This thing called Islamophobia

Truth is Muslim refusal to integrate, in closed ethnic communities makes it difficult for citizens to embrace this.

Khaled Ahmed August 27, 2011

A mad Norwegian called Breivik soaked up a lot of hate literature on Muslim immigrants and Islam as faith, then sat down and wrote 15,000 words of more hate before killing scores of fellow-Norwegians. This is called Islamophobia and there are many honest Europeans who condemn it more vehemently as a challenge to European civilisation than we can as Muslims with our own prejudices.

But Europe’s thinking about Muslims, not all immigrants, is changing. They are turning away from the tolerance of multiculturalism to a stricter regime of ‘national culture’. As that new order takes hold, Muslims will find themselves at a disadvantage. European prejudice rests on several incidents in recent years: the 2004 Madrid and the 2005 London attacks, the 2004 ban of the headscarf coupled with the 2011 ban of the ‘burqa’ in France, the 2005 Paris riots, the 2006 Danish cartoon incident and several high-profile murders.

The July 2011 killing spree in Norway by Breivik, who preached against multiculturalism and ‘Islamisation of Western Europe’ has further underscored the deepening tensions on the continent. The Muslims are poorly integrated compared to other immigrant communities. Can one avoid discussing this aspect of the problem?

One reason for resistance to integration is the quality of manpower that emigrates from the Muslim world and the other is their loyalty to sharia.

In a thoughtful book Transnational Islam: Religion, Ideology and Power (Pluto Press 2004), an article titled “Islam: An Alternative Globalism and Reflections on the Netherlands”, by Jan Nederveen Pieterse, says: “Common understandings of the way Muslims define their boundaries with Dutch society focus on the areas of purity, sexuality and religion. Purity relates to food (pork, halal meat), drink (alcohol) and habits of cleanliness. Sexuality relates to control over women. In terms of religion, Muslims may view the Netherlands as an anti-Islamic country because of its degree of secularisation in the separation of church and state. Such boundaries give a sense of self-worth. Purity and sexuality provide a sense of moral superiority, which may compensate for class inferiority” (p.98).

The truth is that Muslim refusal to integrate has resulted in closed ethnic neighbourhoods, high crime rates in Muslim communities, calls for use of Sharia law in Europe and the wearing of the veil. Muslim scholar at Oxford University Tariq Ramadan says: “Over the last two decades Islam has become connected to so many controversial debates it is difficult for ordinary citizens to embrace this new Muslim presence as a positive factor.”

Muslim governments got together in the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) to plan some kind of response to the rising anti-Islamic sentiment in the West. In 2008, the OIC (then known as the Organisation of Islamic Conference) established an observatory on Islamophobia at its General Secretariat. Its 35th Council of Foreign Ministers, noted manifestations of Islamophobia and the rising trend of Islamophobia in parts of the western world.

Ekmeleddin Hisanoglu, the ninth secretary-general of the OIC, in his book The Islamic World in the New Century (Hurst & Company 2010), has outlined Islamophobia in the West, but has not taken much note of the provocation to the baser European self offered by the expat Muslims who resist integration and do not show moderation in the face of what they think is discrimination and injustice. The OIC has not set up any monitoring cell to observe the behaviour patterns of the Muslim communities in Europe.

The latest race-based rioting in the UK has served to somewhat tone down the prejudice of the intolerant Briton. The Muslim community, a majority of whom is Pakistani, not only stayed away from violence and crime, but gave a good account of themselves as loyal British citizens.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 28th, 2011.


Khadim Husain | 11 years ago | Reply

@P N Eswaran: Dear Sir, please don't forget that all those europeans married to locals, and as a result of that a new generation of Anglo-Indians was born, majority of those later migrated from Pakistan but many still living in Karachi and Cantonment areas of Pakistan. Anglo Indian sided with Colonists in entire liberation movement, integrated in European culture and converted to their religion. Whereas most christians in Indo-Pakistan belongs to very poor class and those were usually haunted by Hindu cast system, who were later converted. Moreover in all urban areas of Pakistan billion rupees churches were constructed, those still exists. Those were not built for integration but for conversions. All of the European countries were not as civilised like UK, and still in many countries not a single mosque is allowed to be built. When colonies were squeezing and those require labors, so peoples from colonies were welcomed. Indo-Pakistanis in UK. West Africans in France, Malays in Holland, Goa peoples in Portugal and watch demography of Carrebean etc. Majority converted to Christianity except migrants of Indo-Pakistan. The vicious blow of second world war pushed Europeans to talk about human rights but those have changed their stance and particularly NATO has pushed third world or non christian countries to the wall. US allowed migration of South Koreans and South Vietnamese, all whom converted to christianity. Integeration mean change of religion nothing else.

Shock Horror | 11 years ago | Reply

@hassan: Excellent and on the spot analysis of the origins of Islamophobia. In addition following points are relevant and complete the analysis.

Many of the children born in the host country start hating the country of their birth and say they are Muslims first and citizens of the country second and only as far as they can get state benefits without contributing to the country. They start dressing as Arabs did 1400 years back with full burka and hijab becoming the vogue. High levels of crime becomes prevalent amongst Muslims. Some of the real radicals start engaging in acts of terrorism and killing the host community. Then some of them want to establish a Muslim caliphate. And the hatred against Muslims continues to grow and grow.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read