PM questions effectiveness of justice system

We need substantial structural reforms and fundamental changes: Kakar

In an oblique critique of the judiciary, the caretaker prime minister has raised questions about the effectiveness of the country’s justice system, emphasizing that rules and laws must be applied to all people without discrimination.

“Our justice system faces some very serious questions. Unless we find answers to them, it is difficult for anyone to feel secure here. Consistent application of principles is essential,” PM Anwaarul Haq Kakar said on Tuesday during his visit to a private university in Punjab’s capital.

The premier was responding to a student’s query about the apex court's responsiveness to political issues versus cases involving ordinary citizens.

He also criticized politicians who uphold state institutions as their benefactors when favorable but distance themselves when their interests are not served.

“It's like this: when in power, everything seems fine; out of power, the institutions seem flawed,” he added. The PM pointed out that both democratic and authoritarian governments have failed in tax collection, with tax evasion exceeding Rs10 trillion and the formal economy accounting for only 20%.

“Tax-to-GDP ratio in Pakistan is merely 9%. Achieving our tax target in the last three months is a source of pride. If we managed this in three months, why couldn’t previous governments? This indicates serious flaws in our government’s structure,” Kakar said.

He emphasized the vast disparity between national income and expenditure, stressing the urgency of a robust taxation system for vital sectors like education and healthcare.

Read Steps afoot to boost IT investment: Kakar

Kakar noted that enforcing laws has been a persistent issue across all governments. He mentioned society’s tendency to obstruct law implementation, often brought forward by human rights groups whenever enforcement is attempted.

“We need substantial structural reforms and fundamental changes,” he emphasized.

Referring to recent Baloch protesters in Islamabad facing a police crackdown, the PM stated that protests should adhere to legal boundaries. He underscored that the state cannot permit violence and will respond within the legal framework to any disturbances caused during protests.

“Violence based on political, ethnic, or religious differences won’t be tolerated. Ensuring peace and security is the state’s responsibility,” he declared.

The prime minister clarified that not celebrating the New Year aimed to raise awareness about Israel’s atrocities against Palestinians.

“We have made it clear to the West that we stand with our Palestinian brothers. While not directly involved in this war, we voice our support for Palestine on every platform. We seek an end to this conflict,” Kakar stated.

Read more PM Kakar exhorts student innovation

The premier also visited PML-Q president Chaudhry Shujaat to discuss his health and the country’s political situation. Punjab Chief Minister Mohsin Naqvi accompanied him. Kakar praised Chaudhry Shujaat for his reconciliation and consensus-building policies.”