Editorial

Reclaiming public spaces

In 2018, a similar anti-encroachment drive was conducted

April 30, 2024

The recent Supreme Court directive to remove encroachments from all roads and footpaths in Karachi within three days has elicited concerns among citizens, particularly those who derive their livelihoods from small businesses operating in and around the city’s markets. While the directive aims to reclaim public spaces from encroachments, there is apprehension that it may result in the displacement of thousands of individuals without adequate compensation or sufficient time for relocation.

The repercussions of such actions are significant, with thousands of families left homeless as a result of demolition drives. Despite assurances of compensation, many of the victims of the past demolition drives have been waiting for years without any resolution in sight. While the Court’s directive is commendable in its efforts to address encroachments that impede public spaces, it is crucial to consider the plight of the vendors and individuals whose livelihoods depend on these spaces. Merely removing encroachments without providing adequate support and compensation to those affected exacerbates the problem and perpetuates injustices. It is imperative for authorities to approach this issue with sensitivity and compassion, ensuring that affected individuals receive fair compensation and assistance in finding alternative means of livelihood. Additionally, measures must be implemented to prevent corruption and ensure transparency in the process of reclaiming public spaces. This is not the first instance of such a directive being issued. In 2018, a similar anti-encroachment drive was conducted, leading to the removal of small carts and stalls from various areas. However, many affected individuals have yet to receive compensation for their losses.

Ultimately, the objective should be to strike a balance between reclaiming public spaces and safeguarding the rights and livelihoods of all citizens. Through a comprehensive and inclusive approach, we can create a city that is both vibrant and equitable for all its residents.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 30^th, 2024.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

COMMENTS (1)

Muhammad Javed | 6 months ago | Reply I am too old. After Covid attack I have 18-20 hours short breathing hole in the lung and many other things which according to Specialists every 60 above who had taken vaccine had one gift or the other I am unable to travel hence since about 4 years I have not been able to travel to Karachi my native city. I had thought that after Nasla Towers every encroacher had himself removed the encroachment and today Karachi is clear of it due to fear of Court if not the law. But this SC order is confusing this old fool.

Replying to X