TODAY’S PAPER | November 19, 2026 | EPAPER

FCC upholds cousin's inheritance right

Says paternal uncle's son may inherit as an 'Asabah bi-Nafsihi'


Hasnaat Malik November 19, 2026 2 min read
FCC upholds cousin's inheritance right

ISLAMABAD:

The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has upheld the inheritance right of paternal cousins as residuary heirs under Sunni Muslim law.

Residuary heirs receive the remainder of an estate after the shares of specific heirs—those entitled to fixed shares—have been distributed. In Islamic inheritance law, residuary heirs are known as Asabah.

According to an 11-page judgement authored by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan in an inheritance case, a paternal uncle's son may inherit as an 'Asabah bi-Nafsihi', that is, a residuary in his own right.

"His capacity arises from his relationship to the deceased through an exclusively male line, rather than through representation of his father's prescribed share.

"Nevertheless, membership of the agnatic class establishes only a potential capacity to succeed. Actual entitlement depends upon priority within that class and the absence of an excluding heir," said an 11-page judgement authored by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan.

A division bench led by CJ Khan adjudicated a question as to whether a full sister, as a Quranic sharer, could exclude the deceased's paternal cousins from the residue, or whether she could claim the remaining estate through the doctrine of radd (return).

The dispute arose after the death of a Muhammad Asghar. An inheritance mutation sanctioned in June 2018 allocated one-fourth of his estate to his widow and the remaining three-fourths to his two sisters. Later, a paternal cousin challenged the mutation, claiming entitlement as a residuary heir.

An assistant commissioner initially rejected his claim but an additional commissioner subsequently accepted it, a decision that was later upheld by the Board of Revenue and the Lahore High Court.

Sister however challenged the high court order in the Supreme Court. The case was transferred to the FCC after the 27th Constitutional Amendment.

The order stated the widow receives one-fourth and the two full sisters receive two-thirds collectively. Both fractions relate to the distributable estate; the sisters' two-thirds is not calculated upon the balance remaining after the widow's share is satisfied.

The prescribed fractions consequently aggregate to eleven-twelfths, leaving one-twelfth whose devolution falls to be determined under the applicable rules of residuary succession or return.

The court clarified that the mere absence of a male sharer does not, by itself, establish a paternal cousin's entitlement. Such entitlement remains subject to the prescribed order of priority, the applicable rules of exclusion and the existence of a residue after satisfying the prescribed shares.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ