Indian govt in new dogfight over French fighters deal

Opposition calls for a corruption probe


Afp March 07, 2019
Prime Minister Narendra Modi said this week that the result of the brief aerial clash with Pakistan would have been "better" if India had Rafales. PHOTO: AFP

NEW DELHI: India's opposition on Thursday called for a corruption probe into a multi-billion-dollar fighter jet deal, raising pressure on Prime Minister Narendra Modi as government lawyers threatened a leading newspaper with legal action for revealing details.

New Delhi agreed in 2016 to purchase 36 Rafale jets from France but the deal has been embroiled in misconduct allegations, which resurfaced in the wake of air battles last month with Pakistan that raised questions about the capacity of the Indian Air Force.

India struck Pakistan's territory during the skirmishes. Pakistan Air Force (PAF) shot down two Indian fighters and New Delhi.

India being pushed for ‘direct talks’ with Pakistan

Modi said this week that the result of the brief aerial clash with Pakistan would have been "better" if India had Rafales while accusing the opposition of hampering the deal he signed with Paris at an estimated cost of $9.4 billion.

During a Supreme Court hearing late on Wednesday, The Hindu newspaper - which ran a series of reports on the deal - was warned it faces charges under the Official Secrets Act over defence ministry documents it cited in its coverage.

Attorney General K K Venugopal said the files - which indicated the defence ministry was angry because Modi's office had carried out rival negotiations for the Rafales - had been "stolen".

"The government claims that the documents were stolen. Doesn't that mean the documents are authentic?" said Rahul Gandhi, head of the opposition Congress party which has led a longstanding onslaught against the deal.

He added: "The PM's name clearly figures in the documents, saying the prime minister's office is carrying out parallel negotiations. Let's have an inquiry into that as well."

French company Dassault initially won a contract negotiated under a Congress-led government in 2012 to supply 126 jets to India, with 18 built in France and the rest in India by state-owned Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL).

But during a visit to France in 2015, Modi scrapped the deal, replacing it with an order for 36 jets - all to be built in France.

The new agreement, formally signed in 2016, named Reliance group, a conglomerate owned by billionaire Anil Ambani, as Dassault's local partner. Ambani is reported to be close to the governing party and Reliance had little experience in the aviation sector.

The government has strongly denied any misconduct in its renegotiation of the deal and accuses Congress of undermining national security to win votes.

The Hindu published details which indicated the price of the jets had risen because normal procedures were bypassed.

India humiliated on international level: minister

India's attorney-general said an investigation is underway into the newspaper, which has stated it will not reveal where its information came from.

The Hindu group chairman N Ram said: "We did not steal the documents from the ministry of defence, we got them from confidential sources and no force on earth can make me or us reveal the source."

The Supreme Court is hearing a series of petitions seeking a review of a previous ruling that declined a demand for investigation into the deal. The next hearing is on March 14.

The first Rafales for India are scheduled to be delivered in 2019.

COMMENTS (2)

Ties | 3 years ago | Reply They better buy Russian jets if they want the winning edge.... Russia is cheaper and much better then all the rest
cuban | 3 years ago | Reply Anyone surprised? I can't think of a major contract between India/France that hasn't been tainted with gross corruption.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read