Yasir Hussain believes Turkish TV shows will destroy the industry
Taking to Twitter, Mansha pointed out why she agreed with Yasir just this one time, saying, "Those lambasting Yasir Hussain and calling the work in Pakistan "sub-par" seem to have forgotten what it takes to make content here."
Those lambasting Yasir Hussain and calling the work in Pakistan "sub-par" seem to have forgotten what it takes to make content here. Even without any subsidy from the govt, even if u manage to gather ur own funds, ur projects can still bet banned or pulled off after clearance
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
She went on to highlight how the local entertainment industry does not get state patronage and thus, suffers. Mansha lamented how, even if some people manage to gather their own funds and make content, they get banned, citing Sarmad Khoosat's Zindagi Tamasha.
"Don't like the content here? Wonder why our content isn't as great as others? Because they have state patronage and we don't. And currently we are giving state patronage to foreign projects. Go figure," said Mansha.
Like Sarmad Khoosat's film "Zindagi Tamasha."
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
Dont like the content here? Wonder why our content isnt as great as others?
Because they have state patronage and we dont.
And currently we are giving state patronage to foreign projects.
Go figure.
She then continued to back up her argument, adding a link to an article that listed all the grants that the Turkish Government provides to its local industry - pointing out the importance of state patronage for arts.
The following are articles regarding grants the Turkish Government provides to its local industry and cash rebates that encourage foreign industries to shoot in Turkey. https://t.co/YAkWreJHx8https://t.co/niRPL2hbxv
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
This is what state patronage for the arts looks like.
Many people naturally presented their own arguments and Mansha came with receipts to defend her point. When a user implied that there hasn't been the same hue and cry for earlier Turkish content, Mansha posted a link to a seven-year-old article that details the industry's outcry at the airing of serials like Ishq-e-Mamnoon.
7 yrs ago when the popular turkish drama Ishq e Mamnoon led to a series of Urdu dubbed foreign dramas played on local tv, many actors protested.
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
A similar debate ensued regd local vs foreign content.
We dont seem to learn from recent history. https://t.co/lxBoxyaatk
Khuda ko mano bhaee!
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
I just shared articles where industry protested ishq e mamnoon and other turkish plays 7 yrs ago.
Also there are many sources that speak on the historical accuracy or lack of in the drama. Pls keep the argument to drama only!
https://t.co/UzU7InLmNu https://t.co/zievmPWqxl
Another user listed the kind of content that our local industry is churning out. "We need to watch more of the current content - mother-in-law and daughter-in-law controversies, husbands assaulting their wives, husband divorcing their wives..."
https://twitter.com/ZayHussain/status/1262132085931868161
Mansha called this generalisation 'supremely annoying.'
This painting of all dramas with a single brush is supremely annoying and just plain wrong.
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
Alif, ehd e wafa and so many other numerous dramas that have been aired in the past few years dont follow this theme.
Bas bhi kardo 🙏 https://t.co/1nf8RdrnVj
She also pointed out another fact worth noting - not all Turkish dramas are like Ertuğrul.
Yes and all Turkish dramas are ertugrul right?
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
Please stop using the anomaly to support ur argument as well 😊 https://t.co/upd1ItrQqb
In the end, she did clear her stance that she does not agree with Yasir on a lot of other things but this time, she does agree with him.
And also (argh i have to say this because ppl are like this)
— Mansha Pasha (@manshapasha) May 17, 2020
I dont agree with everything Yasir H has said in his entire life just cuz i agree with him regd state sponsoring foreign content.
Infact have disagreed with him publicly and privately on many things.
Mansha isn't the only one who voiced her opinion on the matter - Anoushey Ashraf also chimed in saying that the "trolls defending Ertuğrul's airing in Pakistan could have used better language for their own actors."
She also reminded people how their "Ertuğrul wouldn't have lectured, hated and abused him (Yasir). He would have seen it as exploring 'two sides to a story.'"
Safe to say, Yasir seems to have some support for his statements despite the intense backlash that ensued after he initially made his statements which said how "Landay ke kaprey aur Turkey ki dramey, dono hi local industry to tabah kardenge (Second-hand clothes and Turkish dramas will ruin the local industry)."
Have something to add to the story? Share it in the comments below
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ