TODAY’S PAPER | November 18, 2026 | EPAPER

Apparently, harassment has to be sexual

.


Syeda Zahra Shah Subzwari November 18, 2026 4 min read
The writer is an international law and governance expert. Email her at zahrasubzwari@gmail.com

There is something deeply unsettling about being a working woman in Pakistan and reading a judgment that tells you that not everything that humiliates, intimidates or makes your workplace hostile is harassment.

Apparently, it has to be sexual.

I work in a field where men still significantly outnumber women. I know the calculations women make walking into a room full of men. How firm can I be without being called difficult? How much can I push back? When does disagreement become something more? And what happens when the person making you uncomfortable is senior enough to affect your career?

The fear is not always sexual. The power is.

That is what makes the Federal Constitutional Court's recent judgment in Usman Shahid v Nadia Sarwar so troubling. The case concerns a National Bank of Pakistan employee who complained of harassment and a hostile working environment in 2012 and 2013. The Federal Ombudsman found in her favour, imposing a major penalty. The President reduced it to censure, while the Islamabad High Court restored the Ombudsman's decision. The FCC has now set that aside.

There is, of course, a legal wrinkle. The conduct took place in 2012 and 2013, before Parliament expanded the definition of harassment in 2022. The FCC therefore applied the definition in force at the time. But that does not make the reasoning any less troubling.

Because the FCC adopted a narrow reading of the pre-2022 definition and expressly declined to follow the broader understanding of workplace harassment that had already been articulated by Pakistan's Supreme Court.

In 2023, the Supreme Court revisited Nadia Naz and held that the law covers gender-based discrimination at work, not only conduct that is sexual. This was not some obscure foreign academic paper. It was our Supreme Court. And yet, here we are.

What makes this harder to understand is that the Supreme Court had already given us a broader view. In Muhammad Din, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah opened the judgment with the line: "Sexual harassment is not about sex. It is about power."

Courts should look at the power but the FCC has brought us back to looking for the sex.

This is where it becomes almost absurd.

If a superior can humiliate a woman, threaten her livelihood and make her workplace unbearable, why are we asking what he wanted rather than what he did? A confession? A love letter? A witness willing to testify that he looked sexually interested?

Perhaps women should simply be issued a workplace harassment kit: a notary public, two witnesses and a recording device.

Because harassment is not always witnessed by a convenient row of people. Sometimes it happens behind closed doors. Sometimes it happens in front of colleagues who know exactly what is happening but know better than to get involved. Sometimes the witnesses are part of the same circle protecting the person doing it.

A junior employee is not necessarily going to testify against the person who controls her promotion. A colleague may see what happened and decide their job is worth more than becoming a witness. And in a well-established boys' club, the witnesses may already be on the other side.

The FCC asked for convincing, independent evidence. Nadia Sarwar had two witnesses, and it was still not enough. The more we insist on "independent" witnesses and increasingly convincing evidence, the more the system demands that women produce a crime scene for conduct that is inherently difficult to prove.

Evidence matters. Of course it does. But evidence standards cannot pretend harassment happens in a courtroom. International standards point the same way: CEDAW treats workplace sexual harassment as gender-based discrimination, and ILO Convention No 190 defines harassment by the harm it causes.

And after all that exposure, this is where we have landed on workplace harassment?

There is more to it. In the Noor Mukadam case, Justice Baqar Najafi did uphold Zahir Jaffer's death sentence. That is not the issue. The problem was what the honourable judge chose to add: describing "living relationships" as a societal vice and linking them to Noor's murder. The remarks drew criticism from women's rights advocates and the National Commission on the Status of Women for shifting attention towards social behaviour rather than Noor's killing.

The two cases are not the same. But it is difficult not to notice the direction in which the gaze falls.

When a woman is harmed, are we looking first at the man who exercised power over her? Or are we examining her behaviour, her choices, her relationships, her clothing, her words and her circumstances?

I am tired of pretending women only need protection from sexual desire at work. Sometimes a man does not want anything from a woman. He simply wants to show her that he can. There is no desire involved. The point is to remind her who has the power.

Women should not have to wait for harassment to become recognisably sexual before the law takes it seriously. We need a system that recognises the intimidation and humiliation that can make women leave jobs, stay silent and eventually stop entering certain rooms. The government has sought a review, and the National Assembly has resolved that harassment is not limited to sexual conduct. The Court should take the chance to correct itself. Because the question is not whether a man wanted a woman. The question is whether he knew he could intimidate her, and whether the law was prepared to do anything about it.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ