
We had Indian Army Chief General Bipin also speaking on the subject. Before writing what he said I would recommend the readers to read a column I wrote in The Express Tribune on September 28, 2017 titled ‘The Bipin Doctrine’ — a general who draws fame for conducting surgical strikes in Myanmar and who continues to threaten Pakistan with doing the same when asked about the ongoing peace talks between the Americans and the Taliban answered “we welcome peace talks as long as they don’t have any pre-conditions.” If war is an art or as Carl Von Clausewitz defined it as a political act then are not these politicians and the generals the artists? The job or function of any good artist is to express the sentiment of the people which they feel but cannot articulate. I think there is an overwhelming demand for peace in Afghanistan not only by the domestic audience but by all the neighbouring countries and the international audience as well.
The Taliban’s preconditions of the exodus of US forces from Afghanistan and their unwillingness to talk to an Afghan government that they consider a puppet have been there for 17 long years and they came to the negotiating table carrying the baggage of this demand. Even the US tacitly agreed and the announcement of withdrawal of US forces by President Donald Trump became the very reason for the Taliban to indulge in talks in the first place. Why is General Bipin not aware of it? Even the fourth round of talks between the Americans and the Taliban has been called off due to the incompatibility of understanding on the issue of involvement of Afghan officials, ceasefire and prisoners’ exchange. The real issue should be how to address these incompatibilities and how to reach a negotiated settlement? Not be seized by an impulse and give political statements that can further derail the peace dialogue. Seventeen years of war and the unending political plight in the country yet the political leadership in Afghanistan seems averse to the fact that a negotiated settlement or a dialogue process would need a favourable environment to proceed forward. Such statements would only add padlocks to a deadlocked peace process that has been brought to life after great difficulty.
We already have precedence in Lebanon where a militant organisation, Hezbollah, sought and was granted political representation. It won 13 seats in 2009 elections but in the elections held in 2018 along with its allies and current coalition partners, Hezbollah now holds 71 seats out of 128 in the Lebanese parliament. Would Hezbollah be representing the people in parliament if Israel was still occupying Lebanon? Was their fight against the invading Israeli army in Lebanon unjust? The relative peace and stability that Lebanon has experienced is because of the success of political process. Under the Hamid Karazai government in Afghanistan, it is a matter of record that the Tajiks headed the key ministries, they even made up 70% of the Afghan Army’s battalion commanders (only 27% of Tajiks are Afghans). For years, US air strikes pounded the Pashtun regions and the Taliban, and during that time the Tajiks not only held positions of power and authority but also appeared to grow rich and wealthy.
The US war in Afghanistan was also doomed because the US underestimated the power of group identity. There was deep division amongst Afghanistan’s Shias, Sunnis and Kurds. The US would do well to influence the domestic leadership in Afghanistan by preventing it from speaking in a retaliatory and vengeful language. This only adds fuel to the burning fire that many stakeholders together want to put out. Those that charge the Taliban with committing heinous crimes against humanity must also give an alternative way on how to achieve the goal of “never allowing Afghanistan to serve as a platform for international terrorism”.
Lastly, when Turkey allied with Germany in the First World War, weren’t we Muslims not once fighting against our own Caliph under the British Raj. Truth is a great healer and so is forgiveness.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 13th, 2019.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ