TODAY’S PAPER | November 22, 2026 | EPAPER

Reset: recycle or revolution?

.


Ali Hassan Bangwar November 22, 2026 3 min read
The writer is a freelancer and a mentor hailing from Kandhkot, Sindh. He can be reached at alihassanb.34@gmail.com

For quite some time now, the people have found themselves plunged into an abyss - a well-acquainted abode - and have experienced a sense of déjà vu, having been there so many times before. At the same time, they have hoped for and invoked the divine for a future they deserve, only to find the heavens falling upon them - yet again. Given all the rallying cries and repeated betrayals, the lingering glimmer of hope in the form of a potential reset seems destined only to add further gloom at the end of the tunnel. Wouldn't it?

Throughout the roughly eight decades of its existence, the fate of the nation has passed from one critical juncture to the next, paused only momentarily to prepare for the one that follows. This recurring pattern might seem beyond human agency - almost like a miracle, or something incited by external forces and the follies of internal factions. Its repetition in almost identical cycles, nevertheless, suggests a design – one that plunges the country's system and its people into the abyss, only to be reset by a sacrifice, or, more aptly, the scapegoating, of one of the key players.

The sacrificial group - which until recently was largely responsible for the country's plunge into the abyss, and which has been stripped of relevance in the eyes of the people - is momentarily sidelined and forced to cede a little space. That space is swiftly claimed by the factions that waited in the wings, scrutinising from the supposed opposition.

Thereafter, the sidelined group is left to cry foul, play the victim, shift the blame onto its ostensible opponents holding the reins, and scrutinise those in power. This scrutiny essentially serves three purposes. First, it makes the ousted group look better and helps it regain relevance, however unwarranted. Second, it tarnishes the credibility of those holding the reins, paving the way for the ousted group's eventual return to power. Third, it perpetuates the recycling of these factions on the backs of the people through a tacit complicity.

The brief interludes of stability that perpetuate the cycle always carry a whiff of optimism for the naïve or sentimental masses - and even for those who are politically awakened. The public is not entirely at fault for perceiving these episodes of scrutiny by recycled groups as a sacred revolt or a genuine road to revolution. Having lived their lives in manufactured darkness, the people naturally deem every beacon, however illusory, to be their salvation.

This has been the case throughout the country's history, where an erstwhile villain is rehabilitated and hailed as a saviour - until stripped of that sacred cloak by the next round of staged scrutiny. Tellingly, this mutual scrutiny of past misdeeds is no mere coincidence; it is anchored at the very core of the design that endlessly recycles these factions.

Through such scrutiny, each supposed revolt may ignite hope in the long-betrayed masses, yet it only worsens the fate of the country and its people. Every contrived round of scrutiny - every staged revolt anchored within the system - is merely a reverse revolution: a step backward dressed up as progress. So the next time you hear fiery speeches or mudslinging from within the system, be worried - not optimistic.

Those who genuinely wish to serve the masses are either barred from doing so or driven into quiet desperation. The day real change arrives will be the day that eclipses these planted and supposed revolutionaries - an act the entrenched parties will never undertake, and no angels will descend from heaven to perform. Alternatively, it will be the day the system outlives its utility and succumbs to its own decay, paving the way for a just and equitable Pakistan.

The rival factions facilitate one another's scrutiny and trade insults without compunction, for this is where their true expertise lies. Today, Pakistan's so-called reawakening - whether championed by intellectuals, civil society or political parties - amounts to little more than a bargain for a greater share of power.

Therefore, calls for a reset should be seen more as SOS signals than as moments of relief, for they aim only at readjusting and bargaining for higher stakes. It is neither a reset nor a revolution - merely the same cycle, renewed.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ