The events of September 11 2001 transformed how Muslims were perceived by and portrayed on mainstream media. While stereotyping has always been an issue in pop culture, 9/11 led to some rather inaccurate representation of Muslims in the media, particularly in the west. On the 20th anniversary of the attack, a media outlet in the US tweeted asking users what they believe the worst pop culture portrayals of Muslims have been in the two decades since 9/11. From labelling pretty much every language spoken in the Middle East and South Asia as Arabic, to the often regurgitated caricature of the Muslim terrorist, Twitter users had several on-screen examples of inaccurate Muslim representation in their arsenal.
What is the worst portrayal of Muslims in pop culture in the #20YearsSince 9/11?— ReThink Media (@rethink_media) September 10, 2021
One user shared a short video clip from the Netflix Why Are You Like This? in which the Muslim character says Bismillah and breaks her fast with a shot of alcohol.
Another mentioned Morgan Freeman’s character in Robin Hood, who implies that Muslims pray to the sun when he says, “Is there no sun in this cursed country?” The Twitter user wrote, “Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves (1991). Morgan Freeman played ‘Azeem’. They put zero effort in learning how a simple Muslim prays and the results were hilariously offensive.”
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves 1991,Morgan Freeman played “Azeem” .. they put zero effort in learning how a simple Muslim pray and results were hilariously offensive 🤷🏽♂️ https://t.co/pjBHM3x7mW pic.twitter.com/bWM8TjOLDW— پيبَرسْ (@Jaschnakeer) September 11, 2021
Speaking of praying, another user shared a clip from this unknown anime where Muslims instantly drop to the ground at the first sound of the azaan. Also, the Muslims are devoid of any and all colour. They are quite literally grey, as opposed to the non-Muslims.
A user shared a screenshot from a video game in which the Arabic text wasn’t even properly formatted, with each letter in the script being written separately. The tweet read, “Literally any movie, TV series or video game where they are so lazy that no one bothers to buy a word editor or proper font support for Adobe which allows them to write Arabic script properly instead of separate letters thrown together.”
Literally any movie, tv series or video game where they are so lazy that no one bother to buy a word editor or proper font support for Adobe which allows them to write Arabic script properly instead of separate letters thrown together. 😭 https://t.co/OkKR1WcSxh pic.twitter.com/Y96kVYojtw— Fouzan (@FQBarca) September 11, 2021
Another spoke about the erasure of language diversity amongst Muslims on screen, writing, "Anytime a media shows Muslims talking in a language that isn't Arabic, but is labelled Arabic in the subtitled."
anytime a media shows Muslims talking in a language that isn’t Arabic but is labelled Arabic in the subtitles… https://t.co/X377J1sfAr— Khaver خاور (@thekarachikid) September 11, 2021
Highlighting the white saviour trope, a user tweeted, “The Muslim falling in love with the white Christian boy to save her from her parents’ oppression”
The muslim falling in love with the white Christian boy to save her from her parents oppression 😐 https://t.co/iaitQUlqEr— 🏳 (@KurdDin) September 11, 2021
“Yeah, they all suck. Muslim characters are either the token liberated Muslim character or a terrorist. If they do have a good Muslim character, they’re usually portrayed by someone who is not of the same faith,” wrote an exasperated user.
yeah they all suck. muslim characters are either the token liberated muslim character or a terrorist. if they do have a good muslim character, they’re usually portrayed by someone who is not of the same faith like the 13th warrior https://t.co/Xw51TkRmc6— tired egg (@tired__eggg) September 12, 2021
Another user shared the sentiment, tweeting about the stereotypical Muslims in media. “There’s the three B’s syndrome: billionaires, bombers, and belly dancers. Then there’s the negative portrayal of Muslim women, and I don’t know where to begin. Basically, Muslims are underrepresented, and when they are represented, it’s negative, naïve, and derogatory,” they wrote.
There’s the three B’s syndrome: billionaires, bombers, and bell dancers.— Reem Al-Harmi ريم الحرمي #SaveSheikhJarrah (@Reem_AlHarmi) September 11, 2021
Then there’s the negative portrayal of Muslim women, and I don’t know where to begin.
Basically, Muslims are underrepresented, and when they are represented, it’s negative, naïve, and derogatory.
However, there was some positivity sprinkled into the mix. One user pointed out the character of Dr Rahul Nadeem from Marvel’s Daredevil. “One of my faves is Detective Rahul Nadeem from Daredevil, a really nice principled family guy conflicted by fisk’s corruption,” they tweeted.
What’s actually the best ones though let’s ask that, since almost all are terrible.— Sakib (@mertesakib) September 11, 2021
One of my fave is Detective Rahul Nadeem from Daredevil, really nice principled family guy conflicted by fisk’s corruption pic.twitter.com/HkY67OSpkG
In the same vein, another user tweeted about Christopher Lee as Muhammad Ali Jinnah. Despite the fact that the character was played by a white man, for this user, the portrayal did justice to the character. They tweeted, “Literally every single one. I don't think there's ever been a positive or meaningful portrayal of a Muslim except Muhammad Ali Jinnah played by Christopher Lee in Jinnah. That being said he did him justice so I'll allow it just this once.”
Literally every single one. I don't think there's ever been a positive or meaningful portrayal of a Muslim except Muhammad Ali Jinnah played by Chirstopher Lee in Jinnah.— Nabs (Makoto & Akechi's Husband) (@ANabs96) September 11, 2021
That being said he did him justice so I'll allow it just this once. https://t.co/E3DV3toQxl
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ