TODAY’S PAPER | November 20, 2026 | EPAPER

In search of nationhood

.


Shahzad Chaudhry November 20, 2026 5 min read
The writer is a political, security and defence analyst. He tweets @shazchy09 and can be contacted at shhzdchdhry@yahoo.com

Two hundred and fifty million people, defensible boundaries and a veritable record of overcoming multifarious challenges prove the viability of a state. Pakistan has survived external aggression, calamities and an inconsistent political environment at home. Where geography and the people intertwine, a state is born. From 1947 till date, through baby steps and negotiating monumental events, it has found its calling. There was an attempt to force an early fermentation of nationhood through prescriptive ideology and imposed nationalism (Pakistaniat), but only when each aspect of statehood had been tested did geography and the people find relevance in the imagination. Eighty years later, we have arrived at the phase of defining our nationhood.

It helps to compare with another state founded in similar circumstances and almost similar challenges – Israel. Carved out by external intervention, despite its ideological idiosyncrasies that most of the world disagrees with, it has had to fight for its viability. It is now fighting its pariah manifestations – a consequence of its conduct and devastating policies – to find global acceptability. Pakistan has been far luckier, and the world at large accepted its institution as an independent state as a natural consequence of the passing of colonialism. The size of the population and their unique socio-religious culture that formed the new country were significant enough to gain them their right to an independent homeland. Subsequent events in this young nation's experience have only reinforced that belief. Pakistan is here to stay.

Insecurities of initial formation and unique historical experience now bridged – a perpetual adversary in India, which has done all it could to decimate the young nation, overwhelmingly blunted – the next steps to a more assured nationhood are in the offing. Looking back, only time would have brought us to the realisation that, from securing the state, the emphasis must now move to nation-building. To many, and rightly so, we could have endeavoured to do both in parallel, and there were sporadic efforts in that direction, but those stalled rather early because of weak political intent and poor conception. Inadequacies of leadership and lack of commitment to place people first came in the way. Now the people are seeking their moment of attention. They have been neglected far too much, for far too long.

For eighty years, the emphasis has been on the state. Pakistan's precarious financial state testifies to how the state has been callous in its affairs and immersed in its own viability and well-being. The entire debt stock of the nation, external and internal, for the most part has been centred around what came first to the state, not the people. Worldwide, as people begin to seek changes to traditional state structures and their policies, the sentiment finds wider resonance on the back of a more connected world of instant communication and social media. India's Cockroach Janata Party, as well as the youth movements in Nepal and Bangladesh, stand as testimony to this global trend.

The gaping hole in Pakistan, as has been evident over time, is the disconnect between the people and the state. The state is absent from people's lives, and when it does engage, it is mostly through populist rhetoric and symbolic projection. People's day-to-day lives rarely change. Big-ticket projects are announced, but if ever concluded, they serve the state and its principals. The gap has thus become increasingly difficult to bridge without wholesale restructuring of our governance and political systems. The people are increasingly being pushed into desolation and hopelessness as their cries of neglect and disappointment echo sharply.

It needs immediate course correction. The four-province state structure has turned voracious in appropriating resources for its own well-being. The belief that devolution would enable local governments at the lowest level, with fiscal and administrative authority to influence the lives of the common man per their needs, failed to materialise. All resources were appropriated to the provincial heads and their governments instead. Local governments were defied and denied in institution and in their efficacy. Where reluctantly instituted, those were neutered in their function by debilitating legislation. Such manipulation of democratic authority has not only crucified the spirit intended in the 18th Amendment, but has also distorted the nation-state construct. Because of such excesses of political masters, Pakistan is threatened with a nation-state collapse.

The dual track, thus, of ensuring full devolution to the lowest level of governance through representative local bodies, and downsizing the provinces to their more optimal levels given the vast geographical and population spread of the country, is the right course. That is real democracy – of the people, for the people, by the people; not the nominal inflection when traditional politicians seek votes in their favour around tribal and familial alliances. Pakistan's brand of democracy is patently exploitative and patronage-centred. It has produced a class of elites who arrogate power to themselves based on dynastic culture and financial exclusivity. Their proximity to centres of power, and their ability to manipulate its levers, gives them the pre-eminence in a largely poor society – forty-six per cent live below the poverty line by some calculations. Their conduct at the helm is mostly opportunistic and patently self-serving. The election process remains notoriously tainted, and the void between the people and those that claim to represent them only grows wider.

It is time to fill the void for the sake of retaining the viability of the state and securing the nation-state construct, and to avoid eruption of accumulated discontent. Any state structure must then address first and foremost the aspirations of the people. Let smaller units provide that sense of fairness and belonging to the people. Let constitutionally secured local governments under uniform country-wide laws open the door to self-governance with both authority and the resources that must devolve to that level. Let the people find their representatives from among them and win political representation away from the dynastic control and entrenched entitlement of a few.

Smaller provinces and administrative units, a uniform structure of local bodies, and a transparent, fair and free election process remain the key to Pakistan's state-society construct, giving it greater resilience and self-belief as it negotiates the next phase of its existence as a nation-state. Without it, we may be in an uncontrolled meltdown, socially, economically and institutionally. The state and its politics must be restructured. Else, the alternatives are stark.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ