Fake news spread on WhatsApp to Indian Americans plays stealth role in US election

Messages on WhatsApp are confidential and cannot be seen by moderators who police misleading content

OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA:

New Jersey tech entrepreneur Arun Bantval is US presidential candidate Joe Biden’s top fake-news watchdog on messaging service WhatsApp about the Democrat and his Indian American running mate Kamala Harris.

Messages on WhatsApp, owned by Facebook, are confidential and cannot be seen by moderators who police misleading memes, claims, and other content on the social media giant’s flagship platform. Two billion users rely on WhatsApp’s free app to chat with individuals and groups of up to 256 people.

Bantval, 56, who chairs the Biden campaign’s five-member rapid response team focused on South Asian voters, has tracked dozens of concerning messages of unknown origin and crafted about 50 rebuttal graphics and texts over the last three months.

His team and similar ones at nonpartisan groups are trying to fill WhatsApp’s moderation void by joining big WhatsApp groups and asking community leaders to report items.

Fighting fake news on social media such as Facebook and Twitter has become standard practice for campaigns. But apps for secret messaging such as WhatsApp have flown under the radar despite serving as a crucial political forum among middle-aged Indians, Latinx, and other immigrant groups.

South Asian voters, mostly Indian Americans, will be pivotal in the November 3 contest in swing states such as Florida, North Carolina, and Pennsylvania where results will be close and predict the national outcome, researchers and nonpartisan voting advocacy groups say.

Internet group condemns lack of transparency in formulation of Pakistan's digital policy

About 72% of Indian-American registered voters plan to back Biden, according to a September survey by Carnegie Endowment. But South Asian Biden supporters and nonpartisan activists worry that misinformation on WhatsApp will affect turnout and support.

“There’s just a lot of inaccurate information for an already confusing process,” said Chavi Khanna Koneru, executive director of nonpartisan group North Carolina Asian Americans Together.

“And this year is different for everybody because we’re relying on virtual connections more than ever.”

Each day, users can receive hundreds of memes, videos, voicemails, and texts spanning greetings, social invitations, and political propaganda. Users regularly forward shocking and humorous messages, with the original sender’s name automatically stripped, making it hard to trace them.

“It’s almost like going viral on Facebook,” Bantval said.

WhatsApp said its role in US politics is small. But political misinformation on WhatsApp in Brazil, India, and elsewhere prompted the service beginning in 2018 to limit recipients when forwarding messages.

It also introduced a chatbot that users can message to access fact checks by internationally recognised organisations. But when Reuters queried the system for topics in messages sent to South Asian voters, it generated zero results.

WhatsApp also said users can search the web from heavily forwarded messages to find relevant fact checks, though Reuters again found no related results.

A campaign spokeswoman for Republican incumbent Donald Trump said WhatsApp was not a focus for its social media staff. But some misleading messages on the app target him over racial justice policies and alleged extramarital affairs, according to Indian voters from both parties.

“There’s more on the Democratic candidates, but there is fake news about the Republican side, too,” said Kannan Srinivasan, an Orlando businessman.

TAPPING INTO FEARS

It is unclear where WhatsApp misinformation originates or whether the examples observed by Bantval and others are part of organised efforts. They said spelling and wording suggest some authors are Indian residents who view Trump as better for bilateral relations.

WhatsApp to start charging for business services

Messages are seen by Reuters and sent to swing-state voters portray Biden’s views on Pakistan, Islam, China, taxation, and policing in ways debunked by fact-checking groups.

Bantval said the misrepresentations preyed on older Indian immigrants' concerns about crime, wealth, and religion.

Other messages sent to South Asian voters in Texas and North Carolina, seen by Reuters, contain false claims that ballots will not count when voters select a Democrat in every contest or when election officials sign dropped off ballots.

Koneru estimated her North Carolina group spends about 15% of its time correcting inaccuracies about voting procedures on WhatsApp and other popular services compared with 2% during the 2016 presidential election.

“We do our best to jump in and clarify but there are so many WhatsApp groups,” she said.