Navy says PNS base under control after attack

Published: May 23, 2011
Soldiers arrive for a military operation against militants at Pakistan's naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP

Soldiers arrive for a military operation against militants at Pakistan's naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP

Screen capture of a terrorist wounded/killed in the attack, shown by Interior Minister Rehman Malik. Pakistani soldiers arrive for an operation against militants at a major Pakistani naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi on May 23, 2011. PHOTO: AFP. Soldiers arrive for an operation against militants at a major Pakistani naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP Wreckage of a P-3C Orion aircraft is seen at a major Pakistani naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP Wreckage of a P-3C Orion aircraft is seen at a the naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi on May 23, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Wreckage of a P-3C Orion aircraft is seen at a the naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi on May 23, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Soldiers arrive for a military operation against militants at Pakistan's naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP Pakistan army helicopter flies over Pakistan's naval air base during an operation against militants following an attack in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP Soldiers arrive for a military operation against militants at Pakistan's naval air base following an attack by militants in Karachi. PHOTO: AFP Ambulances gather outside the PAF base. PHOTO: AFP Flames and smokes belches out from a Pakistani military air base after an attack by militants, in Karachi early on May 23, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Flames and smokes belches out from a Pakistani military air base after an attack by militants in Karachi on May 22, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Flames and smokes erupt from a Pakistan's military air base following an attack by militants in Karachi on May 22, 2011. PHOTO: AFP More than 10 militants late May 22 attacked one of Pakistan's main military bases, used by the navy and air force in Karachi, the country's biggest city. PHOTO: AFP Ambulances arrive outside Pakistan military air base after an attack by militants in Karachi on May 22, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Pakistani troops arrive at Pakistan' military air base after an attack by militants in Karachi on May 22, 2011. PHOTO: AFP Screen capture of the PAF base on fire.

KARACHI: A spokesman for Pakistan’s Navy said Monday that the PNS Mehran base in Karachi was back under control, 17 hours after militants attacked with guns, bombs and rockets.

In an ongoing operation at one of Pakistan’s main military bases, security forces are engaged in a battle against militants who stormed the base late Sunday night. At least 15 security officials have been killed in the operation that continues on Monday morning.

More than 10 terrorists late Sunday attacked the PNS Mehran base on Shahrah-e-Faisal Road, Karachi. At least 15 people, including Navy and Rangers personnel died in the attack.

Towering flames arose from inside the PNS Mehran compound throughout the night.

End of live updates

3:50 pm

Pakistan Navy official said several terrorists have been killed but did not confirm the number. The bodies have been shifted to an unknown location.

3:40 pm

The Pakistan navy has issued an official statement that the operation to kill or capture terrorists who had taken over the compound is over.

Spokesperson added that all the naval assets at PNS Mehran have been secured.

3:20 pm

Express 24/7 correspondent Shaheryar Mirza reports that Interior Minister Rehman Malik who was expected to talk to the press, has left the navy base without making any comment.

3:10 pm

There were about 30 to 40 journalists gathering outside, with seven satellite dishes attached to their trucks.

Helicopters buzzed overhead and the main road outside was closed to traffic. Moin Babar, 35, a technical engineer, said people were trying to understand how the militants made it inside.

“I heard that 15 went in through a sewer,” he said.

Kamran Khalil, 48, a civil engineer, suggested, like many others, a conspiracy. “How can this happen? It’s taking them so long to resolve the issue. India or the CIA could have been behind this. They want to show that Pakistan forces are ineffective.”

Many in Pakistan were furious with the US operation to kill bin Laden without sharing any intelligence beforehand with Islamabad, which they saw as a severe breach of sovereignty.

“This is all a reaction to American policy in Pakistan,” said Atif Ali, a 30-year-old construction worker.

3:00 pm

As troops wound down their assault, some Karachi residents said they could not believe security could have been so lax, Reuters reports.

“If these people can just enter a military base like this,then how can any Pakistani feel safe?” asked Mazhar Iqbal, 28, engineering company administrator taking a lunch break in the shade outside the complex where a crowd had gathered.

“The government and the army are just corrupt. We need newleaders with a vision for Pakistan.”

2:50 pm

Talking to Express 24/7 Brigadier Ghazanfar Ali said that the terrorists had a mechanism in place for targetted attacks on naval assets.

“This attack is possible without inside help, but the possibility cannot be ruled out,” he said.

He added that if taken alive, these terrorists can give valuable information on the groups they are affiliated with.

“There agenda is that Pakistan should be destabilizsed. The message being sent out is that Pakistan nuclear assets are not safe” he said.

Twitter update:

marvisirmed My blood boils.wnt 2 hold gun now. My ppl, my jawaans-all becoming fodder of…dont U dare defend Taliban & AlQaida


kaalakawaa If you think that the attacks are being carried out by CIA/RAW how would pulling out of the War / ending drones end them?


sharmeenochinoy This is the first time #Taliban have attacked military Aircrafts or hardware in #Pakistan– shift in strategy? #karachiattacks


2:30 pm

Tribune reporter Mahnoor Sherazee says the martyred navy officials and injured have been shifted to PNS Shifa and PNS Rahat hospitals. She reports that journalists are not allowed to enter the building.

2:00 pm

The operation to regain control of the Karachi naval base assaulted by Taliban militants has been completed after almost 16 hours of fighting with up to 20 assailants holed up in a building, a security official told Reuters from inside the base.

“The operation is over. The main building has been cleared,” the official said. “For precaution, we are continuing search around for any more terrorists but the main operation is over.”

1:25 pm

Talking to Express 24/7, retired Air Commodore Jamal Hussain said security officials will not announce that operation is complete “till they are absolutely certain the compound is secure.”

“Even if they suspect that one militant is at large, they will not announce that it is over,” he said.

1:05 pm

Express 24/7 correspondent Mirza says the operation has drawn to a close after 14 hours. One helicopter  is still circling the area for surveillance purposes.

12:45 pm

The naval officer shot dead at PNS last night was identified as Lt Syed Yaser Abbas, son or (R) Col Syed Jaffar Abbas. His picture can be viewed here.

Twitter update:

mirza9 Navy officials that left earlier have come back to the #pnsmehran . BMW with four stars on the license plates – can someone ID?

abidhussayn @Razarumi After attack on CID and Abdullah Shah Ghazi, this was first major incident.

Razarumi #Karachi is the base 4 Al-Qaeda. its operatives & leadership tiers live thr. Causing mayhem in the port city is vital 4 Al-Qaeda

12:40 pm

Naval Chief Admiral Nauman Bashir arrives at PNS Mehran base.

Security forces are in the final stage of ending an hours-long siege by Taliban militants of a naval airbase, security officials said on Monday.

“The operation has not finished yet, but is nearing an end,”one security official said. “It’s in the final stages.”

12: 20 pm

Interior Minister Rehman Malik has arrived at the navy base and will brief the media once he is given details of the operation.

“A major area has been cleared,” Malik told reporters. “The sweeping process is continuing.”

Express 24/7 correspondent Shaheryar Mirza reports that high ranking navy officials have left the area, an indication that the operation may be over.

12:15 pm

Talking to Express 24/7, security analyst Ikram Sehgal said “Today the Pakistan Navy is blind; its eyes and ears are gone,” adding that anti-sub capability, electronic intelligence capability, radar capability are all gone.

“We can equate this situation to 9/11. It is a very grave situation,” said Sehgal, adding that neighbouring countries may be involved in planning this attack.

11:25 am

Talking to Express 24/7, Naval spokesperson Irfanul Haq said the operation is underway and security officials are working hard to minimise casualties and damage to naval assets.

Haq confirmed that 12 navy officials have been martyred and 14 injured

11:05 am

Prime minister Yousaf Raza Gilani has phoned Navy chief to dicuss the ongoing operation.

Navy official says officials are “taking maximum care” so as to preserve naval assets.

10:50 am

Ambulances and security vehicles are rushing to the navy base once again.

Two firemen have reportedly been killed in the operation.

“A (single-storey) building in the premises is still under their occupation from where they are exchanging fire with our soldiers,” Interior Minister Rehman Malik told AFP.

10:40 am

Firefight resumes at navy base after 30-minute pause. Security forces are engaged in operation to capture militants alive. Loud shots heard in the vicinity, indicate heavy battle underway at navy base.

Express 24/7 correspondent Ahmed Jung reports that half of the navy base has been secured by security officials and militants have been restricted to one building.

10:30 am

Navy chief says the operation is “heading in the right direction and the situation will be reverted very soon.”

No sounds of gunfire or explosions heard near navy base.

10:25 am

Express 24/7 correspondent Shaheryar Mirza reports taht 30 Frontier Constabulary officials have arrived at the site.  About 200 SSG commandos and rangers are deployed as back-up for the operation.

Mirza adds that there is no official word from the armed forces and police and intelligence officials do not have details on the ongoing operation.

10:20 am

The navy base under attack is 15 miles (24 km) from the Masroor Air Base, Pakistan’s largest and a possible depot for nuclear weapons.

“They (militants) were carrying guns, rocket-propelled grenades (RPG) and hand grenades. They hit the aircraft with an RPG,” Navy spokesman Commander Salman Ali said of the militants.

10:15 am

Talking to Express 24/7, defence analyst Lt Gen (R) Talat Masood said that the militants had sent out a clear message to Pakistani security forces.

“They want to weaken the security insitutions one by one,” he said, adding that the attack was planned with precision.

“They are growing more and more powerful. The state is getting weaker and more helpless.”
10:10 am

Express 24/7 correspondent Shaheryar Mirza reports that sounds of gunfire and explosions have halted, however it is not clear if this signals the end of the operation.

“There is complete silence in the area, but this could be a delaying tactic,” said Mirza.

10:00 am

Express 24/7 correspondent Shaheryar Mirza reports that a man has been arrested from the area due to suspicious activity.

The man was reportedly viewing the ongoing operation through binoculars from a high point.

Twitter update:

sharmeenochinoy TTP soldier tells me our training is better than your military because v are ready 2 die #karachiattacks #Pakistan

madihariaz Don’t want to watch the news, can’t stay away either.

9:50 am

Express 24/7 reporter Ahmed Jung confirms that sophisticated LMG rifles, rocket launchers and Russian hand grenades have been used by the militants in the ongoing battle. The terrorists were dressed in black clothes.

Sources say 6 terrorists have been killed, however their bodies have not been dragged out of the base.

9:40 am

Taliban said that the team of militants they sent into Karachi’s PNS Mehran naval base Sunday night had enough supplies to survive a three-day siege.

“They have enough ammunition and food and they can fight andsurvive for three days,” Taliban spokesman Ehsanullah Ehsan told Reuters.

9:35 am

Two P3C Orion aircrafts have reportedly been destroyed by militants in the attack.

9:25 am

Express 24/7 reporter Ahmed Jung says 26 have explosions have so far taken place at the navy base in the last 12 hours.

Two helicopters are circling the military base in the ongoing operation, and security forces are trying to capture terrorists alive in order to interrogate them.

“Security forces want to know how the militants could enter a base where security is so strict that not even a camera is allowed inside,” says Jung.

9:20 am

The Taliban claimed responsibility for the brazen attack on the base by 15-20 gunmen, saying it was to avenge the killing of al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden on May 2, AFP reports.

“It was the revenge of martyrdom of Osama bin Laden. It wasthe proof that we are still united and powerful,” Ehsanullah Ehsan told Reuters by telephone from an undisclosed location.


Navy spokesman confirms five people have been killed in the attack — four Navy personnel and one Rangers personnel.

Interior Minister Rehman Malik has arrived in Karachi.


A few minutes back massive gunfire forced media personnel to lie down on the ground, reports Ahmed Jung. Fire is still erupting from the spot.

The gun battle has lasted 5 hours.

The Shah Faisal colony drain line leads to a small wall, which allows entrance into the base, says Jung. This was the likely route the terrorists took.


An official speaking on condition of anonymity says at least 4-5 terrorists have been shot dead, but the aim of the operation is to catch the militants alive.

Fire has erupted again as fire fighters paused efforts due to an on going gun battle.

Heavy gunfire is ongoing at PNS Mehran, confirms Express 24/7 reporter Ahmed Jung.


Confirmed reports that Lieutenant Yasir and a fireman, Khalilur Rehman have been killed in the line of duty.


The fires on the PAF base have been completely extinguished, confirms Express 24/7 reporter Ahmed Jung.

Shah Faisal number 5 area sewerage line was used to enter PNS Mehran, say sources on-ground.

“They were equipped with sophisticated weapons,” navy spokesman Commodore Irfanul Haq told Reuters.

Interior Minister Rehman Malik said the militants had attacked from the rear of the base. “We have been able to confine them to one building and an operation is underway either to kill or capture them.”

The Karachi attack evoked memories of an assault on Pakistan’s Army headquarters in the town of Rawalpindi in 2009, and revived concerns that even the most well-guarded installations in the country remain vulnerable.


Terrorists used a sewerage line behind the PNS Mehran to enter the base, unconfirmed reports suggest. Rangers have been deployed at the entrance of the line.

Law enforcement agencies from many towns have been called in to surround the entire base to ensure the terrorists do not escape, confirms Express 24/7 reporter Ahmed Jung.


Ahmed Jung reports that oil tankers exploding due to the fire are the likely cause for the recent blasts on the base.

Emergency services are confirming at least one death in the attack.

It is expected the search operation will continue till daylight as the base is kilometres long.


Director General PR, Pakistan Navy, Irfanul Haq has confirmed two injuries — one sailor and one officer, both of whom are in critical condition. No foreigner has been killed in the attack, he says. Haq also confirms damage to one P3 Orion aircraft.

Another Navy source say the terrorists stormed the base with rockets, attack the P3 Orion and then snuck in further during the fire caused by the plane. The fire also spread to two other planes in the hangar.


A 10th explosion has been reported on the PAF base by Tribune reporter Faraz Khan.

President Asif Ali Zardari has condemned the attack.

Twitter response:

fispahani RT @Ali_Abbas_Zaidi: I repeat: This comes directly from victims. Blood needed in PNS Rahat

OmarWaraich PNS Mehran received two P-3C Orions from the US in June 2010:


CID police and Army personnel were inside for an hour, however, CID officials are exiting says Ahmed Jung reporting for Express 24/7.

As yet, only fire brigades have been let inside.

The identities of the alleged four dead in the attack have not been confirmed.


Tribune reporter Faraz Khan reports another blast in the PAF compound.

Pakistan Navy Spokesman confirms there are no casualties and only two people have been injured so far. He has confirmed that the P3 Orion aircraft was attacked.

Navy depot and a godown was attacked as well, say initial reports.

Firing is continuing inside the PAF base.

The fire in the compound has died down substantially.

DG PR Navy Irfanul Haq also confirms two injuries in the attack.

Twitter response:

OmarWaraich The fire’s wild. Thick plumes of black smoke stretching across the Karachi sky

mosharrafzaidi Not really too interested in empathy from abroad. I am interested in answers from within Pakistan.

SWarisShah People should stop discouraging our army and intelligence and start praying.. they are risking their life for us.


Fire has spread to three locations confirms Ahmed Jung reporting for Express 24/7. Fire is still visible where the terrorists first attacked.

Special forces including Army personnel and CID police have arrived to fight the terrorists inside the base.

Earlier reports that Americans were present when terrorists targeted P3C Orion plane have been refuted by a US Embassy spokesman.


Terrorists entered from the back of the base, say sources. They had information regarding what aircrafts were inside. The attack was well planned.

Twitter response:

husainhaqqani R prayers & support for victims of today’s tragedy at PNS Mehran. R resolve 2 defeat terrorists must endure

mirza9 If there was no inside help on getting militants inside, they had to be given intel on the plane,location and maintenance schedule. #karachi

cyalm I’d rather have the delusional Rapture folks than the delusional folks here who can’t see the enemy within


Terrorists used rockets in the attack confirm reports.

Firing is continuing inside the base sporadically, says Tribune reporter Faraz Khan. However, he says there has been no new blasts as reported elsewhere in the media.

Army commandos are on the spot.

Twitter response:

AdilNajam Situation ongoing. Coordinated attacks already being called “Mumbai-style” some suspect there may be hostages…

needroos Respect to all security personnel, military, rangers, police, ambulance and firefighters facing the ongoing #Karachi attack


Sources say that the initial target of the terrorists was the P3C Orion plane. The plane has reportedly been destroyed.

“This plane acts as the eyes and ears of the Pakistan Navy” says security analyst, Ikram Sehgal. The plane functions as a form of radar.

AFP updates — “It’s a terrorist attack. More than 10 terrorists are inside. They have attacked a navy air station located in a Pakistan Air Force base,” said provincial home ministry official Sharfuddin Memon.

“One of the four aircraft inside the premises has been damaged,” he added.


American teams were working on the plane which came under attack.

P3C Orion is the name of the plane. It is a four-engine turboprop anti-submarine and maritime surveillance aircraft.

Twitter response:

beenasarwar @thekarachikid Easy to blame govt, when it’s the security establishment that needs to change paradigm, & strategy.

sharmeenochinoy Just spoke 2 ppl on sharae Faisal still blocked- ppl being advised to go thru alternate routes #karachiattacks

Razarumi Vulnerabilities of Pakistani security agencies being exploited by terrorists. What a shame! #Pakistan v@ShabbirShah


Ahmed Jung reporting for Express 24/7 a hunt for terrorists is on going inside the base. Fire fighters have managed to get the fire under control.

A specific plane inside the base may have been a target.


At least four members of the PAF have been reportedly killed in the attack, says Ahmed Jung from Express 24/7. The Interior Ministry reported this casualty figure to the Chief Minister house.

However, no emergency vehicles have gone into the base.

Emergency has been announced in all Karachi hospitals.


CCTV cameras are monitoring the situation inside — it is confirmed that terrorists are inside and they have targeted PNS Mehran and PNS Faisal, says Faraz Khan reporting for The Express Tribune.

Four to five spots have been targeted within.

It is also possible a hangar and a navy depot has been targeted.

ISPR’s Major General Athar Abbas has confirmed there is an attack ongoing inside.

For previous attacks on Pakistan Navy within Karachi click here and here.

Twitter response:

mosharrafzaidi RT @javeednusrat: dependable source insists attack started w rocket fires & not bombs. has all the appearances of a well-drilled out attack.

beenasarwar #CPLC sources @Rezhasan: Samaa News channel: 4 security personnel killed in attack on airbase

faizanlakhani @tammyhaq third attack on Pakistan Navy in one month


Media and emergency services have not been allowed to enter the base so far. Only fire brigades have been let in.

Earlier this month in Karachi, the Navy had come under attack, with multiple bombs targeting buses.

11: 34pm

Rangers, wing commander’s vehicle and up to five other cars have have gone inside the burning base.

The attack is specifically targetting PNS Mehran, confirms Faraz Khan reporting for Tribune.

Interior Minister Rehman Malik has confirmed that this is a terrorist attack.

Twitter response:

thekarachikid There’s a 9/11, 26/11 and 7/7. Then there’s everyday in Pakistan.

ammaryasir 5 injured includes one foreigner, probably a Chinese.

faizanlakhani complete blackout in base Faisal and Mehran


Pakistan Navy is trying to put out the fire inside the base. Interior Minister Rehman Malik has confirmed that this is a terrorist attack.


Sporadic fire is continuing at the PAF base says Ahmed Jung reporting for Express 24/7.

The first fire rescue team has reached the spot.

Twitter response:

sharmeenochinoy This naval aviation base v sensitive area- how can terrorists enter this area- serious lapse of security #karachi

faisalkapadia People of #karachi we are under attack we must “unite” and not panic! Please stay calm we are togather in this. #mehran

AtikaRehman 4 dead, others injured according to Dunya TV #Karachi PAF explosion


Terrorists entered the base and there is an encounter on going report eye witnesses in the area say.

The Express Tribune correspondent Faraz Khan reports that hand grenades are likely being used according to the sounds from within the base.

There are reports of upto 6-12 terrorists inside the compound. Media standing about 2 kilometres from the blast site.


Reports are coming in that this is a coordinated attack. Security forces are allowing no one inside or out of the base.

Army housing and the PAF museum are also located within the compound.


Four major explosions have been heard so far, along with gunfire. It is as yet unclear whether there is a gun battle going on inside the air base.

Ahmed Jung reporting for Express 24/7 says Rangers, and police officials are on the spot at the PAF base.


According to initial reports a hand grenade was used in the attack and an attacker has been killed.

The force of the blast has shattered  surrounding buildings.

Heavy gunfire was also reported after the explosion. An eyewitness said that the blast took place near the gate of Faisal Base.

Police, rangers and rescue had reached the site of the blast.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (227)

  • Disco Molvi
    May 22, 2011 - 11:12PM

    Total of four blasts have occurred now.
    Waiting for conspiracy theories to come rolling.Recommend

  • May 22, 2011 - 11:13PM

    If you want to believe Imran Khan and think this is not our war, then you live in a fools paradise. More jawans and security personnel probably died today! Stop blaming america! Sovereignty means responsibility! If you think people who are orchestrating such elaborate attacks are going to give up their weapons and go home if America leaves Afghanistan…then God help us!Recommend

  • faraz
    May 22, 2011 - 11:16PM

    Strategic assets have struck againRecommend

  • 10th
    May 22, 2011 - 11:16PM

    Time for the Army to takeover Karachi?Recommend

  • Hasan
    May 22, 2011 - 11:23PM

    Never a dull day in Pakistan.Recommend

  • Khalid Javed
    May 22, 2011 - 11:29PM

    Ah, another blast and the revenge of terrorists continues after the Osama Drama. Pakistan will once again flash across the world as a hub of terrorists activities and unsafe place for all. Our nuclear assets will again be a subject of quenstion mark whether they are safe or no. It seems a part of some great game, a conspiracy to subjugate Pakistan to seize its nuclear assets.

    Till Pakistan does not dissociate itself from this war on terror, this revenge will continue. War of terror is a vicious circle, The only solution to this problem is disengaging ourself from this war of US & start negotiations with the local dissidend groups to sort out the differences,Recommend

  • Khalid Javed
    May 22, 2011 - 11:30PM

    You may post the last comments,Recommend

  • SZ
    May 22, 2011 - 11:32PM

    Bloody hell, this is a high security zone. These so called terrorists are among us among the army, navy, airforce. How else can they plan something like this?Recommend

  • Thinker
    May 22, 2011 - 11:33PM

    This attack seems to be perpetrated by India…..judging by its coordinated style……Recommend

  • faraz
    May 22, 2011 - 11:36PM

    P-3 Orion destroyed. 40 million dollar turned to ashes.Recommend

  • May 22, 2011 - 11:37PM

    paf faisal base fight navy commando operation / air force commando operation fight with the international terrorist in karachi. http://www.karachicity.orgRecommend

  • Bangash
    May 22, 2011 - 11:43PM

    Pakistani security forces continue to demonstrate their utter incompetence while public remainsi n denial.Recommend

  • May 22, 2011 - 11:44PM

    @Khalid Javed: Wake up! Disengage with the US and negotiate with terrorists who have killed over 30,000 people. We should surrender to them to prove what? Do you think people who orchestrate such elaborate attacks are going to give up their power and influence just because America leaves. Recommend

  • Pakistani Punjabi (PP)
    May 22, 2011 - 11:49PM

    We should ask Imran Khan to help us to stop these terrorist attacks.Recommend

  • Andrea
    May 22, 2011 - 11:50PM

    @faraz: I am sure that the military is mounting a clean up operation right now. Criminals may grow more and more desperate but they will never succeed because people are united against them like never before.Recommend

  • Syed A. Mateen
    May 22, 2011 - 11:50PM

    I am very grieved to learn about the terrorists attack at PNS Base at Shahrah-e-Faisal.

    The law enforcing agencies should deal with the terrorists with an iron hand and no terrorist should escape.

    Our security forces should arrest one of the terrorist alive so that we should know who these terrorist are and which are the forces behind these terrorists, providing support to these terrorists, using them against the Pakistani soil.

    May Al-Mighty Allah save Pakistan. Ameen. Recommend

  • Anoyn
    May 22, 2011 - 11:51PM

    Don’t worry .. China will save us! Hu Promised!

    We need to hide and preserve our strategic assets!Recommend

  • KL
    May 22, 2011 - 11:52PM


    nobody must be permitted to do this

    sad part is we still see idiots who blame India, Mossad, CIA etc etc while never acknowledging the problem which is so clear and out in the openRecommend

  • Khalid Javed
    May 22, 2011 - 11:53PM

    How 15/20 terrorists entered this sensitive base? Where was our surveillance system!!!! dormant like in Abbotabad? Recommend

  • Khalid Javed
    May 22, 2011 - 11:59PM

    @ TightDhoti: If Pakistan disengages, several dissidends will be neutralized as their struggle is against US influence in Pakistan. If US can negotiate in Afghanistan, why not we can do that with those indigenous dissidends? Much of this anger is against US……… See after OSAMA, its mostly govt assets and sensitive places which are mostly targeted because they consider the present govt as US puppet.Recommend

  • Thinker
    May 23, 2011 - 12:00AM

    Taliban hit pakistanis…and they wont get anything by hitting aircrafts like P-3 or hangars or chinese engineers…
    so this is surely an Indian backed attack…………Recommend

  • Zumiya Furqan
    May 23, 2011 - 12:01AM

    why we always blame india … this is the reply of the drama we planned with America abt OBL… i agree that people say that that our people and agencies are involved ….Recommend

  • Khalid Javed
    May 23, 2011 - 12:05AM

    Coming to negotiation table does not tantamount to surrender. See all the global flashpoints, negotiations are the only road to permanent solutions. Violence breeds more violence. Recommend

  • Nurmomad
    May 23, 2011 - 12:07AM

    This proves that even if USA leaves, Pakistan will have to fights its own war. Better late, than never.

    Don’t stop Pasha and Kiyani. Crush these terrorists forever. Recommend

  • CP
    May 23, 2011 - 12:09AM

    P3 Orion destroyed….lol..lmaoRecommend

  • joe
    May 23, 2011 - 12:11AM


    yeah yeah whatever happens dont forget to blame india huh!!!!

    pakistanis will never learn or grow if they have an anti india attitude like this Recommend

  • Osama
    May 23, 2011 - 12:12AM

    I’m watching the TV now and they’re showing scores and scores of military and rangers personnel surrounding the area. Where were all these fools when the attack happened? It’s so frustrating to see ‘security’ only after an attack happens..Recommend

  • saleem khan
    May 23, 2011 - 12:13AM

    Hope Taliban and Terrorist Apologists now wake up. This was not a soft target which shows that your assets can target you if you don’t abandon them. Wake up, please. Don’t blame Hunood wa Yahood for this. They are among us, reared by us and now threatening the very existences of us. Recommend

  • tanya
    May 23, 2011 - 12:15AM

    unbelievable. now obama will say o dear pak army, navy, air force – you cant even keep the weapons we give you safe , how will you fight terrorists Recommend

  • Independent from UK
    May 23, 2011 - 1:06AM

    Lack of professionalism of the military is the main reason of incidents like the one in progress tonight. The Army is already heavily involved in commercial enterprises. The Navy does not lag behind either. Where in the world you would find military owning housing estates, cement and sugar factories, private universities etc etc. I am not sure whether the institution which is under attack has any policies and procedures to deal with disaster like this one. It is quite obvious that there is no disaster management plan. Ideally there should have been helicopters hovering around that area. Nothing like that. One wonders what was the need of keeping vast numbers of military personnel at the expense of poor people of the country. Recommend

  • Nojeba
    May 23, 2011 - 1:10AM

    O negative blood needed at PNS Rahat –Recommend

  • Cooper
    May 23, 2011 - 1:11AM


    now obama will say o dear pak army, navy, air force – you cant even keep the weapons we give you safe, how will you fight terrorists

    Won’t he be correct? Pathetic performance of Pakistan’s intelligence. They can’t even keep secure “high-security zones”. Shameful !Recommend

  • faraz
    May 23, 2011 - 1:15AM

    Before 911, we had dozens of militant organizations based in Pakistan which had over 500,000 members. Whether US leaves or not, these jihadi groups cant be neutralized, we are doomed.Recommend

  • C
    May 23, 2011 - 1:16AM

    As you sow so shall you Reap….…..Politician and other Institutes and agencies ko Allah sy Maafi Mangni chahey…Injustice, corruption, using and killing of innocents for long time, black propeganda are the main roots of present sitution. Ay taiyer ahoti es reszk sy moth achee…jes resk sy parwaz main hoti ho kotahee. Allah Raham Kary.Recommend

  • mahmood
    May 23, 2011 - 1:21AM

    yaeh, Indian have divine right to blame Pakistan but Pakistan have no rights even with concrete evidences of RAW involvement in may terrorist activities within Pakistani territory. Indian even don’t let their own people; dallat, muslim, sikhs to live peacefully, how they can bear a peaceful Pakistan.Recommend

  • robby
    May 23, 2011 - 1:29AM

    As I read somewhere it is the most luxurious army in the world. Too much of hulva consumption is hitting back!Recommend

  • fahim
    May 23, 2011 - 1:32AM

    Reap what you sow. Pakistan has maintained these strategic assets to go and win Afghanistan and Kashmir. The result is that both these countries are moving ahead while we destroyed our own house. Surprised to see that even now, citizens in this section cannot come out the India/US/Israel/Afghan mindset and still defending these terrorists!!!! Even learned members of our society has become blind out of hatred !!!Recommend

  • Nadeem Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 1:35AM

    I trust Taliban more than our “property dealer marshalls’. Taliban are safe in their hideouts, only fear they have is of Drone attack, but soon Imran’s efforts will stop those attacks too, We are not safe after spending half of our budget on armed forces. Recommend

  • Hissam Amir Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 1:38AM

    So America is rite about the fact that we cant defend our Nuclear Sites…
    They are rite coz its the Americans doing all this to our country…
    Taliban/Al-Qaeda are on the pay rolls of America…Recommend

  • Tariq Bhutta
    May 23, 2011 - 1:39AM

    We need an even larger and grander Defense Housing Authority Scheme in PNS Mehran——

    Terrorists strolling on Air force Runways!!! WTF

    What else do you expect from World’s biggest real estate agency aka Pak Army.!!?Recommend

  • ohh
    May 23, 2011 - 1:45AM

    In my View….All humans born in the same way..As you are and we are. This is the society/community that molds new born baby into wrong shape. In my view no one is terrorist, no one is criminal, no one on the wrong way and no one born as Nobel, but the society, injustice, corruption and misuse are the main roots. Today situation in the world are because of the same reasons. Identification of truth and root causes and its cure are the only way to make the situation peaceful. No unjustified use of power in the history gets success so far. Recommend

  • Chotta Chetan
    May 23, 2011 - 1:46AM

    This has RAW/CIA/MOSSAD/MI1,2,3,4,5,6 written all over it. Who is with me?Recommend

  • CP
    May 23, 2011 - 1:51AM


    The unbelievers (Hindus and Jews along with the Christians) are out there to attack the Fortress of Islam …LMAO.Recommend

  • Javed
    May 23, 2011 - 1:52AM

    @Khalid Javed: We did negotiate with them. How easily us Pakistanis forget that they came within 60 miles of Islamabad. They are not after the Americans, they want control of this country. You are welcome to negotiate a surrender but they would continue to kill after the surrender Recommend

  • Nadeem Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 1:53AM

    Now its clear why there were few people in Imran’s show. They were planning something else.Recommend

  • gandoo
    May 23, 2011 - 1:54AM

    These so called terrorists are among us among the army, navy, airforce. shut up u silly dont know anything. terrorist used weak point of museum Recommend

  • Aftab Kenneth Wilson
    May 23, 2011 - 1:55AM

    So these are the innocent people whom Mr. Imran Khan defends on top of his voice. This is total security lapse and unwillingness from our security apparatus to act firmly with iron hand and flit out these elements and their managers from the society. Many are in our legislative assemblies who are silent supporters of these rogue elements. If we are really interested to save ourselves and most importantly our country then merciless action must be taken ASAP.Recommend

  • poh
    May 23, 2011 - 2:00AM

    Allah Knows Better who is right and who is wrong…who is real shaheed and who is just….Who is so called terrorist and who is the Nobel….who is the culprit and who is innocent. The actual roots are hidden and Allah knows better….I don’t trust and consider some one criminal /terrorist on one side statement and reports. Beshak Allah tamam chupy raazo sy bakhabar hain. Recommend

  • Javed
    May 23, 2011 - 2:00AM

    @Chotta Chetan: Please don’t stop at 6 but keep on countingRecommend

  • Ali Wazir
    May 23, 2011 - 2:00AM

    This attack is scary it means the terrorist are well armed , well motivated, well planned and have infiltrated our armed forces.The can attack anywhere and anytime at will. And our intelligence and security apparatus can only respond after the damage is done. The Americans cant seem to stop them in Afghanistan and we arent able in Pakistan.
    Attacks has been common place in KP & tribal areas since last few year on soft civilian targets which hasnt bothered our establishment much. But now it seems this fight is spilling over into other Urban & Military centers of Pakistan. Artillary shelling and drone strikes in tribal areas have been utterly counter productive. We have lost any chance of organizing a intelligence network to counter the terrorist. A change of strategy is required at least $36 million dollars of assets went up in smoke by a $30 RPG this is unsustainable. What if they attack a nuclear installation next, or HMC, or the GHQ again.If I were working for RAW I would ask my ambassador in kabul to get in touch with these guys and give them list of targets, detonators and a few million dollars. Do we have any idea what the Americans have got us into?????Recommend

  • Tariq Bhutta
    May 23, 2011 - 2:04AM

    This would have never happened if we had ordered more Air Conditioned Pink Prados and Land Cruisers for our Armed Office

  • Nadeem Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 2:04AM

    This is not a news, calm of last 24 hours was a news.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 2:09AM

    Such a coordinated and well planned attack, couldn’t be possible without the help of intelligence agencies, there is no point to blame anyone at the moment… :( Stay Safe guys … Recommend

  • Raja Arsalan Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 2:13AM

    @Khalid Javed:
    You live in the world of fools and continue to make the others as well. The conspirators are those who believe in the evil concept of Muslim Ummah. If you you want to end terror, target and eliminate them. Forget strategic depth and Riyadh and dispose of the jihadi outfits. Recommend

  • salim
    May 23, 2011 - 2:17AM

    its done by taliban and AQ gang!!

    may be chechen people might have done tooRecommend

  • Raja Arsalan Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 2:17AM

    @Chotta Chetan:

    The jihadis and terrorists will surely agree and dance with you. Recommend

  • Fahad Zafar
    May 23, 2011 - 2:23AM

    Its a very sad moment. May ALLAH give courage and strength to our soldiers to fight the terrorists. Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 2:23AM

    Oh so sad, this is the very cheap act by terrorist.. Plz help Pakistan is BurningRecommend

  • Fahad Zafar
    May 23, 2011 - 2:26AM

    May ALLAH give courage to our soldiers to fight the terrorists. Pakistan Zindabad !Recommend

  • Shock horror
    May 23, 2011 - 2:30AM

    Whether or not we like it, the fact is that Chickens are coming home to roost. Instead of constantly looking to establish “Strategic depth” Pakistan should just defend its strategic assets! Enough is enough. Recommend

  • Nasim Mirza
    May 23, 2011 - 2:32AM

    Are the nuclear bombs in the submarines safe? Americans are right, we cannot defend ourselves. Perhaps we should outsource that to the Chinese? Let the PLA come and defend Pakistani nuclear installations against the terrorist. They are our best friends after all. The damaged Orion cost us $36 million. And we buy more aircraft without a chance to use them.Recommend

  • Fahad
    May 23, 2011 - 2:33AM

    @Ali Wazir:
    Surely the JF17s can be used against these terrorists holed up in the installation. What is their point otherwise?Recommend

  • Fahad
    May 23, 2011 - 2:36AM

    It is a naval base and not a museum. And no one keeps a $36 million operational surveillance aircraft in a museum. Recommend

  • Ijaz Mir
    May 23, 2011 - 2:38AM

    These taliban are paid agents of India. Any one in Pakistan support Taliban should be arrested.
    Start with Imran Khan. Give full intelligence report to USA for drone attack let them do the killing of Taliban.

    We do not want any supporter of Taliban in Pakistan. India is sporting and paying through Afghanistan. They should migrate to India or Afghanistan.

    Taliban should be out of Pakistan with their supporters.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 2:43AM

    Thoughts, prayers and well wishes with my fellow Karchites. PNS will be saved. But our delusion needs to go. This war on terror is not a “war in error.” Yes our enemies are within.Recommend

  • Michael
    May 23, 2011 - 2:44AM

    Would the Pakistan government be billing the USA for the cost of the lost air craft?Recommend

  • sunny
    May 23, 2011 - 2:58AM

    P-3C Orion long range ASW aircraft!!!! Oh my God our poor country lost one more P-3C. Why our army fail to even protect themself. I wonder how they can defand whole Pakistan, Dear Pak army please try to make your bases, protect and save. We can take care of our and our country by ourself. I am worry for our army prtotection. It is 2nd time after GHQ attack..In india Parliment was attacked and after that they make security proof arangements and nothing happen further. Is it not some thing to correct to our Army????
    Description about P-3C plane!!!!!!
    Four-engine turboprop anti-submarine and maritime surveillance aircraft.
    Features of P-3C plane!!!!!!
    Originally designed as a land-based, long-range, anti-submarine warfare (ASW) patrol aircraft, the P-3C’s mission has evolved in the late 1990s and early 21st century to include surveillance of the battlespace, either at sea or over land. Its long range and long loiter time have proved invaluable assets during Operation Iraqi Freedom as it can view the battlespace and instantaneously provide that information to ground troops, especially U.S. Marines.
    The P-3C has advanced submarine detection sensors such as directional frequency and ranging (DIFAR) sonobuoys and magnetic anomaly detection (MAD) equipment. The avionics system is integrated by a general purpose digital computer that supports all of the tactical displays, monitors and automatically launches ordnance and provides flight information to the pilots. In addition, the system coordinates navigation information and accepts sensor data inputs for tactical display and storage. The P-3C can carry a mixed payload of weapons internally and on wing pylons.
    General Characteristics
    Primary Function: Antisubmarine warfare(ASW)/Antisurface warfare (ASUW).
    Contractor: Lockheed Martin Aeronautical Systems Company.
    Date Deployed: First flight, November 1959; Operational, P-3A August 1962 and P-3C August 1969.
    Unit Cost: $36 million.
    Propulsion: Four Allison T-56-A-14 turboprop engines (4,600 hp each)
    Length: 116.7 feet.
    Height: 33.7 feet.
    Wingspan: 99.6 feet.
    Weight: Maximum takeoff, 139,760 pounds
    Airspeed: Maximum, 411 knots; cruise, 328 knots
    Ceiling: 28,300 feet.
    Range: Mission radius, 2,380 nautical miles; for three hours on-station at 1,500 feet, 1,346 nautical miles.
    Crew: (P-3C) three pilots, two naval flight officers, two flight engineers, three sensor operators, one in-flight technician.
    Armament: 20,000 pounds of ordnance, including AGM-84 Harpoon, AGM-84E SLAM, AGM-84H/K and AGM-65F Maverick missiles, Mk46/50/54. Recommend

  • Fahad
    May 23, 2011 - 3:02AM

    well this had to happen, when will we just get it… its not our war !
    the blood on our streets and yet there is no one dying in USA! then how come its out for …
    for GODsake! wake up Pakistan, we are just being used by the Americans
    who’ve put us in this situation …its time to bow out of this war on terror and shot down those dam drone and NATO violating choppers and all this will end Recommend

  • Raja Arsalan Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 3:10AM

    They are not. Straight and simple. Majority backs them, consciously or unconsciously.Recommend

  • Mirza
    May 23, 2011 - 3:18AM

    Terrorists did not enter the base, they live there! Remember OBL’s custom made fortress?Recommend

  • Fahad
    May 23, 2011 - 3:21AM

    What lies. This is our war. They are attacking us. Not the Americans.Recommend

  • bc49er
    May 23, 2011 - 3:22AM

    nice to see the blame the jews/indians/usa crowd is still alive and well.Recommend

  • Chotta Chetan
    May 23, 2011 - 3:22AM

    Surely we can China to fill in with a spare P3C Orion. I am sure our all weather friends will obligeRecommend

  • umerbinmasood
    May 23, 2011 - 3:22AM

    The P3 Orion which was supposedly destroyed is/was valued at over $30 million! Hopefully Pakistan had sufficient insurance on the plane.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 3:27AM

    I think pakistan is very unsafe in this world and terrorists going to attack almost all highly secure places means they will very soon under control atomic weapons of pakistan and it’s highly alerted by present scenario…I think USA and India should take immediate action to save Pakistanis else the day is no far when terrorists will control the atomic weapons and attack on the people that will be ever worst situation of the whole world… Recommend

  • basharat
    May 23, 2011 - 3:28AM

    100 percent Indian at doing this.
    And American and Israelis they backe up IndiansRecommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 3:29AM

    I think pakistan is very unsafe in this world and terrorists going to attack almost all highly secure places means they will very soon under control atomic weapons of pakistan and it’s highly alerted by present scenario…I think USA and India should take immediate action to save Pakistanis else the day is no far when terrorists will control the atomic weapons and attack on the people that will be ever worst situation of the whole world…………….. Recommend

  • ShahJee
    May 23, 2011 - 3:32AM

    Once again, big question mark on Pakistan security situation. Well planed and equally well carried out attacks in Heart of Karachi. I am still unsure to call this terrorist activity or a full f ledge Military activity, judging from the planning and execution. These people are among us, but they are not one of us. Because, no one can destroy strategic assets of own country, terrify own children and create terrifying environment. Well trained militants by Indian RAW and American Agencies, who have infiltrated deep into our society. A BIG QUESTION MARK ON ISI AND OTHER AGENCIES OF PAKISTAN. WAKE UP Recommend

  • Fareed
    May 23, 2011 - 3:34AM

    40 million USD = 4 crores USD = 344.88 crores Pakistani Rupees.
    What a waste of national wealth … should have been used to set up
    schools and colleges. Bade dukh ki baat hai. Recommend

  • BetterThinker
    May 23, 2011 - 3:36AM


    By what logic did you reach that conclusion? “coordinated style”? Are we talking about a terrorist attack or a Bollywood dance sequence? Can’t we just be human for at least a day and hope, pray and mourn instead of throwing around accusations that at this point, are utterly baseless?Recommend

  • ranjit
    May 23, 2011 - 3:36AM

    @Ali Wazir
    [Do we have any idea what the Americans have got us into?????]

    Its not the Americans that have got you into anything. Its Pakistan itself that has gone into this mess imagining that it was building up a jihadi force to counter India, setup strategic depth in Afghanistan and grab Kashmir from India……….instead of that, these people have become Frankenstein monsters out to get you………this is why Gandhi used to say that ends do not justify the means…….or as our bare buzurg have said – ‘Bure kaam ka Bura Nateeja’……………..

    The only way out is for you to make friends with India……and then eliminate all jihadi outfits in Pakistan…….no exceptions…… the same time, try to change the culture to make it more tolerant……without these steps, you will not have a humane and livable society any more……..Recommend

  • dr shabir choudhry
    May 23, 2011 - 3:40AM

    What has happened is sad, but it does not surprise me? It was not Pakistan’s war, Pakistani governments worked very hard to make it a Pakistani war. But despite all the problems related to terrorism Pakistan’s real policy has not changed, as still have thousands of ‘Mujahids’ in various places to advance Pakistani elites cause in KASHMIR, India and Afghanistan. Pakistan has to change its policy, you can’t have it like that when bomb blows in Pakistan it is terrorism and when bomb blows is in Afghanistan and Kashmir it is jihad.Recommend

  • Nadeem Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 3:41AM

    Perhaps its American operation gone wrong to hunt down Mullah Omar.Recommend

  • Siva
    May 23, 2011 - 3:42AM

    It reminds me Mumbai attack. I think establishment and its attaches are doing rehearsal to attempt this somewhere else. Recommend

  • Imran
    May 23, 2011 - 3:46AM

    Navy’s Ojhari Camp!!! Naval officers had let the enemies in to destroy the aircraft. Audit teams will now just be rubbing their hands!Recommend

  • Umar
    May 23, 2011 - 4:13AM

    @Khalid Javed: How to negotiate with people who have killed 30,000 Pakistanis and crippled its Navy. I would say we need to fix this issue with full force and unity. These are not dissidents. These are our enemies. Recommend

  • TLW
    May 23, 2011 - 4:39AM

    Hey where’s a livestream of Exprewss 24/7’s English channel? You guys are all for this web 2.0 routine, where’s the Livestream for Express 24/7??Recommend

  • PakIsPrecious
    May 23, 2011 - 5:14AM

    these terrorists must be cleansed off pakistan

    hard decisions need to be made now, the army should annihilate these psychopaths

    wishful thinking is clearly not working here now is it?

    once they started killing our people, we should have drawn the line and make them wish they were never born

    what is the value of a pakistanis life? WELL I SAY ONE TOO MANY!

    no more negotiations, actions speak louder than wordsRecommend

  • Maria
    May 23, 2011 - 5:17AM

    @C: You should repeat this line of ” as you sow, so shall you reap…” to your Indian criminals who are behind these terrorist attacks on Pakistani soil. Attacking a Pakistani Navy station is clearly the mark of clever Indian intelligence terrorists who will stop at nothing to damage Pakistan. I am sure that our military will clear out the criminals quickly.Recommend

  • Babloo
    May 23, 2011 - 5:30AM

    BBC is reporting that Chinese military men have been taken hostage at the Pak air base.
    The question is , what are Chinese doing around US built Orion aircraft ? Recommend

  • Raja
    May 23, 2011 - 5:39AM

    Strategic depth?Recommend

  • Tass
    May 23, 2011 - 5:43AM

    These terrorist have been funded and trained by saudis and their cronies in pakistan like jamaat islami and ahlehadith. Saudis have fooled pakistanis in the name of Islam. Keep Saudis out of Pakistan.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 6:37AM

    Our present govt is failed. Now this time call to IMRAN KHAN ( PTI ) for humanity and PAKISTAN.

    O.! my ALLAH bless on my PAKISTANRecommend

  • Musing Haq...
    May 23, 2011 - 6:48AM

    Did you say Karachi….

    Is it not the city where Dawood Ibrahim lives????Recommend

  • sunny
    May 23, 2011 - 6:49AM

    It is one of the greatest loss of Pakistann. I wish to good luck to Pak Army in this hard time! We need to put strong security for F 16. As I red news that some of the airman might leak the information to terroriest! Good Luck Army for this operation!!!
    The Air Force AP-3C Orion is an extremely versatile aircraft capable of:
    •maritime surveillance
    •anti-submarine and anti-ship warfare
    •naval fleet support
    •search and survivor supply.
    The Orion is the workhorse of No 92 Wing, .
    The Orion first entered military service in 1962, with the current P-3C first introduced in 1968. The significantly upgraded designated AP-3C, were introduced into service in 2002 and are fitted with a variety of sensors, including digital multi-mode radar, electronic support measures, electro-optics detectors (infra-red and visual), magnetic anomaly detectors, identification friend or foe systems, and acoustic detectors.
    The Orion may work alone, or in conjunction with other aircraft or ships. Wartime missions include locating and attacking enemy submarines and ships using torpedoes and Harpoon anti-shipping missiles. Orions also assist in search and rescue operations by conducting search and survivor supply (air drop) missions.
    Orion flight training is conducted primarily in two simulators, the Advanced Flight Simulator and the Operational Mission Simulator.

  • Bikku
    May 23, 2011 - 7:43AM


    Its is your misconceived knowledge about Indian society. We live peacefully with sikhs and dalits. Its your media that portrays minor feuds as sectarian voilence. I have many dalit friends who are very rich that happened because of their upliftment by the society as a whole whereas your society hunts shia’s, christians, ahmedi’s like stray dogs. We are a state with well defined objective of social equality and equal rule of law, not like Pakistani state where only Muslims benefit and that too only sunni’s. Recommend

  • Jehanzeb Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 7:49AM

    Why should ‘terrorist’ attack Pakistan military establishments and kill innocent men. They should realize they only weaken Pakistan defense to the advantage of India,UK,NATO,USA whom they consider their enemies. In Pakistan, they are now hated for having killed thousands of innocent Pakistanis. If they want to fight or revenge Osamas’ death, they better fight USA,CIA,UK,NATO in Afghanistan to support Mullah Omar to liberate her and much rather make another Muslim country slave to India,UK,NATO,USA.Is it their game they are clandestinely playing ?.if Osama was killed in Pakistan, it was by USA and not Pakistan and quite possible someone amongst you would had been spying for CIA,USA to win 60 million dollars prize money. Why do not you target the agents of USA, UK,CIA,RAW then kill innocent?Recommend

  • irfan
    May 23, 2011 - 8:05AM

    Sooper appu…Recommend

  • Iftikhar-ur-Rehman
    May 23, 2011 - 8:10AM

    @Syed A. Mateen:
    Agree with you but then any terrorist arrested will be released by the courts for lack of evidence as has been done in the case of GHQ, HAMZA CAMP and many other high value targets where general was killed.So do we really need any alive terrorist to be released and attack Pakistani assets again?Recommend

  • Iftikhar-ur-Rehman
    May 23, 2011 - 8:13AM

    @Ali Wazir:
    Are you sure it is not sponsored by our very good neighbors?Recommend

  • ani
    May 23, 2011 - 8:21AM

    Strategic assets at work. They were trying to destroy P3 Orion aircraft so that RAW / CIA doesn’t spy on them. Uncle will send the destroyed aircraft for free. No worries.

    And don’t worry, ISI and Army knew about this well in advance. They were waiting to hold a meeting with their assets at the naval base. Recommend

  • Robert47
    May 23, 2011 - 8:26AM

    If you want to understand why the middle east and east asia are going in to chaos, then look no further than PNAC(Project for the New American Century) Specifically the policy paper: Rebuilding America’s Defenses

    May 23, 2011 - 8:27AM

    I think these attacks are just drama staged by ISI to please Obama.Recommend

  • Mr. Right
    May 23, 2011 - 8:27AM

    Mr.Rahman Malik and other politician these are the same kids,people..who you have trained and have been useing for long…now they are terrorist and extremist…haha..The whole corrupt political system, injustice, your corruption, wrong and black propaganda are the roots. As you sow so shall u reap…Recommend

  • rightman_07 Bond
    May 23, 2011 - 8:28AM

    @faraz: Very Sad, all the aid Groper got from china, strategic assets has blown up 4 times its value Recommend

  • Shamsi Ajanee
    May 23, 2011 - 8:29AM

    Please get rid of these terrorist from Pakistan.

    why was security at base so lax?Recommend

  • Gen kayani
    May 23, 2011 - 8:30AM

    We have broken the backs of the terrorists – Gen. KayaniRecommend

  • Nadeem Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 8:33AM

    I think terrorists are checking the security measures of Mullah Omar.Recommend

  • Hedingen
    May 23, 2011 - 8:41AM

    Must be a RAW/MOSSAD/CIA joint operation.

    Hopefully one day Pakistan wakes up and realises that this strategic asset has gone out of their hands and needs to be destroyed. I really hope this wake up call comes soon. Be’ezrat Hashem (Insha Allah)Recommend

  • ikhan
    May 23, 2011 - 9:11AM

    After the OBL incident it is proved that our army in incompetent – Today’s incident is no surpriseRecommend

  • jssidhoo
    May 23, 2011 - 9:17AM

    @Javed: U r right brother their foot soldiers may be doing it out of religious fever but their leadership is after power Bhindranwale wanted it in Indian Punjab and the Taliban wanted it after the Russians were driven out from Afghanistan. It is POWER they want Recommend

  • Hedingen
    May 23, 2011 - 9:32AM


    really…wake up dude this your war and dont live in a dream world that this will end with the US withdrawing from the region. The security establishment in Pakistan thinks it will play the same game as they did in Afghanistan i.e. One side against the other as they did before when the US leaves. This WILL NOT be possible anymore. The only way is to take these people head on and destroy them. There is nothing like good Taliban and bad Taliban they are one and the same as you can see for yourself. This is your war wake up before its too late..else stop shaving as the Taliban will take over and take Pakistan to the stone age.Recommend

  • Ted
    May 23, 2011 - 9:39AM

    @Ali Wazir:
    @Syed A. Mateen:
    Do we have any idea what the Americans have got us into?????……in spite of being a pakistani.. you asked a sensible question… this is so true.. resolving differences with India wud have been so easy rather than dealing with this confusion.. end always comes with confusion…Recommend

  • SARA
    May 23, 2011 - 9:46AM

    taliban or america’s trained agents, whatever we want to call them and our forces’ security for their own base, great work. sleep well u allRecommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 9:49AM

    Its funny to imagine why Tehreek-e-Taliban does not do anything to US who are in war with them. It reminds me of a typical government clerk who is beat-up by his boss, but takes revenge from his wife at home. Coward clerk.Recommend

  • Yousuf Rehman
    May 23, 2011 - 9:50AM

    Where are our Army, Rangers, Intellegence Agencies, Law inforcement Agencies, No one stop that type of attack? which directly hit our strategic assets. Now its time to assemble against terrorism.Recommend

  • Faraz
    May 23, 2011 - 9:50AM


    They can’t even defend them selves. It ti e to take this war to the enemy, we canot sit back and wait any longer. Recommend

  • S. Ahmed
    May 23, 2011 - 9:56AM

    I think our forces should hide their all expensive assets and troops to avoid any damage in the future. We “Proud” our forces???Recommend

  • malik
    May 23, 2011 - 9:56AM

    Looks like the terrorists have touched the lives of Chinese.

    Now see the Chinese will say the same thing what Obama is saying all these days:

    “You act or we will act, and we don’t give a damn to your sovereignty.”Recommend

  • Muhammad Abid Afzal
    May 23, 2011 - 10:06AM

    Brothers open your eyes.. Think that how it is possible…..???? The security agencies h’ve no information regarding this terrorist attack. First of all why we are fighting for America..??? Even Pakistan suffer heavy loss in this war. But now, everyone in the world except China saying that our country is best & safe land for terrorists……!!!!

    This is a big game of America to take the control of nuclear weapons of PAKISTAN. I am requesting to all of you, please support our armed forces & pray for their success…!!!

    PAKISTAN PAINDA BAAD……..~!~Recommend

  • maestro
    May 23, 2011 - 10:17AM

    Whoever did this should be given a massive, brutal response! No Pakistani can do this – attack PAF or Pak Navy! No Pakistani can even think of it. Time for Pakistan to respond with full force and a massive slap! Recommend

  • Chilli
    May 23, 2011 - 10:26AM

    This seems a clear signal that CIA Talibans are well trained and they want to make point that Pakistan cannot save their atomic weapons. Our army should immediately revise their security arrangments and practices. We are at war and we should first eliminate CIA and its footprint completely from Pakistan before we start an operation. We are trapped in US double game.Recommend

  • MRKaramAli
    May 23, 2011 - 10:28AM

    Well Imran Khan is right upto some extent. If we would have punched the US just after the Abbotabad incident, yesterday’s tragedy wouldn’t have happened. While our whole system from top to bottom was completely decorated with lame excuses for the previous one and for sure will remain for this one too. Recommend

  • Siraj Ahsan
    May 23, 2011 - 10:30AM

    In this hour also we dont forget to call names… blame India and Israel… man they are from within us… wake up.Recommend

  • RizwanTKhan
    May 23, 2011 - 10:30AM

    Its a shame to see from above statements that we still dont have no clue what to do and who is our enemy even though we all know who is behind this. And lets not think India is a saint and should also not solely blame India. Lets get united and crush the hands behind these puppets or else very soon you wont see your country no more.Recommend

  • Saman
    May 23, 2011 - 10:34AM

    The traitors are within us….No need to blame others when our own hands are dirty….Wipe out TTP and their benefactors….May Allah bless the souls of those personnel who lost their lives in this attack..Ameen!!Recommend

  • Siraj Ahsan
    May 23, 2011 - 10:34AM

    I am a Pakistani and can safely say that my countrymen have given us more shame than anything. Wish I wasnt born in such a horrible country.Recommend

  • maria
    May 23, 2011 - 10:38AM

    shame on all dose blaming r armed forces….they r sacrificing there lives so u can sit in ur comfortable couch n comment around!!Recommend

  • anand singh
    May 23, 2011 - 10:39AM

    The acid has begun to eat into its container.Recommend

  • Aisha
    May 23, 2011 - 10:41AM

    Wasn’t Obama the one to kill Osama…………….then why attack us???Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 10:42AM

    Wow, white man is saint. Tell us something new.Recommend

  • Naseem
    May 23, 2011 - 10:46AM

    100 % Americans …. a case build-up to rupture pak’s nukes……which are of no use to us anyways… we are frens with india and US (look we got no enemy), we are a rented $$$ army, our chiefs have already surrendered… now they are preparing the nation to follow their pious footsteps… lets all hail america, bow infront of the sole most dominated, most advanced, most powerful (more powerful then God himself) state …
    our chiefs know better n thats whats they say, we should obey the chain of command =)

    YES SIR !!Recommend

  • Furqan
    May 23, 2011 - 10:47AM

    They did not come anywhere near 60mile of Isb this was just a hype created by a fake rumor by the Americans. Guess you should do your research properly first. Recommend

  • Bismillah Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 10:49AM

    If Osama can live with all his wives at the PMA, Mullah Omar might be living inside the Karachi Navy Base!!
    One of his Grand Kids could have played around!! It was an accident.
    Theres no Complicity or incompetency. Guys, dont get excited.Recommend

  • I write U read
    May 23, 2011 - 10:50AM

    It’s an attack where one Pakistani is pointing gun to other.
    I dont think so there will be one person even who can say these attacks are justified?
    Who attacks their own army?
    Surely, they are enemies! So, we need to decide whether as a responsible Pakistani we should be apologetic towards these extremists or join hands with Army to wipe them off.
    Army alone cant get rid of them because these extremists are not a difference race-but, in fact it is a mind-set that is sporadically being adopted. Instead of blaming Army (note: I am not justifying them but talking about the need of time) we should talk people into have more peace loving aspects. We need to be clear that before drones the families were asked to move to IDP zones. If they dint move and stayed back in drone’s radius then it was their choice. It should not be manipulated as Army attacking civilians.
    It’s time to be united-and do what we can in our personal capacity to save ourselves (note: I did not use the word country deliberately.Because, if we will save ourselves, we will reduce half of Army’s job of saving the Pakistani nationals and can expect them to fight out the fundamentalist.
    Before some wrongly interprets “save ourselves” to be taking guns in hand. Instead- I mean a softer and more logical approach than emotional. I mean talk to people around us and do not let extremism grow. Show good behavior to others around so that grouping can be easy and ultimately unity can be achieved and then we can single out extremists in one group.
    Pakistanis need to tell extremists that we stand with our defense organizations when it comes to our safety.Recommend

  • let there be peace
    May 23, 2011 - 10:56AM

    This incident is an internal matter between Pakistan Navy and a (not so) secret wing of Pakistan Army.
    However it raises serious question about security of Nuclear Warheads.

    Good that there are no civilian casualties.Recommend

  • Chacha
    May 23, 2011 - 12:08PM

    @Thinker: You think it was organized by India. I wish it was – that way India would have got more planes destroyed. These are the expensive ones, not the cheap stuff from ChinaRecommend

  • Jayzee
    May 23, 2011 - 12:10PM

    @Chota Chetan: You say it like it’s one sided, check out the Indian media and the responses to India’s woes, the recently released “Most Wanted List” for Pakistan and it goes both ways sport. HaHAHA. Very funnyRecommend

  • Nazia
    May 23, 2011 - 12:19PM

    So Pathetic ! really upset on this inside War :)Recommend

  • Feroz
    May 23, 2011 - 12:32PM

    There is no better time to wake up from lethargy and slumber. It is very clear that all arms of the Government and Establishment have been infiltrated by Taliban ideology and sympathisers, often resulting in internal sabotage. Most terrorist organisations have support from serving and retired Military officers whose loyalty is to a cause, not nation. Situation is alarming to put it mildly. No one knows the true ideology of those guarding the Nuclear Assets either. Those believing that the nations Assets are safe obviously do not take into account the ideology and religious orientation of the guards. Recommend

  • Ashraf R
    May 23, 2011 - 12:35PM

    Maybe Pakistani Military is not as powerful as we have been believing. Abbottabad and now this.Recommend

  • Ahmer Ali
    May 23, 2011 - 12:35PM

    Assalam-o-Allaikum Warahmatullah.First of all this is the most tragic event of today but the most ignoring thing our corrupt and slaves leaders do,id est,giving this statement to divert the nation’s attention from the disabilities and demerits of the leadership and to camouflage their weakness and disability of providing security to the key departments of Pakistan and that statement is “Taliban has accepted the responsibility of it”.This is confirmed that foreign hand is involved in this terrorist attack and especially Black Water’s involvement can never be ignored.Our corrupt and slaves leaders’ main objective and motives are only first their own security on the priority basis than the nation’s and key departments’ of Pakistan and this tragic event is the live example of intelligence departments’ failure.Recommend

  • Sabih Shad
    May 23, 2011 - 12:38PM

    A targeted attack on Planes that can detect submarines is being associated with militants. Well, for sure this attack has come from someone with submarine capability and intentions to use it against Pakistan. If you assume that the militants have access to even ‘Submarines’ now, God help us all. Otherwise it’s not hard to imagine who actually is sponsoring these militants, and what they plan to do.Recommend

  • Pappu Kalani
    May 23, 2011 - 12:45PM


    you say “Time for the Army to takeover Karachi?”

    I say It is time for Army to go back to Barracks, it is time for civil govt to be in lead

    God bless Pakistan ! and I sincerely mean it

    Hyderabad, India Recommend

  • Ammar
    May 23, 2011 - 12:46PM

    Sad to hear the news.

    Put Imran Khan in charge, apparently he can end terrorism in “40” days. Recommend

  • Kazmis
    May 23, 2011 - 12:50PM

    This off course not our fight. Do not come under the enemy propaganda that it is done by TTP. Why TTP spares all the time American target. Is it just Pakistan who killed Osama? No monsieur! The enemy soldiers (Not Terrorist) came with full force, they opened the gate with Mortar fire, it is simply a cowardly attack of an regular army wearing any type of cloth. Pakistan forces are fighting as normal, as a force should fight. the country behind this attack is hiding behind TTP.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 1:26PM

    Please pray for Pakistan.Recommend

  • maqbool
    May 23, 2011 - 1:28PM

    where is your all whether friend?

    Please remember your best friend could be your worst enemey in future.Recommend

  • Radial
    May 23, 2011 - 1:38PM

    does the pakistani military have the spine to crush these miserable talibans and make an example out of them? what are pakistan’s nukes for? the enemy is within the country. send an f-16 to waziristan and drop a nuke on mehsud’s house.Recommend

  • S. H. Zaidi
    May 23, 2011 - 1:40PM

    The attack demonstrates once again our initial folly in teaming up with the US in its war on terror. However, it is also true that after a decade of diligent service to the US government, Musharraf and his successors in office have succeeded in converting America’s war into their own.
    What are the options now for Pakistan and its military? Certainly not war against the US. But they need to carefully disentangle Pakistan from the tentacles of the American Octopus.
    Get the terrorists out in the open through negotiations. There is no need to listen to the powers that are willing to negotiate with the ‘terrorists’ themselves, if only the latter would, but frown on any suggestion that Pakistan do the same!!
    The alternative is to go on and on and keep suffering loss and damage at the hands of groups whose agenda remains as shady and as incomprehensible to most people as it was in the late 1990s when they started their ‘struggle.’
    It is also necessary for the government and the army to examine and define their enemies and friends afresh. Without this exercise, they would keep moving in circles and we, the people of Pakistan, would keep suffering at the hands of both the US and the Taliban and al-Qaeda. They are the victims of their own confusion. Recommend

  • Khalid
    May 23, 2011 - 1:41PM

    No one is going to help us but ourselves.. Wake up and smell coffee… Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 1:44PM

    OMG! this is crazy!!!!!!!!!!Recommend

  • parvez
    May 23, 2011 - 1:47PM

    In the news its been reported tht two of the bad guys were arrested fleeing from a seminary close to the Mehran Base.
    There is no attention being paid to these semenaries spread throughout the country.
    Violence is directly linked to them. The argument that not all are involved is just evading the issue.
    On a lighter note all the Admirals must have heaved a sigh of relief that their golf course near by was safe.Recommend

  • SAAwais
    May 23, 2011 - 1:55PM

    I don’t care two hoots about what the west says about our security and intelligence apparatus. All I know is that an attack of this magnitude speaks less about the intelligence capabilities of our spy agencies, if any, and more about the level to which these delusional jihadi elements have infiltrated our armed forces. And after today’s attack and the precision with which it has been carried out, I, for one, have serious concerns about the security of our nukes notwithstanding whatever top-notch security is in place at the sites.

    The question is if these terrorists can attack military installations, ISI offices and that bastion of our military establishment known as the GHQ at will then what is there to stop them from taking over our nuclear assets? After all they are being protected by the very same people who seem helpless and disoriented against these terrorists.Recommend

  • Muhammad Jawed
    May 23, 2011 - 2:00PM

    Its happens again and again every one knows they all Anti Paki and Anti Paki forces either its TTP and others and they all belong from that all who are against Pakistan as we know about USA Israel India and others our Govt. should get hard action against them with co operation of China and Russia and as soon as possible deliver Gawadar Port to China they are attacking on Navy it can be a big cause war from the Sea Side areas.

    We salute our brave solders they are doing their best and we know our forces and our public can fight with any one either its super power or any one else and InshaAllah we will beat them all.

    Muhammad Jawed

  • Waqas Dilawar
    May 23, 2011 - 2:00PM

    My mind unable to accept that only TTP alone can do this… We have to think there are non-state actors acting in our state as our friends…
    Even if Pakistan have to continue war against terror, they have to do this on their own without USA involvement… Then they can do this… with USA there is no end of this war as USA is playing double game.Recommend

  • Shamsi Ajanee
    May 23, 2011 - 2:08PM

    Let us reflect:

    The terrorist ( those who attacked) went straight for the PC3 Orion aircraft. Looks odd as normally they would have gone for soldiers for maximum kill.

    Where were the barbed wires in large area of the wall?.

    The base commander should answer.
    Army,Navy,Air Force cannot be teflon coated. We love our armed forces and have highest,BMW respect and love for them But they have to vigilant.

    I think time has come, when Brigadiers, Generals stop driving around in Mercedes cars and Prados and they should start moving around in Jeeps. No more escorts; if army personnel need escorts then who will provide escorts to citizens.

    Let us provide full trust and support to our brave soldiers.Terrorism has to be eliminated from the country at all costsRecommend

  • Pakistan One
    May 23, 2011 - 2:12PM

    You cant protect yourselves how can you protect us? Give us all our taxes back? Bear the cost of economic hardship and stop living in mansions, You are a force that is castrated.Recommend

  • dude
    May 23, 2011 - 2:14PM

    Who trained them?Recommend

  • sara
    May 23, 2011 - 2:23PM

    go to hell this government totally faillllllled ,plz elect pervez mussharaf orrrrrr imran khannnnn……Recommend

  • Rahim
    May 23, 2011 - 2:28PM

    This is very scary, more than half of Pakistan budget goes to Army and they cannot protect themselves, how they are suppose to protect us. What if they attack the nuclear assets? ISI need to show professionalism. I am living abroad and this kind of stories are not doing any good. For God sack get a grip. Recommend

  • KM Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 2:29PM

    Wow..It looks so easy and convenient isn’t it? Every terrorist attack in this “Agentistan” goes directly to the credit of TTP, they even claimed the responsbility of killing a Saudi diplomat in Karachi. I really admire our so called “SAFE HANDS”, once again they have shown us how alert and competent they are.

    Developing a housing scheme at PNS Mehran after terrorist clean up wouldn’t be a bad idea?? Recommend

  • Khurram Mansoor
    May 23, 2011 - 2:32PM

    What is our security appratus doing where is our intelligence, they kill unarmed people on side just because they are foreigners and the other side they sleep at strategic installations. I am feel sorry and pitty for myself that my people are unsafe in my own country. There is zulm going on in all parts of my country.Recommend

  • Hamza Ali Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 2:42PM

    Bombs explode, bodies blow, heart weeps, yet we are ignorant of the threat which the cannibals pose.How often we see bombs exploding,media personnel shouting,bereaved ones weeping? Yet in the end, all we are able to come up with are conspiracy theories.Despite the fact that so many innocent lives have been lost, we are still blinded by denial; and continue to put blame on Americans/ Zionists. The TTP claims responsibility yet we try and negotiate with them. Imran Khan comes up and asserts that the terrorist attacks are only a result of drones, while the statistics do not reaffirm his claims. Is he stupid enough to believe that if the Americans left, then these people/TTP will leave us alone? A beast savouring red flesh is as likely to keep biting in the presence of an outsider as it is in its absence.Obviously that does not mean that the outsider be allowed to interfere, but then it also does not allow for the beast to remain. We have to cut these animals; that is the only solution available. IK is delusional and his ideas are confused. All he is doing is making others delusional. He joins ranks with the same mental group who would probably advocate such bombings. Most of those hypocrites would in fact be happy inside to have army and defenses suffer. The ones who were against the creation of Pakistan, and now trying to become its saviours. Impossible that is! Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 2:44PM

    This is American Agent and also involved Obama
    So America is rite about the fact that we cant defend our Nuclear Sites…
    They are rite coz its the Americans doing all this to our country…
    Taliban/Al-Qaeda are on the pay rolls of America is a country of taliban obama is taliban with afgan taliban Recommend

  • khalid junaid
    May 23, 2011 - 2:44PM

    Tribal nationalists are doing this, and like it or not its true the Indians are generously paying for it. The two aircraft we just lost there was the only thing the Indian Navy was technically afraid of. 90% of everything we get is via the sea. This is as serious as an attack on a nuclear asset.
    If all of us don’t like being Muslims and want to worship nationalism in exchange for dollars, then we will break down into tiny nations like this. The Indians must be laughing all over the floor at us. Recommend

  • KM
    May 23, 2011 - 2:45PM

    The worst part if that around 15 such people were living amongst us and our law enforcement agencies had no clue of what is happening under their nose. Thumbs up for being party to the militant wings of all these political parties of this country. Who knows, who is selling cheaply?Recommend

  • Hamza Ali Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 2:46PM

    It is our war. Those fanatics attack us, not Americans. How else can this be stated? What else do you need to be convinced that is it is our war?? They bomb us. They bomb masjids, imambargahs and what not? They kill innocent people. They threaten us. They openly claim responsibility. Is this not clear enough? They wage Jihad against us. They DON’T go and wage their Jihad on Americans. Americans live safely. Pakistanis are killed.Recommend

  • Buzz
    May 23, 2011 - 2:56PM

    Firstly: Taliban can’t just SIMPLY attack a nuclear facility nor can this attack be used as a precursor to the illogic. It’s not like you can drive around town and spot a nuclear facility. If you know anything about nuclear security you would know that it is near impossible to access a nuclear site let alone penetrate it. Pakistan’s nuclear programme has been audited by international agencies and declared safe and secure several times.

    Secondly: On the comments about our military being real estate agents. You should refrain from such comments if you don’t understand what it takes to run an institution in Pakistan. I’ts activities like these that not only provide a source of income to our starved defence budgets but also a hope of shelter for people who retire from these services. Are you even aware of the salaries service personnel get? You would be shocked. It is the civilians who have marketed DHA and tried to earn a quick buck as there is still some form of authority residents can rely on to validate genuine purchase and sales – contrary to non-military schemes run by mafias.

    Thirdly: Stop blaming India and everyone else. Taliban is our problem. Our servicemen have dies by the thousands. We should be showing them some respect. Not slandering the army, navy etc. How many of you will go fight in a war? nothing can be 100% secure – even the world most advanced nations have been attacked so where do we stand. Show some understanding, respect and dignity to those who have died senselessly. They have families left behind with fathers and husbands. Recommend

  • Rishi
    May 23, 2011 - 3:04PM

    Congrats. You nailed it down. Good job. Keep it up.Recommend

  • Musing Haq...
    May 23, 2011 - 3:15PM

    no doubt, pakistani army keeps losing to India in every war…Recommend

  • Mohammed Imtiaz
    May 23, 2011 - 3:15PM

    Dear sirs,

    The attack on Mehran base is another failure or ignorance of our int. agencies. Every new day bring trouble in Pakistan. This is mainly due to sympathy for terrorist in int. agencies and in army and general public is also sympathises these terrorist by non openly talking in their favor but also recites Fatiha on dead terrorist. If these compromises continued then the day is not far Pakistan will become another Somalia. So Pakistanis should think what they want, the better future for their children or continue blood shed in the hnads of Taliban.Recommend

  • dextor
    May 23, 2011 - 3:20PM

    Hey just stop all..SSG and Marines Zindabad…..Its Pakistani soldiers who brought this base back in less than 16 hours….they are martyred but still standing….Salute them and raise fingers only on corrupt politicians…Salute u martyrs and seurity forces….Recommend

  • Aamir Khalil
    May 23, 2011 - 3:22PM

    This attack is planned and executed by Raymond Davis Group, which call themselves Tehrik e Taliban Pakistan(TTP). Not only this, but all such attacks in the past are executed by them.It is obvious that one day this group will attack our nuclear assets providing excuse for USA that our nuclear assets are unsafe and they should be shifted from Pakistan immediately. Our incompetent and greedy and corrupt leadership is responsible for all this.
    Wake up Pakistan please wake up.Recommend

    May 23, 2011 - 3:24PM

    Remember what George Fultan said before leaving Pakistan- ‘If Pakistan disintegerates, it will be only because of military’. The military didnot take proper action against Pak Taleban and allowed to them to melt away in the safe havens of NWA and others outfits are also being sheltered by them. Its Taleban now, which may be joined by other assets like Let, Jem etc, then what will happen to Pakistan ? Kayani has to take immediate action against all outfits and also keep ISI in check otherwise many more attacks may follow on military and soft civil targets. Recommend

  • Ab
    May 23, 2011 - 3:27PM

    usa,mosad and raw are behind these attacks. I am 1000% sure about it.Recommend

  • dude
    May 23, 2011 - 3:35PM

    they cant even draft ‘most wanted’ list, do you think they are capable of planning such kind of attack..Recommend

  • hamid
    May 23, 2011 - 3:39PM

    @Fareed: BTW “dukh” is a word of sanskrit origin.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 3:39PM

    Let us gather at the site tomorrow and demand the reduction in defense budget and housing schemes for the army. A must for every individual to serve time in the army at the age of 18. Moreover the budget should be spend on educating and training the citizens to defend themselves for such a brazen attack since the military has proven its incompetence. Those who are supporting the army here are themselves relatives of some military men living in a posh locality of Pakistan. This is the tax payer money and WE WANT OUR LIVES TO BE SECURED. This is a parliamentary democratic country where the PEOPLE are empowered. Down with the support of military if its not even capable of securing lives at a heavily guarded military compound let alone civilians.

    The picture of soldiers arriving in the morning by Express tribune is noteworthy since it verifies the response of the army , a private with sleepy eyes. The purpose of the state and the ‘leviathan’ (Hobbes) is to protect and provide safety to people. The state is the security arrangement for the ‘PEOPLE’. If the PEOPLE don’t wake up now then least you should stop paying the taxes. The money is going to the pockets to purchase more properties at the sea , where else ? If Ghq can be attacked, if a guarded one of the largest military base can be attacked, a C.I.D bureau can be attacked and navy buses be bombed etc then please accept your failure or be ready to face the wrath of people. The Sympathizers should be blamed too for giving the army an open field to play around with our money. Be proud of the army when you see a befitting response, this is a total security failure. Where was the intelligence , the checkpoints and surveillance ?

    As Hobbes put it correctly , life in this country is nothing but brutish, nasty , solitary , poor and short. Recommend

  • Murtadi
    May 23, 2011 - 3:42PM

    When the fanatic terrorists themselves are screaming they are against the Pakistan state and the Pakistan army where is the Mosad or USA or RAW coming from ?
    Please read the statements made by the Al Qaida terrorists themselves after OBL was killed, you will get to know the facts.Recommend

  • bhai
    May 23, 2011 - 3:47PM

    Insane… Go read the statements made by Al Qaida after the death of OBL. They themselves vowed to take action against the Pakistan state and the Pakistan army. Recommend

  • Zofian
    May 23, 2011 - 3:50PM

    Sovereignty means responsibility. First be able to say something about military. If u have dare then go to borders. Any idea to sleep in mud under the scorching beam on the nail of enemy’s bullet.
    Think than speak. U don’t have any idea. So,please just say ,don’t think.

  • Kashif Naqvi
    May 23, 2011 - 3:52PM

    This is neither the CIA nor the RAW trying to make us out like clowns. Honestly, do they need to!
    This is yet another ‘in your face’ example of inept and incompetent nature of our security apparatus, be it the army, navy, airforce, police or the ISI.
    Billions of dollars are being pumped in the armed forces, and have been for decades. Sadly this is what they have to show the shocked nation- yet another breach of security.
    What are our forces good for? We know they are good at making housing estates, fertilizers, cereals, office and business complexes, and yes march past with all the pomp.
    Sad, sad, utterly sad, I just don’t see any light at the end of this tunnel.Recommend

  • harkol
    May 23, 2011 - 3:53PM

    There are way too many folks who are spewing venom against USA here. But, I don’t see the violation of sovereignty by terrorists today being an issue with them… Is it because the acts were committed by TTP, which is an indigenous group, thus under the control of Pakistan?

    Pakistan is in a no win situation. It has to decide which loss is better.

    Loose its long cultivated strategic assets like LeT & Taliban.
    Loose the nationhood and become a failed state.

    It can no longer follow a dualist approach. Because doing so is equivalent to choosing the 2nd choice above.Recommend

  • Waqas Dilawar
    May 23, 2011 - 3:58PM

    These are backed by non-state actors acting in our state as our allies…Recommend

  • Hedingen
    May 23, 2011 - 4:17PM


    Come on man..why did you leave us out you have to involve Israel in this as well ,lets re-phase it. This was an Indo-Israeli operation sponsorship by the CIA and directed out of Langley by Mr. Panetta & telecast live to Bibi and Obama.

    PS: Bibi = Netanyahu Recommend

  • ShahJee
    May 23, 2011 - 4:18PM

    What a waste of comments..Feel pity on your self Mr. When its India on target, you people blame Pakistan for it, and when its Us, Its an act within us. Any ways what about caste system in India?? Do you give importance to Shuddars? what to talk about Importance, you even think of them as HUMANS?? Feel sorry for your comments on this sensitive issue. Recommend

  • KM Khan
    May 23, 2011 - 4:35PM


    Better you buzz off, or talk some logic and sense. I’m for the people who fight against the enemies of this country whether in army or somewhere else. I realize and to some extent aware of the challenges we are facing as a nation; also I know the greatest threat we face is from inside and not from outside. It is our old habit of putting trash under the carpet, but we cannot afford to do this anymore. We have made blunders like Kargil, and countless others, but we don’t wanna admit our failures. I’m not against the soldiers who fight and sacrifice their lives for this country, but its the “big guns” who live in fortified fortresses, who make policies, and decisions, who have unlimited resources at their disposal, and yet time and again they fail miserably. Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 5:51PM

    I am shocked and amazed that many comments written by Pakistanis here…are makung fun of the army and writing “LOL” and silly comments that really show that we do not realize that Pakistan’s day are numbered…our biggest city has been attacked badly….What next you people want?? Please for the sake of the existence of Pakistan..rise and join hands with the army and for just once think of “PAKISTAN”…may God bless our only home..Recommend

  • True Pakistani SELFISH
    May 23, 2011 - 6:33PM

    A very great conspiracy underway to isolate Pakistan worldwide, that we are………..already on Economy side.
    We need to rejuvenate our NATIONAL SPIRIT and stand by each other. We really need a very good leadership, believe me this nation can do miracles….Just recall the PAK INDIA SEMI PREMATCH Scenario……we need our PATRIOTIC instinct BACK that is being rested under LOADS of TONS of SELFISHNESS……….ONLY THEN WE CAN REGAIN OUR sovereignty…….. Recommend

  • Talat Haque
    May 23, 2011 - 7:04PM

    Brilliant reporting of a dark hour ……….. a job well done.Recommend

  • Omar
    May 23, 2011 - 7:39PM

    what to do now? Recommend

  • AB
    May 23, 2011 - 8:36PM

    The OBL is a character made by us,mosad and india to destroy Muslim states. Taliban is a drama which is run by above mentioned 3 entities. It is allconspiracy against Muslims. Open your eyes dear. Where was OBL’s body? If he was a true enemy like Saddam, he would brought to trail. He is just a character.Recommend

  • John
    May 23, 2011 - 8:56PM

    @shahjee…. Before talking about caste system in india, why dont you look at your country..come on mate.. we do read the news and have enough knowledge..Recommend

  • shahid
    May 23, 2011 - 9:22PM

    what happen to armed forces specialy army chief,president,prime minister,they all are KHOSRE,S they dont have any command and control all of them have to resign immidiatly.Recommend

  • Muhammad Muaaz Saqib
    May 23, 2011 - 9:32PM

    This is not the time to point fingers or accuse the establishment.It doesn’t matter if we are fighting our war or someone else’s, the fact remains that we are at war: And the only outcome of war is the defeat of one side and the victory of the other.This means that we’ll have to win this war in order to end it on our terms.Also every one who supports these terrorists should know that these terrorists are not Muslims, but are closer to being atheists(people who have no faith or religion).Also anyone who thinks otherwise is either either very mis-informed(and terribly naive to believe it), or just plain old stupid.We should also give our full moral support to the armed forces as the main purpose of this attack was to demoralize the armed forces and the nation.We should do this because without them India would have taken over this country within the first decade of Pakistan’s existence.India gained comparatively the most advantage from today’s attack and it’ll be prudent of us to be extremely wary of the nation which has been hostile to us since our very existence.I salute you Lt Syed Yaser Abbas Shaheed.
    I salute the Armed Forces of Pakistan,and
    Pakistan ZindabadRecommend

  • Muhammad Muaaz Saqib
    May 23, 2011 - 9:35PM

    @True Pakistani SELFISH: Well done brother i’m with u, but i think more patriotism is needed than that which we get on a Pakistan vs India match.Recommend

  • Muaaz
    May 23, 2011 - 9:43PM

    @Zofian: Good job brother but i am afraid these people are either blinded by ignorance or are too terribly naive to see the truth.
    Pakfaug Zindabad,
    Pakistan Paindabad!Recommend

  • Muaaz
    May 23, 2011 - 9:44PM

    @TightDhoti: Well said brother.Couldn’t have said better myself.Recommend

  • Sana
    May 23, 2011 - 9:50PM

    @ poh : no offence . but anyone who kills an innocent person saying its jihad is a dirty filthy insect and how dare they take Allahs name and do such evil?Recommend

  • angry islamabadi
    May 23, 2011 - 9:53PM

    This is an appeal to the leader of our Armed Forces, General Kayani as a concerned citizen of pakistan.
    Please stop delaying and hit the nail on the head.

    I ask you to form an emergency team of 200,000 soldiers, divided into 2000 quick response teams, aided by our superior air power. Attack don’t defend. Bomb them before they bomb you.

    In cooperation with ISI, they should hit rapidly at Al Qaeda and TTP safe havens all over Pakistan, especially Karachi, as it is our financial hub . If Afghan Taliban are supporting them, crush them too. It’s about time we got rid of this scourge once and for all.

    Also, all tribes should be made to pledge a strong oath of allegiance to Pakistan and those that refuse should be expelled to Afghanistan.

    Don’t worry about India. Their too scared of our nukes to lay a toe beyond our border.

    I know my request sound harsh and extreme but I cannot bare to see one more Pakistani killed in cold blood. Be brave and know that 180 million Pakistanis support you all the way.

    Thank youRecommend

  • Sana
    May 23, 2011 - 9:57PM

    so what do we say if not ”” LOL ””’??? We are just being honest. Its a joke . A Pakistani life is a joke. thats why its been going on for years and does anyone care?? Aggrieve whom? Let them die by the millions but for what reason? Security is besides the point. The point is that innocent Pakistanis are dying at the hands of insane people and they are getting away with it. Do we just sit and mourn? Why doesn’t the government take the nation in confidence? Alright the need for secrecy, but what results do they show? These madmen have no right to kill a single Pakistani. And we cant stand up for our rights. Recommend

  • Muaaz
    May 23, 2011 - 9:58PM

    @Rahim: It’s difficult to stop people who attack with the intent to kill themselves while doing it.Recommend

  • Muaaz
    May 23, 2011 - 10:02PM

    @Pakistani Punjabi (PP): What Imran Khan gonna do,”negotiate” with these murderers.Boy you are so naive. Recommend

  • NJ
    May 23, 2011 - 10:05PM

    @Khalid Javed: Oh my God…what sort of differences we need to settle with the dissidents: should we become like them and fight in the name of religion!!!! what do you mean; will the absence of US facilitate the survival of Pakistan’s liberal society any more!!! it is more hurting to see such views finding place than all what is happening in Pakistan. Our animy is our own thinking and not any nation. We have been fooled and being destroyed by our own thinking and attitude everyday;Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 10:30PM

    We better hide our nuclear assets in China for time being and get them back after situation in Pak improves. China is only our best bosom friend who will definitely help us in this period of crisis.Recommend

  • vicky
    May 23, 2011 - 11:05PM

    Ultimately, this is the repercussion of govt policies over the past 60 years or more specifically fruitful award of our Armed forces policies.Wake up , we should not blame others for our own deeds its time to learn lesson from mistakes.It’s always helpful to learn from your mistakes.Killing your own brother will always invite rebellious atmosphere.It is very easy to hear or read news about 2 or three terrorists were killed in Tribal area without any evidence but its very hard to see your own blood burying under tons of mud.Recommend

  • Kishore
    May 23, 2011 - 11:09PM

    My heartfelt condolences to my Pakistani brothers and sisters,,,,

    It is indeed a sad moment for the entire neighborhood. The silent majority of pakistan must speak up, you need to have a united voice against the enemies of peace and humanity.. Indians dont wake up every morning to hear bad news from the neigbourhood, we have our own lives and livelihood to look after. When people meet here we dont congratulate or hug each other to celebrate osamas death, or to hear about loss of lives in pakistan. 99% of indians dont know what RAW stands for, even the people who have heard about RAW, regard it as impotent and spineless and like any sub continental organisation, corrupt.

    India has 20 million sikhs, 25 million christians, and 200 million muslims, I am a dalit myself, so i am amazed to read some of your comments that talk about 250 million people being persecuted. So please form your own opinions, not from the government sponsored text books, that make us live in fools paradise.

    After reading most educated comments on this website, i feel Pakistan has a great future like India.Recommend

  • Saifullah Mahsud
    May 23, 2011 - 11:18PM

    The chicken are coming home to roost, eh ! Or wait a minute, they have been home for a long time now, haven’t they !? So are we turning a blind eye to reality then? Are we plainly incompetent? Or perhaps we are letting this happen on purpose!?

    Whatever the case may be, its pretty humiliating for sure! Recommend

  • parvez
    May 23, 2011 - 11:31PM

    Admiral Noman Bashir should have the courage to resign. At the very least the Admiral commanding this base should be sacked for incompetence and utter failure of security.
    If this is covered up by an enquiry and matters lingers until the next disaster, it will reflect even worse than the actual happening as it show to the world that our forces are truly incapable of handling a difficult situation.Recommend

  • May 23, 2011 - 11:39PM

    I wonder why people are criticising Imran’s stance here. If he is wrong, what your government or forces have achieved so far, NOTHING. Grow up guys, its not as simple as you think. This evil has deep roots and those roots are only being watered more and more by America and its real alies RAW and MOSAD. And of course they are being helped by incompitence of our army and traitor forces top brass and the politicians.Recommend

  • sana
    May 23, 2011 - 11:48PM

    @Nadeem Ahmad

    why u send this foolish comment its time to be united.Recommend

  • Pakistani
    May 23, 2011 - 11:56PM

    What a shame and disgrace…………….. WELL DONE NOMAN BASHIR

    This is surely a brave and fearless display of our extremely professional forces… It is obviously no problem if some wanderers barged in the Naval Base… there is no reason to bother even if they came a cache of ammunition with them ….. there is nothing significant if the seized the entire security apparatus for a few hours …. there is no harm even if they blown up aircrafts worth Rs.6Bn (obviously from hard earned tax money)…. there is certainly no big deal if they managed to kill a dozen uniformed guys….. certainly nothing to worry when 2 of them still ran away from the undisclosed entry point even if the commandos had surrounded the entire base in 3 minutes… WELL DONE SIR. You should receive Sitara Jurrat, Tamgha Ghairat, Nishan e Azmat on 23rd March if your calendar is free or we can arrange the same for 6th September.Recommend

  • I. Khawaja
    May 23, 2011 - 11:58PM

    What the hell about security standerd, what about the moto ” Sleep fast we awake ! ” Who is security planner there….what a sham……….time has changed……a couple of security guard with no special training can not guard this kind of sensitive places anymore……please awake, do something and DO IT NOW !!! May God bless Pakistan.Recommend

  • Bikku
    May 24, 2011 - 12:00AM


    Dude you talk about caste system that was prevalent more than 60 years ago. Calling someone by his caste name sarcastically is punishable in India after Independence. Get facts right mate, we are not in Pakistan we live in a space called India where Hinduism was born, which says every every religion is a truth and leads to truth no matter in which form you believe unlike your’s which calls for the brutal killing of nonbelievers. Shudras are not dalits go learn history guys in south India shudras are listed as forward castes.Recommend

  • Amazed!
    May 24, 2011 - 12:00AM

    When you think about it, how easily all these terror attacks and destabilization of Pakistan could have been avoided while saving huge resources from being wasted on the military resulting in keeping Pakistan economically backward. All Pakistan had to do was to make peace with India and leave Kashmir to the Kashmiris.

    Think about it. Do any Kashmiri other than radical Islamists really want to be part of Pakistan now? Has Pakistan gained an inch of Indian land in all the four wars? Actually, it was to opposite- Pakistan lost East Pakistan.

    It is so amazingly simple an idea to make peace with India, yet the Pakistani Army does not get it! They are never going to get Kashmir or pull back Indian development. While Pakistan sinks further into political, social and economic chaos, India is well on the way to becoming a prosperous middle income country. Yes, Pakistan can cause more Mumbai and Parliament attacks, but would they really affect India in the long term? Instead, isn’t Pakistan causing more harm to itself by these Frankensteins?

    Pakistan has received about $200 billions (in today’s dollars) in free foreign money in the past six decades. If this money had been invested in economic development, today Pakistan would be a rich country with no poverty! Instead Pakistan now owns a huge military, hundreds of nukes, fighter planes that is cannot pay for and other expensive military toy that will never be used!

    Bhutto’s wish has come true! – “We will eat grass in order to get our nukes and inflict a 1000 cuts on India in a thousand year war”. Unfortunately, Bhutto did not foresee that in addition to eating grass Pakistanis would be the ones bleeding in a 1000 cuts!

    Isn’t it time to change national priorities, establish a socialistic welfare state and make peace with all the neighbors?Recommend

  • mehdi Jamal
    May 24, 2011 - 12:43AM

    Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani condemned the Taliban attack on a naval air base in the center of Karachi and described it as “cowardly” and said it would not deter Pakistan’s government or its people from fighting terrorism.

    Oh yeah! This statement once again simply deflects attention from the incompetence of the intelligence service and the defense forces or, as many have argued, points to the likely collaboration of these two services with the terrorists. This failure further adds fuel to the argument made every time a high value al Qaida or Taliban member is killed or captured on Pakistani soil (of whom there have been several found to reside in comfort in major Pakistani cities) that, in one way or another, Pakistan is complicit with the terrorists. It also does not help that in response, Pakistan tends to resort to old tricks by whipping up sentiment against imagined foreign enemies, be it Afghanistan, India or the U.S.

    Once again there will be calls for investigation. Once again the truth will be swept under the rug. Does anybody honestly think the all-powerful intelligence and military services will agree to have any serious deficiencies in their organizations be known publicly? Does anybody honestly think the cowered politicians, knowing the historic role the military has played in the demise of previous governments and brought about military dictatorships for over half of Pakistan’s history, push to have the truth come out? Finally, does anybody believe given all this, the U.S. will be willing to share any intelligence with the Pakistani government before once again striking a high-value terrorist on Pakistani soil?

    There are many fundamental and structural problems of governance Pakistan needs to solve before it gains the confidence of the rest of the world in its ability to fight terrorists, and stop being a laughing stock with the rest of the world. Here are some issues that need addressing:

    • Civilians need to take supremacy over the military and the ISI, and then clean house by removing all the current leaders of these services, no exception
    • Show genuine effort to fight terrorists, including the Lashkar-e-Taiba and the Haqqani groups
    • Root out the endemic corruption. Being ranked worst than Zimbabwe on the corruption scale is no badge of honor. It is a badge of shame.
    • Impanel a genuinely impartial, fully independent panel to investigate the deficiencies with the military & ISIRecommend

  • May 24, 2011 - 1:58AM

    Time to accept the truth. Why and who created these terrors. why in USA the army ppl can b questioned by civil administration and know body doubt there loyalty to country and here our media while any question to army always start blaming the ppl as they are not loyal to country.
    Why here in PAK the media always promotes any job done by Army as there grt kindness to country which some time looks they are not getting salary they are doing social service on there own expenditures. wht is the intention of the media behind this. There are many many ppl doing there jobs then they have also right on media every day there shud b lot of news like m a doctor i operated 4 ppl tody like m judge i listened 8 cases tody this that.i will cod one example regarding a tv shoe host brought under question one member that his leader was bribed by army and get 1700 kunal land in DIK i think it was wrong actually that army guy shud b questioned why thy hd aloted the land why the abused the law.
    Army must go back to there own job instead of breaking are making of civil govts.
    FWO and NLC ppl must go and built the proper boundary walls of army installation instead of collecting toll tax on roads.( which where they spend we dnt know). The mendit of accountability belongs to ppl of pakistan not with army for civl govts. Recommend

  • ShahJee
    May 24, 2011 - 3:34AM

    You say this because you are afraid of Jihadis too?? You say we should make ties with India? At what cost? You are right, its not USA that has gotten us into this, It is India, who has thrown every garbage on us to declare Pakistan a terrorist State, but be aware Mr, some elder has also said ” ONE WHO THROWS GARBAGE ON OTHERS, HAS TO GET HIS HANDS INTO THAT FILTH FIRST “. We don’t need India’s help to get through it, We will do it our selves. Don’t interfere in our matters, JUST CARE FOR YOUR COUNTRY, SAME CAN AND WILL HAPPEN TO YOU IN NEAR FUTURERecommend

  • ShahJee
    May 24, 2011 - 3:53AM


    My Brother, Do u believe cutting down defense budget and cutting down military will help stop thees goons from destroying our country assets? Don’t blame our security forces for what ever happened, we all are equally responsible. These terrorists didn’t came from military cantonments or barracks, these people are living among us, may be in your neighborhood. Have you ever thought who is living near you, have you ever investigated who is visiting your neighbors, what activity is going on. This is our share responsibility, dont leave it just to Military. First we have to play our part to blame any one else.May Allah bless us all and make us feel our responsibilities. AameenRecommend

  • Vicram Singh
    May 24, 2011 - 4:10AM

    @Buzz: “Taliban can’t just SIMPLY attack a nuclear facility nor can this attack be used as a precursor to the illogic.

    So you think Masroor Airbase is impregnable ? Recommend

  • Arindom
    May 24, 2011 - 7:47AM

    Must be the Taliban – RAW is too incompetent for this!Recommend

  • Ali Akbar Khan
    May 24, 2011 - 10:57AM

    The dead attackers were all uncircumcised, wore daggers and one even had an “Ek-Onkar” dangling from his neck, proving beyond doubt that this was the act of Sikh Indian commandos. When will our Army wake up to this threat and take necessary action against India? This is an act of war, and should have been immediately met with a nuclear missile launch against the targets we have already delineated. The Indian “2nd-strike” capability is a hoax and does not exist.Recommend

  • Tony Singh
    May 24, 2011 - 4:21PM

    @Ali Akbar Khan:
    Did you see the bodies? Just don’t go on harping. Or is it that Khalistanis have also turned againest their masters?Recommend

  • ShahJee
    May 25, 2011 - 5:55AM

    I think you belong to the Low Caste Called SHUDDER, is it so Mr.?? Closing eyes on some sensitive issue like this will not make India an open minded nation. It was there centuries ago and it will remain there till the end of world, the caste system. If you believe it has gone, then you must not be living in India, You must be in a place called HAVEN. Wake up Mr, Its the Ugly face of India, which you people don’t and wont like to see.Recommend

  • May 26, 2011 - 1:01AM

    Leaders of Talba Action Committee, Islamia Collage, said this in a statement issued here on 24th May, 2011.They accused the wrong system in Pakistan for PNS Mehran base in the southern city of Karachi & Government’s Advocate General Sindh Office negligence over Islamia College Building issue. They said there are eight educational intuitions working in the Islamia College Complex in which 20 thousand male and female students are getting their education. They said this issue has become critical with every passing day………………….Recommend

More in Pakistan