Balochistan cauldron: unravelling the enigma

Balochistan issue is complex, rooted in historical grievances that demand dialogue, development, and rights.


Dr Syed Akhtar Ali Shah October 13, 2024
The author is a former Secretary to Government, Home & Tribal Affairs Department and a retired IG. He holds a PhD in Political Science and currently heads a think tank ‘Good Governance Forum’. He can be reached at aashah77@yahoo.com

print-news

The incessant turmoil in Balochistan, orchestrated by militant organisations and fueled by the political movement under the Mili Yakhjahati Council, has once again brought the province to the forefront of national concern. The perpetual question remains: what is the crux of the Balochistan problem? Is it merely a manifestation of disgruntled individuals or a deeply ingrained issue warranting profound attention?

To grasp the complexity of this conundrum, one must delve into the historical narrative, tracing the genesis of the Baloch struggle. The youth's deep-seated hatred towards a specific ethnic group and their daredevil attacks beg questions: what sparked this sentiment, and how can we address the underlying drivers of militancy? Understanding the chronic issue necessitates adopting a sound strategy, commencing with a thorough examination of the past.

We must acknowledge the Baloch people's aspirations, rooted in a 2,000-year-old quest for self-recognition, preservation of cultural identity and self-rule. Their rich cultural heritage, shaped by centuries of resilience and perseverance, demands recognition and respect. History reveals that after the creation of Pakistan, the Baloch trust was betrayed, culminating in movements in 1948, 1958, 1962, and most vigorously from 1973 to 1977.

The absence of democracy, coupled with negligible human development, has fostered a sense of deprivation. Balochistan, comprising half of Pakistan's land mass, boasts immense natural resources yet lags behind in essential development indicators. Alarming statistics reveal a dire reality: malnourishment, high illiteracy rates, subhuman conditions and scant access to electricity or clean drinking water.

Infant and maternal mortality rates soar, while poverty and unemployment grip the province. The dropout rate of girls from schools is staggering, with nine out of ten girls in rural Balochistan deprived of education. This bleak scenario perpetuates a cycle of despair, fueling discontent among the youth.

The youth perceive a lack of due process, exacerbating trust deficits between the state and the people. Globalisation and development, juxtaposed with nationalism, have intensified fears of marginalisation. Exposure to Western philosophy, history, poetry and Baloch literature – including Mir Gul Khan Nasir's works and Marxist ideologies – has catalysed the militants' resolve.

Literary influences have instilled a sense of resistance. Mir Gul Khan Nasir's poignant words resonate: "When the world constricts around the poor man...then it's better to abandon this life of misery and torture; if war ensues, heads roll & lavish palaces burn to the ground." Similarly, Maxim Gorky's "Mother" inspires the youth to challenge the status quo, as the protagonist boldly declares in the courtroom: "We are against the society whose interests you judges have been ordered to defend; we are its uncompromising enemies...all of you, our masters, are more like slaves than we are. You are enslaved spiritually; we – only physically."

His mother's steadfast conviction that "not even an ocean of blood can drown the truth" echoes through the corridors of time. These powerful narratives have become ingrained in the collective psyche of the Baloch youth, driving their quest for justice and equality.

To quell the militancy, we must address its drivers. Democratic processes must be implemented in the truest sense, providing an enabling environment for self-recognition and human development. We must prioritise inclusive development, preserve cultural identity, ensure due process and justice, and encourage education and critical thinking.

Beyond these immediate measures, a deeper understanding of the Baloch people's cultural heritage and historical struggles is essential. The Baloch have a rich tapestry of traditions, customs and folklore that have shaped their identity. Their history is replete with tales of resistance against foreign invaders and the preservation of their way of life.

Moreover, the Baloch people have a deep connection to their land. Their nomadic traditions and their reliance on the natural resources of Balochistan have instilled in them a strong sense of place. This connection to the land has been further strengthened by the exploitation of Balochistan's resources without adequate benefits to the local population.

Addressing the Balochistan problem requires not only political solutions but also cultural and historical understanding. By recognising the importance of Baloch culture and history, we can foster a greater sense of belonging and pride among the Baloch people.

In conclusion, the Balochistan problem is a complex issue with deep historical roots. To find a lasting solution, it is essential to understand the underlying grievances of the Baloch people and address them through a comprehensive and inclusive approach. By prioritising dialogue, development and respect for human rights, Pakistan can begin to heal the wounds of the past and craft a harmonious, prosperous tomorrow.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ