A nation that gathers but rarely unites
.

Announce a lucky draw offering a free motorcycle in Pakistan and thousands will turn up hoping to be the fortunate winner. Offer free food at a shrine and crowds will gather in their thousands. Organise a religious congregation, and hundreds of thousands will travel considerable distances, spending their time and money to participate. Yet organise a peaceful demonstration against injustice, violations of human rights, rising crime, inflation or the exploitation of marginalised communities, and the turnout will be disappointingly small.
Why does a nation capable of gathering so enthusiastically for personal, material and spiritual purposes struggle to unite around issues affecting its collective wellbeing? The answer is more complicated than simply accusing people of selfishness, ignorance or indifference. Indeed, the contrasting behaviour reveals something profound about the relationship between individual interests, collective consciousness, and the institutions governing our lives.
Consider the difference in incentives. A lucky draw offers an immediate, tangible possibility of personal gain. A free meal satisfies an immediate need. A religious gathering provides spiritual fulfilment, belonging and a shared sense of purpose. A protest against injustice, however, demands personal sacrifice for an uncertain collective benefit. Participants may lose wages, face harassment or even risk arrest, without knowing whether their efforts will make any difference. What appears to be indifference may, therefore, be a rational response to an environment where the costs of resistance are immediate and the rewards uncertain.
But economic calculations alone cannot explain the paradox. After all, people willingly make considerable sacrifices for religious causes. They travel long distances, contribute financially and dedicate days or weeks to collective activities. Clearly, Pakistanis do not lack the capacity for commitment, sacrifice or collective mobilisation. What seems to be missing is the translation of these capacities into sustained civic engagement. Religious gatherings benefit from established networks and shared identities. Civic movements, by contrast, often suffer from fragmented leadership, political divisions and uncertainty about outcomes.
There is also the question of fear. Gathering for charity or worship generally carries little political risk. Challenging the powerful can be a different matter. When citizens perceive that demanding accountability may invite intimidation, harassment or punishment, silence can become a strategy for survival. The absence of protest, therefore, should not automatically be mistaken for the absence of grievance. Repeated disappointment further complicates matters. After repeated failures and setbacks, people begin to believe that nothing changes, regardless of who governs or who protests.
Yet perhaps the most troubling dimension is our selective collective conscience. An injustice committed against someone belonging to our political party, ethnic community or religious group provokes outrage. The same injustice against an opponent may invite silence, rationalisation or even celebration. We defend rights when they serve our identities rather than recognising them as universal principles. This fragmentation prevents individual grievances from becoming a shared national cause. We become communities united by common interests but divided over common principles.
Nevertheless, Pakistan's history also provides examples of courageous collective resistance. Lawyers, students, workers, women and marginalised communities have repeatedly mobilised against injustices. The problem is not an absolute absence of civic consciousness but the difficulty of sustaining solidarity beyond particular personalities, affiliations and immediate grievances. The way forward begins with redefining citizenship. Citizens are not merely beneficiaries of state generosity or petitioners seeking favours from influential individuals. They are rights-bearing members of a political community, entitled to justice, dignity, security and accountability.
Education must cultivate critical thinking and civic responsibility alongside professional competence. Religious institutions, possessing extraordinary organisational capabilities, can reinforce the moral importance of justice, honesty, compassion and defending the vulnerable. Political parties and civil society must build trustworthy institutions that encourage participation beyond personal loyalties. Above all, the state must protect peaceful dissent rather than make civic engagement a potentially dangerous undertaking.
Pakistan's greatest challenge is not bringing people together. It is giving them the confidence, common purpose and institutional protection to stand together for what is right - even when there is nothing personally to gain. And this certainly benefits the state and society but not necessarily an institution or a few privileged individuals.















1727268465-0/Untitled-design-(42)1727268465-0-208x130.webp)



COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ