Former Try Guy Ned Fulmer scandal resurfaces as TikTok footage sparks new speculation, Keith responds

Resurfaced Nashville bar footage reignites Ned Fulmer scandal debate

Former Try Guys member Ned Fulmer finds himself back in the spotlight as a 2022 video from a Nashville bar resurfaces on TikTok, stirring fresh discussions about his infamous cheating scandal. The clip, originally captured during a night out, depicts Fulmer dancing closely with a woman at Jason Aldean's rooftop bar, leading to widespread online speculation about its ties to his 2022 affair.

The footage includes overlay text stating, "Now that it's been a couple years, I think it’s a good time to mention that I witnessed Ned from the Try Guys cheating on his wife in real time in Nashville, Tenn."

@fisherwelch

I remember seeing this man bumping and grinding with some rando’s at Jason Aldeans. Then the news went ballistic on his cheating scandal, had to sit on this video for a while 😳 #thetryguys #tryguys #nedfulmer #cheatingscandal #fyp

♬ som original - user67829585061

The video quickly went viral, with viewers initially assuming the woman was Alexandria Herring, the Try Guys producer at the center of Fulmer's confirmed workplace affair. That scandal erupted in September 2022 when photos and reports surfaced of Fulmer and Herring together, prompting the Try Guys—Keith Habersberger, Zach Kornfeld, and Eugene Lee Yang—to conduct an internal review and part ways with him.

In a statement at the time, the group announced, "Ned Fulmer is no longer working with The Try Guys. As a result of a thorough internal review, we do not see a path forward together."

Fulmer admitted to the "consensual workplace relationship," emphasizing that family should have been his priority but he had "lost focus."

However, online sleuths and fans soon clarified that the woman in the Nashville footage was not Herring but Rachel Ann Cole, a longtime Try Guys executive producer and colleague, who was part of the group's outing.

Social media users pointed out the friendly, drunken context of the dance, with one X post noting it showed Fulmer "bodyrolling on Rachel while they're all drunk & having fun," not evidence of additional infidelity.

The poster,@fisherwelch, explained in a follow-up "storytime" video that he captured the moment during spring break 2022, unaware of Fulmer's marital status or the woman's identity at the time. He forgot about the clip until a Snapchat memory notification resurfaced it years later, and he shared it without intent to profit or sensationalize.

Adding to the confusion, some viewers pointed a figure in the video's background assumed to be Keith Habersberger, sparking theories that the remaining Try Guys might have known about Fulmer's behavior earlier.

@keithhabs

Wanted to give context.

♬ 11 Binaural Beats 1 Hz - August Son Productions

Habersberger addressed the buzz on his TikTok and social media, clarifying that the footage that that was a group outing celebrating the wrap of their tv show they're celebrating and the women in that video is rachel their producer and long time friend, emphasizing that the group was unaware of the affair with Herring until fans alerted them in 2022.

He reiterated the Try Guys' stance from their post-scandal video, where they expressed shock and disappointment.

In 2025, Fulmer broke his silence in an interview with People magazine, reflecting on the pain caused to his ex-wife Ariel Fulmer. "That was most devastating to work through and to realize—how much pain I had caused her," he said, admitting his "wife guy" persona was curated and contributed to the irony of the scandal.

He and Ariel, who share two children, later appeared together on his podcast "Rock Bottom with Ned Fulmer," discussing their post-affair journey through therapy and co-parenting.

This resurgence highlights how old content can fuel ongoing narratives, even with clarifications. While the Nashville video does not depict the actual affair, it has prompted renewed scrutiny of Fulmer's actions and the Try Guys' dynamics, keeping the 2022 drama alive in 2026.