Hrithik Roshan features in a film on Mohenjo Daro while we ignore our heritage: Fatima Bhutto

Published: February 18, 2020

KARACHI  : Renowned writer and columnist, Fatima Bhutto’s new book about pop culture commentary titled New Kings of the World is the talk of the town these days. On Monday, the author sat down with a bunch of enthusiasts and fans at Liberty Books Clifton and spilled the beans on her latest offering.

“My book talks about power, neoliberalism, globalisation and other things I’ve written about before. But I was tired of always feeling like our stories were not the stories,” she told the audience.

Bhutto added that regardless of someone’s geographical location; the West had always been considered the center of the world, until now. “Where we’re standing, should be our center, we won’t say we’re the South of this or East of that. So I think the West’s moment is coming to a close.” WhatsApp Image 2020-02-18 at 5.16.35 PM

She explained how a new wave is coming forward and Trump’s regime is a sign of the anxiety and panic that prevails in the West. “They still want us to believe that they’re the height of enlightenment, but really they’re not. It doesn’t mean that we’re the height either, but we’re in an interesting position, which can’t be judged from the lens of politics alone. Culture is an interesting way to look at it because it’s accessible. It’s still loaded with agendas but we can all connect to it. Not everyone may be interested in politics, but everyone watches films and listens to music.”

She emphasised her point about redefining the center of the world by playing videos about Bollywood’s influence on the working class of Peru. She had recorded the things she discovered on her journey across the places she included in her book – nitpicking the ones that had emerged as the most influential pop culture grounds during the 2000s.

“I also wanted to include China but you can’t even begin a conversation on it within 50,000 words, which was the word limit assigned to me.” She also said she wanted to include Nigeria and write about the franchising of cricket. “But obviously American publishers weren’t interested in cricket,” she laughed.

Bhutto’s book focuses on India, South Korea, and Turkey, however, had she started writing it today, she wouldn’t have included India. “I started working on the proposal for this book in 2016. If I would’ve started today I wouldn’t have included India because the Bollywood industry is taking a more propagandist approach.”


She explained how she chose Turkey because today it is second to America in terms of global television distribution. “The Brave and Beautiful at its peak was watched by an audience of 26 million. Mera Sultan at its peak was watched by 200 million. Unofficially, they told me that number is now 500 million,” said Bhutto.

Then she explained how South Korea was fascinating because of the K-Pop scene and its story of being the first non-Western country to successfully export all its culture. It overcame the IMF and Asian financial crisis of 1997, which was an incredibly humiliating time for them.

“They had to rebuild their economy but they couldn’t do that so easily because they had no natural resources, or agricultural land – they couldn’t have rebuilt it on ginseng alone,” she giggled. “They are also not allowed to pursue military technology because of their defense pact with North America. Not to mention, their reliance on massive corporations like Samsung and Hyundai is what got them into trouble in the first place. But the president of that time, Kim de Jong, was inspired by Hollywood’s pop culture and Korea put all its efforts behind their cultural ministries”

She also added that South Korea started providing broadband connectivity to its people back then in 1984, which is why by 2015; their average internet connection speed was 200 times faster than an American connection. “Music brings Korea five billion dollars a year, video games bring it a 1000 times more than that,” she stated.

In the process of explaining the cultural impact of one cinema on another, Fatima then emphasised on the utilisation of the Pakistani film industry. She said “John, one of the people I interviewed for this book was a film enthusiast. He said ‘listen, I’m not a big fan of Shahrukh Khan, but I do love Rajnikanth.’ After this, he started talking about Shaan’s latest film, which came as a shock to me.”

Bhutto closed off her talk by stressing on the need for making films and music representative of the bold and brave history of our nation, so that politics, military and the need for peace can be better understood. Moreover, “the need for image building is massive,” she said. Adding that the narrative we produce is necessary to counter-correct the narratives produced elsewhere – but not for propaganda purposes.

“I don’t understand why Hrithik Roshan can be in a film featuring Mohenjo Daro but we can’t make a film on our heritage!” said Bhutto furiously. “In Raazi, Alia Bhatt can walk in a place representative of Pakistan, with posters titled ‘Crush India’, but I’ve never seen such posters in Pakistan. Where is that narrative coming from and why can’t we challenge it by building a different image?” she ended up questioning.

New Kings of the World is now available in all local book stores, priced at Rs1000.

Have something to add to the story? Share it in the comments below. 

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (2)

  • Ali Jan
    Feb 19, 2020 - 5:17PM

    Besides Trump, the west (mainly the United States) is home to most of the world’s top 20 universities. Ms. Bhutto seems to be forgetting that it is not the west’s politics but education, economy, and advancement in fields of science and technology that make it so great and dominant.Recommend

  • Ali Jan
    Feb 19, 2020 - 5:17PM

    Besides Trump, the west (mainly the United States) is home to most of the world’s top 20 universities. Ms. Bhutto seems to be forgetting that it is not the west’s politics but education, economy, and advancement in fields of science and technology that make it so great and dominant.Recommend

Leave Your Reply Below

Your comments may appear in The Express Tribune paper. For this reason we encourage you to provide your city. The Express Tribune does not bear any responsibility for user comments.

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

More in Art and Books