Insecure minorities: Threatened at home, jailed abroad

Ahmadis escaping persecution in Pakistan detained by Thai authorities.

Abdul Manan July 04, 2011


Tahir Mehmood Adil, an Ahmadi from Sialkot, was kidnapped in 2009 by militants, held captive for 36 days and threatened with beheading. His cousin, Sajjad, negotiated successfully for his release. A few days later, however, Sajjad was shot dead and Adil received a text message saying he would be next.

That was when Adil fled to Thailand with his wife and three children. On arrival, he was arrested by Thai immigration authorities who tore up their asylum papers and took them to Bangkok’s notorious Immigration Detention Cell (IDC). The family was detained here for the next seven months in the most inhumane conditions.

Detained refugees

Adil is one of 96 such refugees from Pakistan whose fate hangs in balance as they are transferred from one detention centre to another, despite having their status recognised by the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR).

By December 2010, the Thai immigration bureau detained 91 Pakistanis seeking asylum on grounds of religious persecution in their home country. Another 38 were detained in the early months of 2011.

Of the 131 Ahmadis at Bangkok’s Suan Phlu IDC, 35 were sent back in the last week of December. The remaining 96 refused to budge on grounds that it amounted to suicide. These persons were finally released with the support of the Thai committee for refugees in June.

The group now reports to the immigration bureau every month. Their situation has improved as compared to their time in the IDC but they are not allowed to leave their residence without permission from the local police.

Inhumane conditions

This group, including 34 children, now lives in two separate confinement centres and apartments in a Bangkok suburb. Each family has a single room. For them there is some light at the end of the tunnel. The refugees are awaiting resettlement to third countries, mainly the US.

The conditions at the detention centre were worse, says Adil as he looks back at his time there.  The cells where they were detained were designed to hold around 40 but housed 150 detainees. Women and children were separated from the men.

The choice was clear. Stay in the IDC or go back to Pakistan. It is an unending battle. Two of the detainees who have been in IDC for 23 months were granted bail but the UNHCR refused to recognise their status.  Two others who were at the last step of their resettlement process were told to repeat the entire process.

Painful process

Adil told The Express Tribune that everyone had a story to tell. He acknowledged that even though they were aware of Thailand not being a signatory to the UNHCR’s convention on refugees, their fate in Pakistan was one which would be worse and that is why they decided to come here.

Adil said that the process of seeking asylum and refugee status from UNHCR was lengthy and painful. He said interviews don’t take place for months, much beyond the mandatory three-month period. The resettlement is another lengthy process in which refugees are informed about their final destination.

Individual stories

The stories go on. Qamar and Mansoor who had been in the centre for the last two years had been granted bail but they were later refused refugee status. After their release, their resettlement process had slowed down.

One Rana Qamar had been detained along with his two children while his wife was in Pakistan.  Qamar’s 11 year old daughter, Areesha, was detained for seven months all alone.

Another detainee, Adnan Rashid, said that he was in detention but his wife and two children were not. He feared for them.

Doctors who escaped targeted killings at home are
also part of the group. Dr Hafeez Ahmad, who hails from Karachi said that after his colleagues, Dr Hameedullah Shah and Dr Najamul Hassan were shot dead he decided to leave. But not after shifting his clinic four times in a bid to discourage those targeting him.

Kashif Butt whose wife gave birth to their child in the IDC recalls his horrible experience. When his wife was taken to the nearby hospital, her legs were tied so she could not run away. In another case, a Pakistani woman’s feet were bound when she went in for a caesarean procedure.

Every day is a living hell for many. The Ahmadiyya Community representative in Thailand Imran Ahmad told The Express Tribune that the future of those family members who later joined their next of kin hangs in balance.

Despite all the frustration and the fear, most are fearful of returning to Pakistan. Some laugh and others cry at the mention of their home country. But all pray for their future and for those left behind.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 4th, 2011.

Our Publications

Most Read


Burhan | 9 years ago | Reply

@Ghulam Basheer:

No hatred material have been spread by Ahmadis. This maybe your disinformation or your lack of vision. Visit Official website of Jammat Ahmadiyya and links of other website of jammat are also on this website. This is the only authentic source of information for ahmadis. You must not have read hatred material spread by oppenents. Our moto is LOVE FOR ALL HATRED FOR NONE. So please try to be fair. And if any individual speaks something hatred against others, this is disliked by jammat. And giving answers to allegations is not spreading hatred material.

Whole Pakistan is crying for its right and similarly we raise our voice peacefully which is our right and this is not whinning. We practise Islam peacefully and spread message of Islam peacefully and not like other religious parties who create chaos in country and spread hatred against each other and who forcefully tries to stop others from practising their beleives as they did with Ahmadis i.e we can't say kalima or give azaan or say salam..cant build mosques etc. So you should have referred to other religious parties to practise their beleives silently and let others also practise it.

And not each and every Ahmadi is targeted indivdually and you need to explore your common sense that when few of us are at target whole Pakistan becomes tense. SOme areas are targeted more some less and some havn't yet been targeted but still there is fear. Similarly when any ahmadi Muslim is targeted fear is created at large. And its neccasary to raise our voice peacefully not like others who protest and become a source of pain for our own people.

May Allah have mercy on all of us.Aameen!

MAS | 9 years ago | Reply

tribune is promoting hatred against the state of Pakistan and this should be noticed by the government and the true patriots

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ