A fresh take on Sense and Sensibility has barely started filming, yet it’s already igniting fierce debate among Jane Austen fans. The remake, led by Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esme Creed-Miles as Elinor and Marianne Dashwood, has divided audiences after its full cast announcement sparked heated reactions online.
The film, produced by Focus Features and Working Title, boasts a high-profile ensemble. George MacKay is stepping into the role of Edward Ferrars, Caitríona Balfe is playing Mrs. Dashwood, and Fiona Shaw will portray the chatty London socialite Mrs. Jennings. Frank Dillane, known for more brooding roles, is cast as the infamous John Willoughby, while Herbert Nordrum and Bodhi Rae Breathnach complete the core lineup as Colonel Brandon and Margaret Dashwood, respectively.
Despite the star power, many Austen purists are voicing concern. Critics on social media argue the casting choices feel “too modern” and claim the production is shaping up to be another overly stylized period drama rather than a faithful adaptation. “It looks like they’re going for edgy instead of elegant,” one Austen fan wrote on X, while others fear the chemistry between the leads might not hold up to the legacy of the beloved 1995 version.
Adding to the skepticism is the creative team. While director Georgia Oakley has earned praise for Blue Jean, and screenwriter Diana Reid is a bestselling author, fans are still wary of how much creative liberty they might take. The internet discourse has been especially unforgiving, with “Elinor” and “Willoughby” trending across multiple platforms as fans dissect every casting detail.
The film is only in production, but the court of public opinion is already in session. Whether the final product will win over skeptics or deepen the divide remains to be seen.
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ