Juror says women on Depp-Heard trial jury doubted Amber Heard more than male jurors

New book reveals juror insights from Johnny Depp defamation trial, claiming female jurors were toughest on Heard.

A male juror from the high-profile Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard defamation trial has shared new insights into the jury's deliberations, revealing that the two female jurors were particularly skeptical of Heard’s testimony.

The comments come from Hollywood Vampires: Johnny Depp, Amber Heard, and the Celebrity Exploitation Machine, a new book by Kelly Loudenberg and Makiko Wholey published June 17. Tom Nugen, a 53-year-old retired defense contractor, stated that “the women were tougher on Amber than the men,” describing significant inconsistencies in Heard’s statements.

The comments provide new perspective on the jury’s mindset during the widely watched trial. Nugen recalled that the jury found “so many holes” in Heard’s account that they struggled to believe her. “They’re all actors; they can put on a different face if you pay them enough,” he said. He also admitted to enjoying Depp’s courtroom demeanor, saying his testimony offered a “breath of fresh air” during the long proceedings.

Nugen said most jurors were unfamiliar with Heard before the trial. He also emphasized that the case highlighted how abuse allegations shouldn't be assumed to involve only male perpetrators. “Not every case of abuse is from the man,” he said, adding that for ordinary men, a false accusation could be life-altering.

Depp sued Heard in 2022 over a Washington Post op-ed about domestic violence. He won all three defamation claims, while Heard prevailed on one of her countersuits. She later paid Depp $1 million in a settlement.

The book offers a rare behind-the-scenes look into one of the most scrutinized celebrity trials, revealing how media narratives and personal bias influence the pursuit of justice.