Begging by choice?

Saudi Arabia urges crackdown on misuse of Umrah visas as concerns grow over Pakistani beggars entering the kingdom.

Saudi authorities have raised concerns over the number of Pakistani beggars entering the kingdom and have urged local authorities to crack down on the practice. Last year, during a session of a Senate committee, it was revealed that 90 per cent of beggars arrested abroad - particularly in Saudi Arabia, Iran and Iraq - are of Pakistani origin. It not only raises serious concerns about human trafficking but also has significant implications for our global reputation. Unfortunately, Umrah visas are being misused for these activities. The sight of Pakistani beggars on the streets of Arab countries has become increasingly common, raising questions about the socio-economic dynamics that drive these individuals to seek help in a foreign land. Many are migrants who left Pakistan in search of better opportunities, only to find themselves trapped in a cycle of poverty and desperation.

Economic instability, lack of job opportunities and rising inflation in Pakistan push many to migrate, often without a clear understanding of the challenges they may face abroad. In Saudi Arabia, where the allure of wealth and employment attracts countless workers, many Pakistani migrants find themselves unable to secure stable jobs, leading them to beg as a means of survival. The presence of beggars is not merely a humanitarian concern; it reflects broader systemic issues. It highlights the inadequacies of migrant support systems and raises ethical questions about the treatment of foreign workers. While some might argue that begging is a choice, the harsh reality is that for many, it is a last resort born from dire circumstances. As a society, we must foster compassion rather than judgment. If human trafficking rings are operating, they must be dismantled. Additionally, there should be effective measures in place for screening individuals exiting the country, ensuring that legitimate travellers are not subjected to harassment. Most importantly, we must focus on creating opportunities for dignified employment at home as a key solution moving forward.