India to Europe. Till around 10th century AD they were speaking an Indo-European language, very similar to their neighbors- Greeks. But they were invaded/occupied by Turkic speaking people from Central Asia in 10th century. And all Turks from present day Turkey adopted a new language -Turki (an Altaic language from Central Asia) and stopped speaking their mother tongue, an Indo-European language, over the course of some 50 years in 10th century AD. So you have Turkey whose neighboring regions are Indo-European speaking Armenia, Greece, Iran, and Kurdistan and who speak a language from Central Asia.
@Homa: I am not a serious student of history. But will check out the PBS documentary. Gypsies/ Romany people came from current Gujarat/Rajasthan area. And besides migrating from India to Europe, the Indian Gypsies (called Banjaras or Lambadi)they also migrated to Southern India - ANdhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu. And though some speak local language they also speak Lambadi at home. Essentially speaking an Aryan language in a Dravidian language territory. The Andhra Banjaras seems to have settled down and integrated with general population. The Gypsies in Tamil Nadu (Narikurava) have some ways to go. CHeck out the lick below http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narikurava
@ Balma, I agreed Urdu is saved today in indo pak region just because of Mullana sahabs,. @Homa, I wanna be your student in history lesson great job well done and this is true i met those gypsy of Romania and Balgharia they actully brought in Europe by Ottoman of TURKEY, first and then they stays there and these peoples still listen indian music and watch indian movies and called them self indians and and if you been there it doesnot feel u are in Europe. So English mess us lot worst than just lang.
Dear @Author,
You have really deviated from the corruption topic to etymology, but you did ask a real question. do we have our own Anna Hazare? I believe you do. He is a respectable not only in Pakistan but all over the world. He is Abdul Sattar Edhi, although it will be too much to ask from him, and he will be obliged to do. I personally believe that Ehdi Sahab must get a Noble Peace Prize also. He deserves it.
The word " hazar " in URDU means thousand .... the word " hazar " also means thousand in MARATHI ... which is anna's mother tongue ...... I don't know where anna was born ... but in 1937 ( you say he was born in gujarat ) .... maharshtra and gujarat were one state / region ...............
@Homa: I agree that there was no Aryan Invasion and that Aryan Invasion Theory was a British concoction to legitimise their own colonial occupation of India. I do however believe that Aryans did migrate into India from present-day Iran-Afghanistan (or Khorasan) area and mixed with the people already present (Dravidian speaking or whoever else was there) to create modern day Indians. And the Aryan migration into India was peaceful and not an invasion.
I do not believe that Aryans moved from India to Iran. But it was the other way round since pattern of migration since ancient times has been east-wards thru Khyber pass. How else can you explain the close similarity between Sanskrit and Avestan? And the similarity between old persian and old indo-aryan culture, language and gods?
And there are other people in the west of present-day Iran who are part of old aryan culture like the Kurds, Azerbaijani, Armenians, etc.
@let there be peace: Writing developed much later. Not sure of the history of writing but Kashmiri at one time was written in Sharda script(Gurumukhi script used for Indian Punjabi/close to Devanagari but not the same) and then after Muslim conquest the Kashmiri language writing was shifted to Arabic script. Don't know about Sindhi script but I am assuming same thing might have happened.
The sanskrit language of old Aryans remained the same because the Brahmin priests would learn and memorise the verses of the Vedas by heart and transmit it to their disciples, usually their sons or other Brahmins, who memorised the whole thing. So even before writing was developed, knowledge in ancient India, passed from one generation to next, in the old Sanskrit language of Aryans, just by rote memorization. The non-Brahmins, the majority of the general population were speaking other languages (generally called Prakrit languages), which evolved over time, for their daily use. And when writing came to India, the Sanskrit vedas were all written down in Devanagari along with Prakrit languages.
DISCLAIMER- I am not a historian so don't beat me up on the specifics or semantics
Tanoli, As Homa mentioned, this Aryans coming into the Indian sub-continent (and kicking out indus valley people) is not necessarily a true story. I once read somewhere that this theory was started and propogated by the English to justify their own rule over India.
By the way, I would like to thank Desi Mullahs and Bombay's movies for keeping Urdu alive until now, otherwise Pakistani burgers nay Urdu kee (fill in the blank) - if you know what I mean. And this is the only time you will find me praising mullahs of India and Pakistan:-)
Until recently I used to watch Indian movies to keep my Urdu alive....but now I have noticed that free style use of f and s words in english and chay words from Urdu in Indian movies is bit too much. The biggest idiots are some of the khans who are acting and directing movies. Horrible and terrible standards. I could handle 'zaleel' and 'kameenah' in Urdu movies but 'chay' words ??????
@expertz If Persian is similar to Sanskrut, did they have some different script originally? or are they using Arabic script from beginning? What is the script for Sindhi and Kashmiri? I have noticed Indian Sindhis and Kashmiris often use Arabic script.
@Ram Bharose Singh: The spanish esta is another cognate of sanskrit asti.
@Balma: I respect and congratulate you for your openness and progressive attitudue. Hopefully it will inspire others.
@Ram Bharose Singh: Look up "saptasindhu/sindhu saraswati". The aryan invasion theory has been conclusively debunked by current scholarship, both indian and western. The migrations actually happened out of india. There is plenty of genetic, linguistic and geological data available now that establishes this. Persia was certainly not the birth place of sanskrit. You may want to check out steven knapps books which have a lot of updated information.The english is, sanskrit asti and persian ast, german ist, latin est, are all cognates, derived from sanskrit AS root infinitive meaning "to be".
The central region of Afghanistan is actually called Hazarajat and the people inhabiting these areas are Hazaras.
@ Ram Bhrose singh sahab, Khorasan is old name of afghanistan when it was part of present day iran and most of aryan civilization also came from same area thats the reason when some one say north indian peoples this peoples are combination of afghan central asia, and persia to Ganga Kinare.
Sanskrit and Avestan (old persian) are almost the same because the people who spoke lived in the Persian-Iran-Khorasan area. Modern Pashto language (if you take out all the Arabic words) words and structure is similar to Sanskrit because the land of birth for both languages was Khorasan or ancient persia (of which present-day Afganistan was a part). I am not very familiar with either Sanskrit or Pashto but one thing that pops out is the word "ast" which means the same thing and used in a similar manner in both Sanskrit and Pashto
Homa: to be honest I have investigated formally learning Sanskirit in the past. Should do it seriously now! I believe my interst in learning similarities among langauges will make a little bit more open minded and a better person.
@Balma: I really hope you get an opportunity to study sanskrit dear balma, because as the substratum language for all indo-european languages and as a co-substratum language for many non indo-european languages it opens the door for the most amazing revelations.
Dee Cee, Thank you for the info on Daughter/duhitr/dukhtar.
Homa: thank you for correcting me on the location of dots. Important nuqtah/nuktah :-) Yes, I am familiar with dots above letters for 'n' sound etc.
Zeerah i thought came into Urdu from Arabic....And, I always thought Gujratis mispronounce it like as they do with "joom lens"....but, may be it is another example of a word's round trip and it's modification during it's journey:-)
@Balma: Sanskrit duhitri=daughter, and Sanskrit dauhitri=grand daughter, which morph into daughter, dukhtar, dotri, doti etc, in various languages.
Limiting myself to the topic the author started with - borrowing our Anna - to seed a change in Pakistan, let us remind ourselves that an "interaction" between any two beings requires contribution from both to further the purpose of the interaction. Pakistan is innately incapable of contributing anything to the interaction with Anna. Anna is a pacifist with great trust in non-violence of the Mahatma, Pakistan and Pakistanis have always been and continue to be antithetic to those ideas. Even if Anna goes to Pakistan, nothing much should be expected of the visit. Much grace is required in the "giving", very much more is expected in "receiving"!
@Khalid Ahmed (not the author):
Lokpal leads to another layer of bureaucracy. Larger the govt. ... more the corruption.
Corruption can be lessened if following steps are taken:
A. Increase of use of more technology by govt. for administrative jobs.
B. Provide people with more options so that people are not forced to pay more.
C. CBI already exists as ombudsman to tackle corruption at higher levels. Free CBI from political influence.
D. Hasten economic and administrative reforms.
Khaled Saheb, I really enoyed your article written in lighter vein. One thing I would like to add that during Anna Hazare's fast, many people including children came with slogans on posters- 'Main bhi Anna' to support his fast against corruption. I am doubtful if such a compaign would be successful in Pakistan since religious frenzy is more popular here than important issues like corruption or economy. These days, many are supporting Qadri, a self confessed killer and if he is released by the courts under immense pressure from clergy and lawyers, one may expect to see his supporters with slogans 'Main vi Qadri'.
@Author,
It is 'Sahasra' and not ' sahasar'. And it is a Sanskrit word and not hindi. Hope you could correct this for the benefit of the readers.
I was waiting for this article that sheds some lights on the term "Hazara" and clearing the confusion. There had been two misleading articles about people of Hazara (tribe) and Hazara division in Pakistan. The author of the article thought Hazara people of Afghanistan that are Shia are same people that lives in Hazara division in Northern Pakistan which is part of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and are Sunni. The people of Hazara (tribe) has Asiatic Mongoloid look that are Shia while people of Hazara division in North Pakistan has Pathan look and are Sunni. These are the two articles that are misleading. I wonder if Hazara killing in Quetta is a co-incident or they are victim of mistaken identity since there is a sharp rise in killing of Hazara people in Quetta after Osama's death as the terrorist believing Hazara people of Quetta are to be blamed for the death of Osama because they have similar name to Hazara division where Osama was residing at the time of his death.
http://www.srilankaguardian.org/2011/05/osama-bin-ladens-death-q.html
http://pakobserver.net/detailnews.asp?id=118937
Delightful article. Thoroughly enjoyed it.
@Balma:
"Devnagri script have modified devnagri for letters like ‘z’, ‘gh’ as in ghubaarah, and ‘kh’ as in khazana by adding dots above closest devnagri letters"
The dots in question, when used, are not placed above but below the various letters for the sake of denoting the borrowed non native sounds in modern hindi. However, none of them are really used commonly except for the one under the j to denote the z sound. The dot often seen above the letters on the other hand is the anusvara, an abbreviated version of the chandrabindu, and designates the nasal vowels n/m as in manch, kangan, paanch, ooncha, saamp, ganga, punjab etc.
Kind regards...
@Harsh Srivastava
Care to explain?
@Readergonecrazy: News flash--this article has been co-opted into a language discussion. Its no longer about corruption. Sorry if you are disappointed.
@Balma: Another intersting one for you -- hindi jeera, urdu zeera (cumin), ultimately from sanskrit jeeraka.
@Balma: "Duhitr" is a root word in Sanskrit from which the word "duhita"(daughter) comes. Sounds close to "daughter/dukhtar" to me. "Duhita" also means a "girl who milks (duh) cows". "Milking" is "dohan" in Sankrit, and I guess "dudh duhna" is still common in Urdu/Hindi. This relation between daughter and cattle points at the family roles in an agrarian society that might have created these words. :) On the Bengali "z" sound, it is common among the people from East Bengal or Bangladesh. I am not sure if it is because of huge Urdu/Persian influence on Bengali, or because of shift from dental "j" to palatal "z", as seen in "ch" to "sa", in general. But Sanskrit origin "j" sounds also get pronounced a "z" in Bangla sometimes, like "jani" (I know) is pronounced as "zani". However, standard/urban Bengali doesn't have the "z" sound except in personal preferences as in "roza/roja".
Ouch! I am from Bihar and was totally unaware of the origin of the name Sahasram. That has "degenerated" to Sasaram, which everyone, or at least most of us, believe was coined by Sher Shah Suri.
Dear Khaled,
Anna is a Maratha. In maratha there are family names like Hazare and Lakhe. I spent a lot of time in this region. It could be the indicators of wealth too.
A hazare might be proud of his thousands of gold coins he owns (maybe). A lakhe might be proud of his lakhs of rupees. This angle need to be reserched too.
better to focus on language these..as in the surrounding situation is getting quite worst...
Nice read, though took me nowhere.
@Balma: true, while sanskrit does not have the z sound, some indegenous languages do, to my knowledge. The z sound is not always due to muslim influence, but is more likely an indegenous development, at least in the examples i have for you. Take the word majha/mazha which means "mine" in Marathi. Some bengalis dialects pronounce the word aaj as aaz. Someone please correct me if i'm wrong. These are not my strong languages.
You are right quite right, Mr.Ahmed. The Sanskrit "sahasr" (or alternatively "sahasra") and the Persian "hazar" are indeed cognates, or rather, to put it more accurately, the sanskrit word is actually the etymon (the root) and the persian word is the derivative, its phonetic "distortion" or adaptation. The ancient Persians developed trouble pronouncing their S's over the course of time following their split from the source Vedic culture, the mother Saptasindhu Civilization, and notiable among the overall articulatory changes was one in particular which involved the replacement of the sibilant consonant S with the aspirate H (phonological shifts, both vocalic and consonantal, have also been established in the case of the evolution of the Romance Languages like French, Spanish and Italian out of Latin in much later periods of human history). The inability of the Persians/Avestans to pronounce the orginal sounds of the parent language pursuant to the split leads us to Sanskrit / Persian cognate (and false cognate) pairs such as Sindhu/Hindu, saptah/hafta (week ie seven days), sahasr/hazar, asura/ahura, saryu/haryu, soma/haoma etc. Please continue writing about such topics. They are fascinating. Thank you.
Please take away Hazare. We don't want him. His proposed solution will result in even more corruption. Sad.. extremely sad that people don't realize it. :(
Khalid sir, you are so good in telling a story. But I am running out of adjectives (complementary) to commend your articles. No, seriously you are a delight to our finer senses.
Dear Khaled Ahmed, Wonderful article as usual. My 2 cents - Sahasra is thousand in Sanskrit and the correct name of the said demon Sahasrabahu (with thousand arms) and not Sahastrabahu as mentioned in the article. Could 'Hazara' be derived from saHasra?
@Balma: there is no ‘z’ sound in sanskirit and languages derived from it
I'm no linguist but Marathi is Sanskrut/Prakrut derived language and it not only has 'z' but two different pronunciations each for 'z', 'cha' and 'j' (tongue touching hard palate and another with the tongue touching teeth).
I like Zigzag way of khalid sahab article battlefield of khamkaran Gujarathi jawan (unusal) and there are good hazara, bad hazara, good bhai, bad bhai log like good Taliban and bad bad taliban hahahahah good one way to go.
I lived about a mile from one Mr. Hazari Lal who was a shoemaker. One of my friends was Lakkhi Singh. One of the colleges on the University of Delhi is Kirori Mal college. I guess when a rupee meant something, people may have wished to be a Hazari (worth thousands) or Lakkhi ( worth one hundred thousand) or a Kirori(100 lakh).
Sir Naam mein kya rakha hai . . What is in a name . . Look at the man's body of work after his voluntary retirement from the army . . Actually India and Pakistan are totally different societies . . SO such peaceful BUT forceful methods such as Indefinite fasts or Hunger strikes will not work in Pakistan
@ Khalid Sahab Really true thank u.
I have been wondering of Anna Hazara's name since he became famous in Pakistan. I thought he was from a family like Nehrus who had adopted (what we now refer to as) Muslim type names. Also, there is no 'z' sound in sanskirit and languages derived from it such as Bengali, Panjabi, gujrati, Hindi-Urdu etc. Urdu of couse has added alphabets for z, gh, and kh. Muslims who write in Devnagri script have modified devnagri for letters like 'z', 'gh' as in ghubaarah, and 'kh' as in khazana by adding dots above closest devnagri letters. For example, 'z' is written as 'ja' with dot. All desi langauges are going to die, baaqi bachay nah kuch, rahay naam khudaa kaa ( I mean English kaa)
Khaledji -- Delightful, as always!
I think you are getting obsessed with Etymology now, Article started with corruption in Pakistan and then ended with Hazaraa and how their name was coined.