Tahira, a 28-year-old woman, living in a shanty town in Lahore, has given birth to five children in her eight years of marriage.
Her oldest child is a seven-year-old son and her youngest are three-year-old twins — a girl and a boy. Her second child died as an infant. After her third child, she compulsively went to a government health unit to get contraceptives — she did not want more.
“They placed an implant. But it reacted adversely with my system. I gained weight and started having severe body pain, so I decided to give up contraceptives altogether,” Tahira laughs and adds that the twins came after that incident.
Now the couple is facing financial conundrums — her husband earns a meager salary of Rs9,000 a month. Tahira has decided to get an operation; a treatment medically known as sterilisation. But she fears since her previous treatments did not go well.
Dr Muhammad Saeed, a gynecologist, explains about misconceptions about contraceptives in Pakistan.
“Women tend to believe that all illnesses occurring after using contraceptive methods are related to them, without any biological correlation,” says Dr Saeed.
He points out that since reproductive health units come under the social welfare department, staffers do not consult medical experts from the health department and this creates a serious problem in addressing health issues related to contraceptives.
According to the Economic Survey 2010-11, Pakistan has the highest fertility rate of 3.5 in South Asia, with the lowest contraceptive prevalence rate of 30 per cent. Dr Saeed adds that religious beliefs are one of biggest hurdles in increasing contraceptive prevalence amongst women in Pakistan.
Muneera, a mother of six, was recently visited by a team of the Population Welfare Department, to inform her of birth control methods but she is reluctant.
“They asked me to come to the clinic, but my mother-in-law will not approve of it. It is because of her that I have so many children, since she wanted grandsons,” adds Muneera.
Punjab Secretary Population Javed Akhtar says after the recent devolution of the Ministry of Population that funding “is now becoming a major issue in giving quality reproductive health services”. But he expects that the federal government will honour its commitment of providing Rs3 billion for the on-going year to develop this sector.
“Political and social support is what we still lack and that is why population is not on the priority list of our government either,” said Akhtar.
When asked about religious problems encountered with government initiatives, he said that the government should alter the slogan, adding that instead of highlighting “two children are enough” it should focus on “space between children” since they had difficulty breaking the mind barriers associated with birth control.
According to a development economist, Qais Aslam, currently only 55 million people in Pakistan – which is less than one-third of the population – are feeding themselves and the rest.
The United Nations projects that world population will surpass seven billion by October. According to a statement released for World Population Day by Dr Babatunde Osotimehin, the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) executive director, the world needs to work together to meet the needs of some 215 million women in developing countries who want to plan and space their births but do not have access to modern contraception.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 12th, 2011.
COMMENTS (23)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@ Moise - Thanks. I am a different kind of an author then eh? A better one i hope.. :).. And yes you are right but the question comes down to the enabling environment to optimize this resource which is in fact majorly missing. Please do share feedback. Its always good to know what the reader thinks...
@Moise, LOL, I don't know how much I agree with you but I certainly admire your tenacity for going against the popular opinion here.
@Moise.....sheesh plz "GET REAL"
@KM: Please just be quiet.
Sorry but this is not Third Reich. It is not government job to decide how many babies they want. The government that cannot manage passport office correctly can be expected to enforce baby limits.
I have well over 8 uncles and aunts, they turned out pretty good by education and life standards. Leading positions in financial institution, foreign chemical company, research center in KU, electrical engineer, doctor, administration and teacher. They didn't have much money, lived in house that shook when trains passed by but all of them did pretty good.
Less babies don't mean better life, more money, less carbon footprint and whatever nonsense elitists and Henry Kissinger fan club can come up with.
All posts point in one direction; the poor and uneducated must not have more children. Agreed. The wealthy and educated must have more children. Agreed?
@Moise: please just be quiet. these people dont have any money, they have 6-10 kids, the kids live in utter squaler without education, and beg on the streets. only the uneducated people think its ok to have dozens of kids. If people cant afford it, they shouldnt have kids. end of story. btw i am a woman & i chose to have 2 kids because i know that any more than that and i wouldnt be able to look after them or provide good things for them.
And the world specially doesn't need uneducated Pakistani kids that are not only going to be a burden on the society but will probably end up in a madrassah only to be abused and brain washed and become even a bigger problem.
World doesn't need more people than it already has. Human beings are like a virus, cancer, where ever they go they destroy, pillage and plunder.
How many of you are parents to know what you guys are talking about? I have a adorable little girl and we both earn a reasonable sum of money. Therefore, we dont need to grow our own food and sew our own clothes. But if we did then we would have to stop working or neglect our child. Nothing in this world is free and eight children are a huge drain on energy and time that can be spent on gathering resources. That is the reason why middle class people have less families because they can focus their resources on quality than quantity. Eight children, no matter how cute, would mean that wife (or me) has to stop working and food that is negligible part of the budget has to grow and be of lower quality..... everyone suffers.
We blame population and illiteracy for all the evils Pakistan is facing. Going by the logic of pro-popn-cntrl. groups, people who can afford to feed and educate should have more children. This will improve the literacy rate in future. Unfortunately, contrary is happening. Educated and well off people are opting for lesser children while the poor are having more. As educated and financially well off Pakistanis, we all must start planning big families.
@Taha Siddiqui [Author]: First of all thank you for commenting, most authors dont engage in conversations.
I am not against contraception for mothers' health but the rationale of less population will somehow make things better in Pakistan is not going to fly.
Problem is with incompetence of economic managers of our country. Large population can be used in creating economic production and creating wealth for the country, China is a good example.
Throughout history if you have large middle class that will result in economic prosperity. Higher wages, less inflation tax and better law and order is needed for this country. Blaming babies won't solve the problem.
@ Moise: If you do focus on the closing line regarding the developmental economist, Mr. Qais Aslam, we are not utilizing the workforce, on the other hand, my article highlights that we continue to produce more babies. It may look like a contraception ad to you but think about the fact that unless we do not educate and provide the enabling environment for Pakistan, we cannot afford to have more children. Let's build with what we have, and prevent its further deterioration. Thanks for your feedback though...
@Danish: Yes, it is not easy for city dwellers.
@Ayesha: Ah yes, the Hegelian dialect.
Please bring something original, this type of spin I have already read since 80s, it is nothing but dogma. Last time I checked there was a population crisis in not only in first world but also China.
@Moise
Its not enforcement. We are not living in China. Its about educating women..and more so..MEN. Who for the desperation to have SONS keep making their wives go through child birth, without worrying about their health.
Its about educating people how they can make their ends meet with less children, rather than opting for selling their kids..as we read in newspapers every now and then. Proper guidance can help you put things in perspective, rather than just going with the flow..and having 12 children.
@ayesha: Who gave the government the right to decide number of kids one woman can have? So much for freedom of West.
@Jim Beam: Conspiracy? “If I were reincarnated, I would wish to be returned to Earth as a killer virus to lower human population levels.” - Prince Phillip (Husband to queen, Oligarch, Nazi supporter)
Here is one of the member of the Oligarchs of today. Do you want more?
@Moise
You make it sound so easy. Wonder if you can sew your own clothes or grow your own food. If I build my own roof, it doesn't mean it'll cost nothing
@Hasan: Really bothers someone when you find the source of words they are parroting.
Rs. 9000 doesnt mean you cant grow your own food. Rs. 9000 doesnt mean you cant home school. Rs. 9000 doesnt mean you cant make sew your own clothes. Rs. 9000 doesnt mean you cant make your own roof.
@Moise : Not everything that you don't agree with is a conspiracy! Scarce resources / Growing Population = Less Resources per Person... You don't even have to be smart to understand that.equation.
I wonder why there is so much hate for contraception..and why do people associate family planning with some outside agenda or conspiracy. Why cant people understand that we need less population to have a healthy generation which is educated.
its a good piece..but i don't think that govt's policy of GAP will help. girls in Pakistan get married at the age of 20..and have many years to reproduce...so even with gaps..they will keep having children. Policy of 2 kids was better.
Lets see how far Moise can go with five kids and only Rs.9,000. Its easy to sit in your air conditioned house/office and eloquently quote Greek myths.
Looks like a PR piece by contraception special interests.
Oligarchs and their hate for population goes way back. According to Oligarchs, Zeus believed that there were too many people populating the earth, he envisioned Momus or Themis, who was to use the Trojan War as a means to depopulate the Earth, especially of his demigod descendants.