What problems to solve?
.

When I first started working in global health nearly two decades ago – coming from the world of engineering and technology – I was a firm believer in the mission of frugal innovation, or context appropriate technology. The idea was that technology can solve some of the most pressing problems we see in the developing countries, but because necessary infrastructure does not exist, we need to create technology that works in these locations. To carry out this mission, schemes with grand ideas were unveiled. These were the days of programmes including "one laptop per child" – the notion that if we give a laptop to each child around the world, we would be able to make extraordinary gains in education. Ideas such as a 100 dollar laptop came from this mindset. The campaign lasted for about a decade, and then ended abruptly as it failed miserably. Today no one really talks about it.
In my own discipline of biomedical engineering, there was extraordinary excitement around paper-based diagnostics changing the face of disease detection. There were claims that a 'device' printed on paper, about the size of a postage stamp, could potentially eliminate the need for many heavy-duty diagnostics. The results of that promise did not materialise in any substantial way either. Most of those companies, that made such promises, do not exist today.
And then there was this broader movement about using local materials, local knowledge and local innovations to solve local problems. A whole bunch of 'innovations' came to the fore, and while some local individuals were able to improve their financial condition by creating small businesses or find ways to support their families, by and large, these innovations did not scale. Large number of those who lived in slums, or in refugee camps, were not able to break free from the shackles of injustice or abject poverty.
Over the last decade, I have struggled with this question – the question of what problems should one solve with one's time and intellectual resources, and what success actually means? Is doing something always better than doing nothing? Another way to think about it is, should a chief justice be leading a national campaign to build a dam? Because he 'did something' while others were doing 'nothing', are we better off because of that?
I do not have all the answers on what should one do. look at data on the hundreds of millions spent on water wells across the world that have not achieved the desired results, and the vast sums and person-hours spent on erecting school buildings that are barely standing. In a world shaped by conflict that wipes out villages, buildings and memories of a lifetime, it is hard to see how these efforts can ever make a difference.
But then there is other side of the story. During the course of building tools, technologies and dwellings from locally sourced materials, people are able to develop a stronger sense of confidence in their abilities, they are able to challenge the notion that they are poor because they are always meant to be poor, that they have nothing to offer. A gymnastics programme for girls living in Machhar Colony in Karachi may not be able to solve all the problems of the stateless persons, but it can give hope to enough young girls to recognise that they too are skilled, talented and just as good as those who live in the houses where their mothers work as a cleaners. That sense of empowerment and self-confidence, even among a tiny group, will transfer to their children.
I do not believe that we will make a major dent in health or housing or education problems simply by being innovative or building from local resources. These problems do not exist in silos, they are part of a broader continuum of lack of accountability, injustice, corruption and disregard for human dignity. Those issues are not solvable by innovation – but the mission to bring new ideas, to work alongside communities in an effort to mutually learn, and to imagine something different may one day create enough people who will no longer be willing to put up with continued injustice.















1727268465-0/Untitled-design-(42)1727268465-0-208x130.webp)



COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ