When money moves, who is accountable?
.

Reports about an alleged online gambling and money-laundering network have brought digital payments under scrutiny. Investigators reportedly traced transactions through payment-linked accounts, while JazzCash and Easypaisa aggregator services faced disruption. The allegations remain under investigation. But the episode raises a question extending beyond those involved: when money moves through several institutions, where does responsibility lie?
A digital payment may involve a customer, merchant, aggregator, technology platform and regulated financial institution. The process appears seamless, but involves distinct functions and relationships.
A platform may introduce a merchant to a bank; a technology provider may connect systems to a payment gateway; an aggregator may process collections for several businesses; and the bank may maintain the receiving account. These roles are not interchangeable. Merchant onboarding is not account opening. Providing a payment interface does not make a technology provider the holder of customer funds. Nor does a transaction passing through a bank's infrastructure mean every function was performed by that bank.
The legal position therefore depends on what each participant actually does and the obligations attached to that activity. Commercial labels cannot, on their own, determine regulatory responsibility.
The SBP's Rules for Payment System Operators and Payment Service Providers provide a regulatory basis for payment gateways, transaction processing, routing and switching. The SBP's July 2025 merchant operations framework and Consolidated Customer Onboarding Framework also seek to facilitate access while maintaining safeguards.
Requirements should reflect the risks involved. A merchant, marketplace and aggregator collecting for several businesses do not necessarily present the same risks. Their onboarding and monitoring should account for their operations. Failing to distinguish between them may impose unnecessary obligations or leave gaps in oversight.
The question becomes more difficult when functions are outsourced. Banks increasingly rely on third parties for software, payment interfaces and data processing. Outsourcing may improve efficiency, but it does not absolve a regulated institution of statutory responsibilities. A service provider, meanwhile, may have obligations arising from its own role and conduct, beyond simply maintaining software or connectivity.
Agreements should address customer verification, transaction data, suspicious activity escalation, record preservation and regulatory cooperation. They can allocate responsibilities, but cannot displace obligations imposed by law.
Even a clear allocation of responsibility will mean little if information does not reach those expected to act. A bank may maintain the account, an aggregator understand the merchant's business, and a technology provider hold transaction-level data. Without effective reporting and escalation, suspicious activity may remain divided across institutions, with no one seeing the full picture.
Oversight must continue beyond onboarding through risk assessment, transaction monitoring and clear escalation procedures, ensuring information is acted upon and responsibilities do not disappear between institutions.
Businesses also need regulatory certainty. Aggregators, marketplaces and fintech companies must know the conditions under which they can operate. Enforcement should be firm where wrongdoing is established, but reflect the participant's conduct and role. One merchant's actions should not define an entire business model.
Pakistan's digital financial infrastructure will increasingly depend on the confidence businesses and consumers place in the institutions supporting it. That confidence requires clear responsibilities, effective oversight and a framework capable of adapting as the industry evolves.
As digital payments continue to expand, are policymakers ensuring that accountability is built into the system from the outset, or are they still relying on it to be established after a problem emerges?

1727268465-0/Untitled-design-(42)1727268465-0-208x130.webp)












COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ