The placards they are holding and quite obviously shoving into the face of the cameraman bear the legends: ‘Hate Amrica’; ‘Crush Amrica’ which seem, quite obviously, the handiwork of the ‘Ghairat Brigades’ supported by the hard-right jingoist media, on the lines of the obviously contrived ‘We love ISI’ demo in Islamabad in the aftermath of Bin Laden’s killing.
The second of the placards (Crush Amrica) took me straight back 41 years to the ‘Crush India’ campaign launched by the Pakistani Deep State hand-in-glove with an Urdu daily out of Lahore. Most of my readers (for, reading the spirited comments at the end of news stories and op-eds it seems to me that this newspaper of record is the preferred newspaper of the young) may not even know of THAT campaign, the result of which, incidentally, was the dismemberment of Pakistan with one-half of the country and the larger part of the population becoming an independent Bangladesh.
Remember, that at the time we were trying to crush impoverished, but much larger than ourselves, India, which was then almost equivalent to us in the sophistication of weaponry. NOW we are calling for the crushing of ‘Amrica’, the only super-power (other than us, of course!) on earth, and on whom OUR military machine (aka the Deep State) depends for the more sophisticated of its weapons systems; cash; moral support; you name it. And on which it strikes attitudes and growls at the rest of the world.
As an aside, a blogger on one of the many, many blogs and threads and sites and whatever they are called, a Jihadi who also wants to ‘crush’ Amrika, challenged all and sundry to tell him exactly how America had come to the aid of Pakistan! Well, I only know what I saw when I joined the army in 1965 (no, I was not a Nur Jahania i.e., one of those who joined the short courses that came in after the 1965 war with India).
While in the Pakistan military Academy (PMA, the much written-about academy near which the terrorist Bin Laden was killed) we were trained on the Rifle No.4 Mk 1, a bolt-action, British-era small arm and the .303 light machine gun (LMG). When we got to our units in May of 1966 we were issued the American semi-automatic .30 M-1 rifle and the .30 Browning automatic rifle (BAR) light machine gun. As also the .30 heavy machine gun. These was also Korean war surplus weaponry which had been diverted to Pakistan after the end of that conflict.
We also had the great M38 Willys Jeep which we called ‘Little Willy’, and which was a little workhorse with a heart as big as an elephant — later upgraded to the M-38 A-1 (by the Americans didn’t you know)? These Jeeps went everywhere, did everything, and I remember so well driving the M38 through the Tavi River, its exhaust in two feet of water; to say nothing of the wonderful ¾ ton Dodge and the 2-1/2 ton Cargo, let alone the Patton tanks and the F-86s and the F-104s and then the C-130s and the F-16s and the Orion-P3Cs (all of which were destroyed by five al Qaeda operatives not too long ago, shame on us); and battle-ships; and cruisers; and mine-sweepers. We ought to be ashamed of ourselves for forgetting history.
It is not my intention to be an apologist for America: I have been a trenchant critic of its long-standing preference for military dictators who did its bidding, from Ayub Khan who actually agreed to change the TO and E (the Top Secret Tables of Organisation and Equipment) of the Pakistan Army just to get more aid from the Americans, to the tyrant Zia, to the ill-meaning Musharraf. I am merely putting on record the largesse that America has shown to our tin-hats over the years which they are now (seemingly, only) not recognising to embellish their so-called ‘nationalism’.
This is dishonesty and hypocrisy of the worst order, and is obviously being pursued to divert people’s attention from their own failings and most recent set-backs (do we have to repeat the names ‘Abbottabad’ and ‘Mehran’?) that have shown them to be incompetent and inept. This managed hysteria and jingoism also helps put other of their problems out of sight. Such as the disappeared people, and Saleem Shahzad’s brutal and cruel murder.
By the way, the ISI had announced through one of its unnamed and mysterious ‘media managers’ that it would leave ‘no stone unturned’ to find Saleem’s murderer, a few days after his violent death, when the spoor marks led directly to itself. Well, how many more stones are left to be turned, please sirs? You obviously aren’t all you tout yourselves to be, what, for you have not told us so many months down the line who killed Saleem?
But, coming back to the fake righteous indignation of our Rommels and Guderians, they know better than us just what America means to them and in what close embrace they are with it. The only problem is that America has shown them up to be the double-dealers that they are. And America is right, for which of us Pakistanis did not know that our Deep State was, yes, consorting with exactly the wrong people? And is continuing to, as evidenced by our great ‘Foreign Policy Elites’ trying to get them a seat at the Afghan High Table.
How, pray, are the Taliban and their friends the Haqqanis good for Pakistan? Their record is uniformly bad.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 30th, 2011.
COMMENTS (69)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
In 1971 we raised the slogan of Crush India and we lost East Pakistan.Now the same people are shouting Crush Amrika and want to lose the rest of Pakistan. Please learn from history and wake up because the greatest enemy is with in.
@ Sikandar u are enough for that my friend.
@NADEEM CHATTHA: An army dictator was in power then. Why did Pakistan have to become the Frontline State, please?
@Ali Tanoli: Have you ever tried to play violin to a donkey? well I cannot be more Explicit-ic. No point friend you cannot be treated, please dont bother to reply
Only one statement, we have been bred with denials and thats the curse. We will be always like this. we will even go against our own mother if needed, thats Pakistan.
@ Viram singh i think i will try more garlic and more olive oil for my LDL to go down to HDL good choles
@Ali Tanoli: ".... india is differ than pakistan we eat cows they worship .... "
When your arteries get clogged with cholesterol, you will not be as condescending.
@Vasan tell what part of my text u dont understand so i can try to write again inshaallah.
@ Vasan Indian history is all ways been a occupation for centuries what they gonna fight with some one?????
@rehmat: What if America attacked India or sent drone attacks into India? Would there be more Indians plotting against America? I am quite sure there would be. It is human nature
Ali Tanoli : Pl write something which others understand.
@ Tanoli
One day, when you will grow up, there will be a realization that you have been living in the delusional world of Muta'alya I pakistan.
@rehamat india is differ than pakistan we eat cows they worship.
@ rehmat india is differ than pakistan food wise only we cow and they dont.
@Rehamat Tell me something is there any country in this world it is not hypocrate i dont think so and pakistanis living all around the world and doing for those bettenness of those countries for last half century and there is no complain we ever heard.
@Hassan: Because we did their bidding, that's why!
Can we just all shut it and understand the hard fact that there are no permanent friends and enemies in international relations to perpetuate a long-term policy. There is just one thing that matters; national interest. We all have our own definitions of it and everyone is entitled to it. US provides a big chunk of our aid so yes they anticipate us to act accordingly.
The question is; have we interpreted our national interest correctly? To me, the answer is a big-time-premiere-league NO.
God only knows what this Ali Tanoli is talking.
100% True! Well done.
@Vasan i think indian leaders changed there mind in 1998 forever because there is no more choice. and u talking about muslim get mejority after becoming one country dude madrassa Deoband was a anti pakistan movment and thats a reason congress party is in love with madrassa they were saying the same thing but its didnot happend for some good some bad but its ok..
@ rational thinker Dudy you know why then why question again and again????
@Ali tanoli.. again, nobody complained about Pakistanis lining up for Amreeka visas.. everyone is questioning their logic in planning to cut the branch that they are sitting on..
@ Vasan Its a day light truth in 1947 Nehru said pakistan will be back in india in six months but god had something else in his mind and one more thing if Mr Shafi sahab and like him so many honorable seculars in pakistan are talking today thats because of some peoples secrifces who give there lives for them to talk.
@Duck Why dont all the Gharath mond leave us alone eastren westren this is my request dont they.
Mr. Shafi, you speak for the heart of every Pakistani with a commitment to common sense and the truth. We need more people like you.
I hope and wish every secular should read this.........
@NADEEM CHATTHA: Yes Jihad in Afghanistan was CIA's brain child and no one is claiming to contrary. But the question Kamaran Shafi puts is why Pakistani army got involved in to it. Why could not they simply say to CIA that in long run this jihad will create existential problems for Pakistan and we do not want to be a part of it. Why didn't they refuse the use of their territory for a war which was not theirs?
A totally one-sided view point.
A very realistic article written by a realistic analyst.But I am sir, for obvious reasons, more concerned about my province(Balochistan) where a very dangerous and dirty game is being played. The master mind of the game is still behind the curtains.I here very humbly urging people like you to expose those before it get too late and another 1971 occurs(God forbid).
I predict 10 years down the line when the Chinese come after the Muslims of East Turkmenistan who operate from Pakistan, the same guys who say death to amreeka will start their chant of death to China. Circumstances change but people dont change.
While I generally agree and look forward to the columns of Mr. Shafi, but at times he is a bit hard on the Army, the "original sin" for taking the American line back in 50"s seems not an Army decision. "Jihad" in Afghanistan was a CIA brainchild, just see the "Reader's Digest" Newsweek and Times publications of the 80's and how they took all the pains to convince the so called " free world" of the great boon and dividends that "Jihad" will bring. As for double crossings and proxys , our American friends are also great experts, they have a history of colliding and ditching partners, in this theatre too, they have their hands full, the TTP only fights on our side and has never ventured across the border, so its an ugly scenario from both the angles.
Ali Tanoli said : @ Zalim singh Recent illegal indian entering in amerrka is higher than 1990 average even they trying from mexico too and most of these indian africans are sikhs from east punjab and gujathis from gandhi nagers please indian economy is so strong so why they migrating to ameerica may be just for fun and kya zulam hua if some pakistanis got here because of economic hurdles in back home. Kabish or no cio.
Mr Tanoli . You missed the points by a light year. This is not about Indians entering US or UK legally or illegally,. It is about Pakis who have gone to US, liviing there and start their hate campaign against US. It is about pakis who migrate to US and plan to bomb in Newyork etc. The question is that if you think you are to be ghairat, then they should go back to Pak and shout as much as they want and as long as they want. You will not find many Indians living anywhere spreading hate messages and planning bombing the host country. That privileage belongs to Pakistans. For heavens sake dont bring the religious angle, suppressed muslims etc. They dont sell. That logic has no truth value and expired. Simply because more muslims are killed and suppressed in muslim countries than "free" countries
Mr.Kamran Shafi; Sir. I have been reading your articles for many years and believe me, this is the first time I am writing a comment. I did not ever comment before since I have always agreed with every line you have written. Believe me Sir; there are not many Pakistani retired army personnel who are respected in India but you are an honourable exception. Your views are held in very high esteem in our country and your relentless pursuit to bring real democracy in Pakistan is extremely appreciated. Sir, please keep working for bringing Pakistan army under civilian control and if that happens; we in India believe that peace will be established between us in no time. Looking forward to your enlightening views in future.
Kamran Shafi Right u r
@Ali Tanoli thanks for reminding me, this writeup is regarding india and not pakistan. and i am fully agree with you that these indians illegally migrate even though they hate amrika(ns) and west(erns). isn't it right.
sorry don't know about amrika, but in uk, pakistani's are top of the chart in illegal migration and human trafiicing.
i still curse myself for that pakistani visa in my british passport. man, its so much of pain to face immigration and security people for at least 1-2 hours at every airport.
@Ali Tanoli: So just to save your nose from India, and just because you "believe" that India is wanting you to collapse, you are ready to make most foolish mistake of challenging USA ? Even though I am an Indian, I can only humbly request you my brother, please sometimes think rationally rather than by prejudices. Maybe then you will see what really is the truth. Answer this questions if you can. What will India gain from Pakistan's collapse ? Do you really think India will attack Pakistan ? Can you please point out which war was started by India. And I suggest please read articles on these war and then comment. ? What is the rationale and result of India attacking Pakistan ? We have 1.3 billion population and struggling with eliminating poverty, by capturing Pakistan we will increase population to 1.7 billion, and will change the balance of hindu muslim population to probably 50-50. Thereby loosing our "Hindu" majority. Which is not much importance to us but I have read you guys using that majority-minority card quite often. So don't you think that if you believe that India is pre dominantly Hindu and if it captures Pakistan what will happen to hindu majority ???? Think ??? SO stop assuming that India has any interest in attacking Pakistan, yes we are still interested in attacking terrorists in Pakistan and in long run if you don't look thru prism of ego you will see it will help Pakistan too since your army and leaders are incapable to fight terrorists.
@Ali Tanoli: Hence you prove to be uneducated. You completely missed the point Zalim Singh was talking about. He was not pointing out to illegal immigration issue in USA. He was pointing out that Pakistanis in general even after becoming citizens of other countries curse and abuse and bad mouth that country. That's called be-ghairatgee, and is rampant in Pakistanis settled in many parts of the world. Check UK, Scandinavia, anywhere. Question is how shameless a person can be that he will take all benefits of the country but will continue to hate it, even plot to attack it. What do you call such people ?
Mr. Kamran Shafi has a fine mind and he brings intellectual honesty in all discussions relating to Pakistan's Foreign Policy.I eagerly await his weekly opinion columns, now at ET and formerly on Dawn. I salute you, Sir! It is unbelievable to me why Pakistan's power brokers and intellectuals do not begin a massive campaign to nominate Mr. Shafi as President of Pakistan. He has all the makings of a great leader who will lead by example from the Front. He is extremely well read, is gifted with thorough knowledge and grasp off global affairs, and commands respect in Pakistan, the US and in India. He is clearly in tune with military matters, a great asset in Pakistan. With trade missions from Pakistan to India coming up with successful 2-way trade forecasts, Mr. Shafi is just the catalyst that Pakistan needs to bring it out of its difficulties and into a new dawn. Let us make a joint start and move from associating with cavemen to bringing progress and technology to the common man in South Asia-India, Pakistan and Saarc- and let our future be bright and joyous! It is only our limitations and narrow minds that are holding us back-and depriving our poor from sharing in our bounty! God bless us all!
Thank you a voice of reason above the din of hypocracy.
~An American
Mr. Shafi Sir, as usual this is another great write-up of yours. I would like write so many words in your praise, but would that be worth? Because, you don't need any more praise and accolades from your readers and fans. I want to resist and refute your opponents ( the ones who hold diametrically opposite and quite sinister views with personal agendas), but the problem is the columnists of the deep state hold sway over the so called "liberal media" of Pakistan, my comment critical of them will never be published. It would be better and more sensible if, I express my opinion via e-mail to you, as I doubt even this comment of mine would be allowed by the "liberal media" ie. the Express Tribune.
First we want aid from US, then we will buy weapons from US out of that aid, then our officers and generals will go to US to attend war courses, and then we will crush US.
@Fahad Ullah Dar: "And what about the American Record ?"
America and its people should worry about their actions and consequences. Pakistani people should be cooncerned about the actions and consequences of their leaders.
USA has a democracy and people regularly make their voice heard on policy matters. Shafi saab is suggesting that Pakistanis also need to do the same.
Once again hard hitting Kamran Shafi has done his duty for Pakistan exposing the failings and double speak of the deep State. Hope and pray more people listen to him. The failure to do so will inevitably lead to more heart aches. God help.
All through my childhood and many of my adult years America has been the the Enemy of India!! We in India knew that America has armed and fed Pakistan since the 50's till curent day.....If anything this is really ungrateful of the Pakistanis to say 'crush America'.
@ Khan So how long pakistan have to say Yes and when will say no is there any finishing point or what shafi sahab trying to say i dont get it a newly country with out a pen and pencil or any office if they went across north atlantic what should they have done that time with one side india who were waiting for this country to collapse.
Advantages to PAK in US hate spewing rallies :
Thriving small scale industries that make US flags, effigies of US politicians, T shirts, etc. Employment of rent a crowd of the unemployed, even for a day. Cushy job for TV anchors who do not have to research their stories every day Imran Khan does not have to bother with his political manifesto Continued US Aid to appease the Anti-American sentiments. Free military aid to suppress out of control anti-us protests Landing fees and sale of aviation fuel to all the diplomatic flights Free publicity to remind the world that there is a country called Pakistan Diverting repressed anger of the populace against the PAK Govt towards America Increased inflow of unaccounted foreign exchange for the terror network that boosts the local economy which the PAK Govt has neglected. .........( sorry no space )This is very well articulated.
++ Our in your face denial is reflected in the FM's statement that reminds us of how the Haqqanis were created and were the blue eyed boys of the USA. May be so. But is that justification to axe our own body?!
++ We are confused between wrong and right. Taliban/LET are friends but USA. Afghans and Europeans are enemies! One is the source of mayhem, the other a source of aid, arms, friendship, and place where our children go to study and we want to immigrate to! But the movie of duplicity and hate is playing to full theaters. That is scary.
@khan:
Sadly, Sir, I don't think your children or mine will EVER get the answers.
Mickey, great stuff!
The Army has brought Pakistan to a sorry pass. We will continue the downslide until civilian supremacy is firmly established.
Unfortunately many of us - Pakistanis - fall for the lies told to us.
Our TV anchor bunnies, without even bothering to exercise their brain 'muscles' (anyway, those few who have them), start frothing in the mouth with pious 'ghairat' at a drop of a hat, or perhaps from a signal received from the relevant quarters.
OBL in Abbottabad, the attack on Mehran Air Base, Saleem Shahzad's brutal end, the almost daily 'kill and dump' operations in Balochistan are the more recent ones. Ojiri Camp, Benazir's death, the Bugti killing - the list goes on and on, seemingly endlessly.
Our children might get the answers one day in history books but by then there is a strong likelihood that our country may no longer exist - largely thanks to the mighty efforts of our patriots of the Deep State.
How many days of petrol and diesel supplies do we have? We cant keep thermal power stations running, how is the war machine going to operate? The hot air that TV Pundits blow doesnt happen to run our tanks, trucks, jeeps, helicopters, fighters do they?
"Death to Amareeka" unites Pakistanis more than anything else, amazing!
Hypocracy and duplicityt is the only operative ideology here.
Before crushing Amreeka, we request US to supply us the spares required for the military equipments they have supplied so far so that we will be in a better position to defeat and defame Amreeka.
Brilliant!
Hate Amrica; crush Amrika and get green card of Amreeeka. this seems to be to be the normal motive of average pakistanis. There is a turncoat a.k.a Riaz Haq, who settled happily in Amreeeeka and makes hate speeched about that nation on his blog. Would Pakistanis settled in US return back to their country to demonstrate their national pride? Dont think so. They are too much of hypocrates,
And what about the American Record ? ?