Isolated nation

Published: May 14, 2018
We do not know what others are thinking. We assume with the help of Western media and other sources

We do not know what others are thinking. We assume with the help of Western media and other sources PHOTO: FILE

We do not know what others are thinking. We assume with the help of Western media and other sources
PHOTO: FILE The writer, a former editor of The Express Tribune, is director of the Centre for Excellence in Journalism at IBA, Karachi. He tweets @tribunian

In a recent discussion in our Masters of Journalism class, we were discussing how isolated we are becoming as a country. We rely on second-hand news sources largely to report on our region to begin with. Our official news agency, APP, and other media houses have a sprinkling of reporters — none in the region. There is no Pakistani journalist stationed in Afghanistan, Iran, China or Bangladesh, let alone in Turkey or beyond. We do not know what others are thinking. We assume with the help of Western media and other sources.

But the isolation does not end there. In comparison to our neighbouring countries, we are losing out on the expertise that would come from our open interaction with the outside world. There are many ways to gauge where we are heading.

Pakistan urged to focus on EU, not just China

Let us start by looking at foreign companies on the ground in Pakistan. Initially it was said that some companies were winding up because of the law and order situation. But now when things are looking better, the good long-term investors are still closing shop.

We import foreign brands but have few joint ventures. The number of foreigners in the corporate sector is almost nil. In most instances, multinationals have Pakistani CEOs. Foreign nationals bring an international perspective. We are losing out on that. Similarly, the number of foreign airlines serving Pakistani airports has gone down significantly. Look at sports. No team wants to play in Pakistan.

Visiting Pakistan is an ordeal. Despite the open-visa regime, bureaucracy makes it almost impossible. Others complain of long waits at embassies abroad.

Barring the very brave who may have a death wish, no one really wants to visit Pakistan. From the day they land, most foreigners complain of being followed, harassed and having to bear with substandard facilities. Hotels are prohibitively expensive and people usually are out to fleece foreigners.

Most foreigners (barring the Chinese) are not allowed to travel the country freely. If a Westerner turns up at a small town in Pakistan, the intelligence agencies of that town go into overdrive. For most Pakistanis, every Westerner is a CIA agent, particularly those who speak Urdu or a local language. Foreigners find this absurd and funny in the beginning but with a few days they are frustrated by this attitude. Gone are the days of exploring new areas or places off the trodden track.

Let us forget this nonsense about our warm hospitality, most foreign visitors say that many Pakistanis want to cheat them — whether the taxi driver, the money changer or the porter at the airport.

Overseas Pakistanis are our window to the world. Their input, in many instances, makes things worse. For many, their perspective of Pakistan is the year they left. Many live in a world of nostalgia and when they come here, they expect things to be that way. By and large many overseas Pakistanis have regressed in their views and outlook while living in closed communities in their adopted homelands.

Academia is no exception. Most foreign teachers and trainers have left. Our government has issued a circular through Nacta that forbids interaction with foreign organisations or entities. We have already shut down a number of international NGOs, harassing them as if they were criminals. This has resulted in the suspension of programmes from which poor Pakistanis benefited.

Interview on Mumbai attacks: Nawaz faces volley of criticism from opposition

The only neighbour we are on good terms with is China. We are on terrible terms with India, Iran and Afghanistan. China, too, remains wary of the type of visitors who enter into the restive Xinjiang province. We are testing their patience.

We live in a vacuum. The best comparison would be North Korea. We have shut ourselves and have started believing our own propaganda. Our ignorance knows no bounds. That is why we believe in cars that run on water. Or that there is a world conspiracy against Pakistan. We are right, everyone else is wrong.

Many in Pakistan still don’t believe that the Taliban inflicted the casualties they did. Others say the same about the APS. In the absence of any mirror to see ourselves in, we believe we are the best. It was with sarcasm that Gamal Abdel Nasser once remarked that it seemed Islam was discovered in 1947. This isolated nation is becoming the new North Korea.

Published in The Express Tribune, May 14th, 2018.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (6)

  • Feroz
    May 14, 2018 - 10:47AM

    When the citizens can be made to believe propaganda over facts and reality, it will seem the world has no other work except to hatch conspiracies to derail the country. You have to breed insecurity to fan this flame and it is done everyday, the few who question the policies adopted are easily called traitors or blasphemers, they will be lucky to avoid disappearance or elimination by non State proxies.

    So far only a few side effects of the ill advised policies are visible. When ability to freely travel abroad or some kind of sanctions under FATF or UN resolutions are imposed the impact of the faulty policies will hit. Getting here has been very easy but putting the country back on track will not be possible until citizens understand how the country got here and are willing to make efforts at putting the country back on track. To expect those wielding all power today to lead the country out of the imbroglio would be delusional. Getting isolated is not a destination but a process, not many can recognize it.Recommend

  • Prabhjyot Singh Madan
    May 14, 2018 - 10:56AM

    I often said that china is north korea and pakistans best friend and china is the world to pakistan and north korea. Thank you columnist for reiterating my views here which gets blocked more than often here nowadays. Rab rakhaRecommend

  • Indian
    May 14, 2018 - 12:03PM

    Take care author. Truth is not welcome in Pakistan Recommend

  • Kushal
    May 14, 2018 - 12:34PM

    Now you grudgingly admit that you are being isolated in the world. Why it took so much time to understand this simple fact, that you cannot poke your “larger neighbor” in the eye and live happily.Recommend

  • Kamal
    May 14, 2018 - 1:50PM

    A country where, there is no clear foreign policy or a Minister even for a stable time period, isolation is imminent. And looking at our Embassies engagement with other states in deplorable. I can say for a fact that I personally attend various Embassy event in GCC and hardly see any Pak presence or delegate representations especially in EU events. It is a pity. Either they are not being invited or they don’t care to show show their “valued” presence. Shame. Hard reality but nation is living in their own “bubble”. Recommend

  • Naeem
    May 14, 2018 - 1:50PM

    I think the writer is writing stuff which he himself has picked up from some obscure source. Ironic isn’t it? If the writer himself had done some research he would’ve known Westerners are telling their compatriots to ignore the horror stories being spread by malicious or uninformed sources, telling them to not visit Pakistan, or they had a ‘deathwish’ if they did, and actually visit the place. Being a tourist myself, I’ve interacted with such westerners in Pakistan. And especially hilarious are the comments of the Indians, who actually have never visited the place and are sprouting propaganda their government feeds them day and night. Which makes the writer’s source material for this article rather dubious, doesn’t it?Recommend

More in Opinion