From Kabul to Kolkata, new beginnings

India knows what it wants in Afghanistan, and before anything else, it wants back in.


Jyoti Malhotra May 19, 2011
From Kabul to Kolkata, new beginnings

In Kabul, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh probably couldn’t tear himself away from the history lesson unfolding a few thousand kilometres away, in Kolkata. So he called Mamata Bannerjee, the leader of the Trinamool Congress, and someone who will now be forever known as the giant killer of India’s communists, and congratulated her.

Singh couldn’t have been more pleased. It was the major left party, the Communist Party of India (Marxist), which had publicly humiliated him over the Indo-US nuclear deal in 2008 by withdrawing support to his government and forcing a political crisis on the country (another party called the Samajwadi party then bailed out the Congress).

In astrologically superstitious India, Friday the 13th could not have been a good day for at least some people. For example, the CPI(M), which is not really known to fall for this particular bourgeois weakness. In power in Bengal for the last 34 years, the longest running, elected Communist government in the history of the world was finally ousted by a 55-year-old single woman who prefers a plain, white sari to the fashionable cotton weaves in vogue with India’s card-carrying intelligentsia.

Seems like the winds of change are sweeping pretty much across all of South Asia these days — even though in Delhi, it’s the hot loo that is primarily warming up the atmosphere. With the temperature climbing to 43 degrees Celsius, Manmohan Singh thought he would beat the heat and head for the mountains, in this case the Hindukush, less than two hours away, by air, from home. Moreover, his forefathers used to trade goods in Afghanistan, using both Pindi and Peshawar as stepping stones to Kandahar and Kabul.

Good time to be here, Singh must have thought. Osama bin Laden had just been killed in the neighbourhood, within whispering distance of the Buddhist ruins of Taxila. Would the death of the world’s most dangerous terrorist impact the willingness of the Afghan Taliban to cut a deal with Afghan president Hamid Karzai, as well as hasten the withdrawal of the Americans from this part of the world?

India knows what it wants in Afghanistan — even if it hesitates in saying it. First of all, it wants back in. Delhi’s been kept out too long by Pakistan, first during the mujahidin years, when the US fought the Soviet Union via Ziaul Haq, and then in the decade of the nineties, when Pakistan was one of three governments in the world to recognise the Taliban in power in Kabul.

Ironically, it was Osama bin Laden who helped India return to Afghanistan. When 9/11 happened and the US decided to bomb the terror havens in Afghanistan, India was among the first to reopen its mission in Kabul. In the last 10 years, Delhi has committed $1.3 billion, of which about $500 million have been spent. Two days ago, Singh committed another $500 million to help the country get a fix on its economic crisis.

Perhaps, some of that money will be used, as a start, to train Afghan women police, in both India and Afghanistan. Certainly, Delhi hopes the US will see Pakistan’s double game in Osama’s wake, and is persuaded to let India train Afghanistan’s security forces. Perhaps, Karzai could ask Delhi to begin right away.

Friday the 13th, did you say? For Manmohan Singh, the demolition of the Left parties in Kolkata and Kerala would have surely brought a big smile to his face. Add to that, the new hand of friendship outstretched in Kabul. Now stir.

Published in The Express Tribune, May 20th, 2011.

COMMENTS (29)

Afghan | 13 years ago | Reply @BruteForce: Thats true but you should know which forces were involved in afghanistan which had turned it against india. The nation had no control over taliban activities, even taliban themselves didn't have enough control over their own activities. Afghans have always loved indian even during taliban era but it has deepened even more during last decade. Afghans are closely watching who is doing what in their country. So the country involved directly or indirectly should be aware of that. There is a simple formula; If you help us build our country we will love you If you destroy our country we will hate you - and when time arrives we will take revenge of that.
Afghan | 13 years ago | Reply @Karim S: There is no training camps in afghanitan. That should not be the basis of indian interests in afghanistan. It is the natural mutual interest of both nations which tie them together. The whole world knows where the terrorists camps are.. If you want to know who was involved in mumbai attack, have a luk at this article http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/may/09/pakistan-spy-agency-mumbai-terrorist Cheers
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ