Book review: Kaptaan’s kahaani

Imran won’t bowl anyone over with his prose stylings.

Nadir Hassan October 02, 2011
Book review: Kaptaan’s kahaani

Unless your name is Jinnah, it takes a healthy amount of arrogance to write a book titled Pakistan: A Personal History. About as much arrogance as it would take to believe that you can lead an injury-plagued, out-of-form cricket team to a World Cup victory or that you can build a cancer hospital from scratch that provides free treatment to the poor.

So let’s get this out there at the start and let’s not hold it against him: Imran Khan is a very arrogant man and he has good reason to be arrogant. Call it delusion or an excess of self-belief, this man has often set out to do the impossible and has usually achieved his stratospheric aims.

This doesn’t mean that Imran can coherently pull off the triple mission of his latest book, which serves as an introductory history of the country, a memoir and a political manifesto. But no one will be reading this book to be dazzled by Imran the prose stylist; we just want to get a better understanding of how this cricket celebrity and philanthropist who had permanent ownership over the hearts of Pakistanis and the social scene of London ended up becoming a divisive right-wing politician.

Imran is honest in admitting that an interest in politics and religion was sparked only after his cricket career was nearly at an end but the roots of his worldview become apparent early on. Forget his subsequent activism against drone attacks and military operations, Imran is at heart a pastoral reactionary in the mould of poets like Philip Larkin. Even at a relatively young age, Imran says, he yearned for the open spaces of an uncluttered Zaman Park, fell in love with Hunza and now laments that the former has been urbanised and the latter has become a tourist trap.

Again, Imran claims that he had no particular interest in religion till much later but the impressions he gives of his first visits to England show that the religious gene was always present. On his first visit to the country he laments how religious belief has been undermined by the twin evils of Darwin and Monty Python.

To be a bit uncharitable, Imran’s own religious awakening can be seen as a sign of his naivety. A man by the name of Mian Bashir came into his life, offered a few predictions that came true and Imran suddenly became a devout Muslim. Introspection isn’t Imran’s strongest suit but a more plausible explanation might be that he simply needed a bit of a push to bring out the religious belief that was always inside him. Whatever the spur might have been, those who maintain that the playboy is simply posing as a man of prayer should have their minds changed by Imran’s heartfelt explanation of his awakening.

The same sympathy should not extend to Imran Khan’s politics, which is based on a simplistic understanding of the country and is yet another sign of his naive nature. One charge that Imran should be exonerated of is that he is pro-Taliban. But he does downplay the Taliban threat by assuming that many of the militants are simply misguided Pakthuns who are simply fighting the US, and that once the imperialist power withdraws all will be well again.

Where Imran is at his most irksome is when he mocks those who think the threat of Talibanisation is greater than drone attacks or military operations, as if the constant bombing of shrines, government buildings and mosques and the continued massacre of Shias is not something to be immensely worried about. Even when Imran is absolutely spot on, as when he laments the murder of Salmaan Taseer, and says that anyone who is a minority or is pro-ANP lives in fear of death, he then follows up with a false equivalence by claiming that people like him also have to suffer because they are labelled pro-Taliban. He also takes unnecessary potshots at NGOs, saying “They did nothing, as most were funded by Western donors.”

Even those who disagree with Imran’s politics should never lose sight of that the fact that he is still one of the greatest living Pakistanis. As Imran documents the struggles he went through to make the Shaukat Khanum cancer hospital a reality, one realises that it is his doggedness, arrogance and refusal to bend to logic that have saved so many lives that would otherwise have been lost. And for that he deserves our gratitude.

Available at Liberty Books for Rs995.

Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, October 2nd,  2011.


M. A. Changezi | 12 years ago | Reply

Imran, who is yet to publicly condemn the killings of innocents (read Shias, Ahmedis etc), has a very simplistic vision of solving problems. I do not believe in his ways. Hell, what kind of person would ask someone to lend his Land Cruiser at the very first meetings? He has the nerve to do that. I am the witness. He visited an NGO in Quetta back in 2001. After listening to the presentation (which he was not interested in at all) he asked the head of NGO to lend his Land Cruiser for his political rally. Obviously, he got declined since the NGO never had any political affiliation since it's inception.

His stance on Taliban is alarming. Maybe it's a political move (similar to his Pakistani youth slogan) on his part since he knows most of Pakistani population in rural areas have soft corner for Taliban. Not denouncing Taliban would probably, in his opinion, bank in votes during next election.

How quick we Pakistanis forget that the same guy was one of the popular boys in Soho area of London where rich and desperate ladies still go to buy boylets for themselves. A person with such moral, like Imran, should be carefully watched.

Not saying that Nawaz or Zardari for that matter are the right people. We Pakistanis, in my opinion, need new faces, albeit new and qualified faces. The oldies have plundered a lot and we have run out of patience. The election commission of Pakistan should start digging the past corruptions and get rid of the bandits by banning them for life. This way, in my opinion, new faces will appear.

Until then fingers crossed.

Baba e quom we are sorry for doing this injustice to your dreamland.

Ayub Hafeez | 12 years ago | Reply

@R.A: I'm sure he'll lead all the political parties....!!!!

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ