‘Clueless’ Krishna asks Pak to release Chishty

Manmohan Singh steps in to correct stumbling minister.

Aditi Phadnis August 12, 2011

NEW DEHLI: Neighbouring ministers, it transpires, are gaffe-prone too. Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had to intervene on Thursday when External Affairs Minister SM Krishna stumbled over a reply in the upper house of parliament on the issue of the release of Pakistani national Dr Khalil Chishty.

Eighty-year-old Chishty, a virologist sentenced to life imprisonment last December, has been languishing in Ajmer jail in Rajasthan on a murder charge. When asked by an opposition MP from Bihar Shivanand Tiwari what the government of India was doing about Chishty’s release, Krishna said the onus was on the government of Pakistan to release him.

Krishna said that this ‘particular person’ was detained in Pakistan and it was a question to be considered by the government of that country on ‘humanitarian grounds.’

As appalled and confused MPs got up to stop Krishna, he went on: “Dr Chishty is more than 80 years old, is wheelchair bound and we are sure the Government of Pakistan would take a lenient view about the case.”

He added that India would take this issue up at the level of High Commissioners, before being slammed by opposition MPs that the minister was confused about the identity of the prisoner and had little idea about Pakistani prisoners in Indian jails.

Manmohan Singh eventually stepped in to save Krishna’s bacon. He explained that Chishty was serving a sentence in a prison in Rajasthan, that he has received a request for his release and had referred the matter to the Home Minister who was in touch with the Rajasthan government. He also said he would report further developments to the house.

This is not the first gaffe by the Indian foreign minister. Earlier this year, he read the speech of the Portuguese Foreign Minister by mistake at a United Nations Security Council meeting. Three minutes into the speech he was interrupted by fellow Indian envoy.

Chishty was implicated in a murder case in 1992 while on a visit to India to see his ailing mother.

The criminal case was pending for 18 years, during which period Chishty was granted bail but with a stringent condition that he should not leave Ajmer, among other conditions. Tiwari, speaking to reporters later, said he was embarrassed to see that an 80-year-old national of a neighbouring country was facing this situation.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 12th, 2011.


Dr Priyanka | 11 years ago | Reply

@Mirza: Don't worry! Hinaji was a hit with Indians. And Mr Krishna and the old generation have nothing against Pakistan. It is the new generation which is being fed lies by a country [ saat samundar paar se] and they are smug in the knowledge that if India is fine everything is ok. They are not bothered about their neighbour !

Abdul Rahman Khan | 11 years ago | Reply

@vickram: I totally disagree with you Mr vickram that our government in pakistan is less corrupt than yours. Most of our prersent rulers have dual nationalities and overseas interest. They have posted all corrupt persons on all key posts in the establishment. So, who will point finger at whom? Every one of them is making money and a few honest and spotless government servants are victimised, marginalized and sent to posts where they have nothing to do. In such deplorable conditions who is to be blamed for this state of affairs in both the countries - THE BROAD MASSES OF PEOPLE who bring these corrupt leaders to power. Arise, 1.5 billion people of south asia to come out of the grip of the hereditary politicians. Both AICC and PPP had reaped enough for the sacrifices of indira gandhi and zulfikar ali bhutto.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read