Women leaders wangle water taps, security in India's slums
Women leaders are 'rarely token figures'
Homes in Jadibanagar slum, where a woman community leader trained by a local non-profit has overseen the upgrade of the settlement with water taps, toilets and paved lanes, and with a guarantee of no evictions for 10 years in Ahmedabad, India. PHOTO: REUTERS
AHMEDABAD, INDIA:
Hansaben Rasid knows what it is like to live without a water tap or a toilet of her own, constantly fearful of being evicted by city officials keen on tearing down illegal settlements like hers in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad.
The fear and lack of amenities are but a memory today, after she became a community leader in the Jadibanagar slum and pushed residents to apply for a programme that gave them facilities and a guarantee of no evictions for 10 years.
"We didn't even have a water tap here - we had to fetch water from the colony near by, and so much time went in just doing that. People kept falling sick because there was just one toilet," she said.
Indian toilet charity renames village after Trump
"Now that we have individual water taps and toilets, we can focus on work and the children's education. Everyone's health has improved, and we don't need to be afraid of getting evicted any day," she said seated outside her home painted green.
Jadibanagar, with 108 homes, is one of more than 50 slums in Ahmedabad which have been upgraded by Parivartan - meaning 'change' - a programme that involves city officials, slum dwellers, a developer and a non-profit organisation.
Every household pays US$31 and in return, each home gets a water tap, a toilet, a sewage line and a storm water drain. The slum gets street lights, paved lanes and regular garbage collection. Each home also pays INR80 as an annual maintenance fee, and the city commits to not evicting residents for 10 years.
Negotiation skills
A crucial part of the programme is the involvement of a woman leader who brings residents on board, deals with city officials and oversees the upgrade. Non-profit Mahila Housing Trust has trained women residents to be community leaders in a dozen cities in the country, including more than 60 in Ahmedabad.
"Women are responsible for the basic needs of the family, and most also work at home while the husband works outside, so the lack of a water tap or a toilet affects them more," said Bharati Bhonsale, programme manager at Mahila Housing Trust. "Yet they traditionally have had little influence over policy decisions and local governance. We train them in civic education, build their communication and negotiation skills, and teach them to be leaders of the community."
About 65 million people live in India's slums, according to official data, which activists say is a low estimate. That number is rising quickly as tens of thousands of migrants leave their villages to seek better prospects in urban areas. Many end up in overcrowded slums, lacking even basic facilities and with no claim on the land or their property.
Yet slum dwellers have long opposed efforts to relocate them to distant suburbs which limit their access to jobs. Instead, they favour upgrading of their slums or redevelopment.
Poor toilet access contributes to India rape rise: study
Earlier this month, officials in the eastern state of Odisha said they will give land rights to slum dwellers in small towns and property rights to those in city settlements in a 'historic' step that will benefit tens of thousands. In Gujarat state, as Jadibanagar is on private land, it is not eligible for the city's redevelopment plan.
"These homes are all illegal, but that doesn't mean the people cannot live decently," said Bhonsale. "With redevelopment, there is demolition and a move, and that can take longer to convince people of, with the men usually making the decision. But with an upgrade, the women make the decision very quickly by themselves."
Bottom up
Elsewhere, in Delhi's Savda Ghevra slum resettlement colony where about 30,000 people live, non-profit Marg taught women residents to demand their legal right to water, sanitation and transport. A group of women then filed Right to Information petitions, to improve their access to drinking water, buses and sanitation.
"The women bear the brunt of not having these amenities, and are therefore most motivated to do something about the situation," said Anju Talukdar, director of Marg.
"The leaders are the ones who show up for meetings, are engaged and keen to learn how to use the law to improve their lives," she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
Contrary to perceptions that slums are run by petty criminals who resist efforts to redevelop or upgrade, women leaders in Jadibanagar and Savda Ghevra are actively engaged in bettering everyone's lives.
Leaders often emerge from a bottom-up process, with reputations for getting things done - in particular, resisting evictions and securing basic services, according to research by Adam Auerbach at the American University and Tariq Thachil at Vanderbilt University.
"They are themselves ordinary residents, living with their families and facing the same vulnerabilities and risks as their neighbours; they too want paved roads, clean drinking water, proper sanitation, and schools for their children," they said.
Women leaders, while still a minority, are "rarely token figures" serving male heads of households, and are "just as active, assertive, and locally authoritative as their male counterparts", they said in an e-mail.
Rasid in Jadibanagar, whose two sons and their families live in homes alongside hers, is certain her leadership helped residents improve their homes and their lives.
"Everyone wants security and nicer homes, and they are willing to pay. Someone just has to get it done," she said. "I am illiterate, I cannot read, but I know now how to talk to officials and the developer and tell them what we want, and make sure they deliver."
Hansaben Rasid knows what it is like to live without a water tap or a toilet of her own, constantly fearful of being evicted by city officials keen on tearing down illegal settlements like hers in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad.
The fear and lack of amenities are but a memory today, after she became a community leader in the Jadibanagar slum and pushed residents to apply for a programme that gave them facilities and a guarantee of no evictions for 10 years.
"We didn't even have a water tap here - we had to fetch water from the colony near by, and so much time went in just doing that. People kept falling sick because there was just one toilet," she said.
Indian toilet charity renames village after Trump
"Now that we have individual water taps and toilets, we can focus on work and the children's education. Everyone's health has improved, and we don't need to be afraid of getting evicted any day," she said seated outside her home painted green.
Jadibanagar, with 108 homes, is one of more than 50 slums in Ahmedabad which have been upgraded by Parivartan - meaning 'change' - a programme that involves city officials, slum dwellers, a developer and a non-profit organisation.
Every household pays US$31 and in return, each home gets a water tap, a toilet, a sewage line and a storm water drain. The slum gets street lights, paved lanes and regular garbage collection. Each home also pays INR80 as an annual maintenance fee, and the city commits to not evicting residents for 10 years.
Negotiation skills
A crucial part of the programme is the involvement of a woman leader who brings residents on board, deals with city officials and oversees the upgrade. Non-profit Mahila Housing Trust has trained women residents to be community leaders in a dozen cities in the country, including more than 60 in Ahmedabad.
"Women are responsible for the basic needs of the family, and most also work at home while the husband works outside, so the lack of a water tap or a toilet affects them more," said Bharati Bhonsale, programme manager at Mahila Housing Trust. "Yet they traditionally have had little influence over policy decisions and local governance. We train them in civic education, build their communication and negotiation skills, and teach them to be leaders of the community."
About 65 million people live in India's slums, according to official data, which activists say is a low estimate. That number is rising quickly as tens of thousands of migrants leave their villages to seek better prospects in urban areas. Many end up in overcrowded slums, lacking even basic facilities and with no claim on the land or their property.
Yet slum dwellers have long opposed efforts to relocate them to distant suburbs which limit their access to jobs. Instead, they favour upgrading of their slums or redevelopment.
Poor toilet access contributes to India rape rise: study
Earlier this month, officials in the eastern state of Odisha said they will give land rights to slum dwellers in small towns and property rights to those in city settlements in a 'historic' step that will benefit tens of thousands. In Gujarat state, as Jadibanagar is on private land, it is not eligible for the city's redevelopment plan.
"These homes are all illegal, but that doesn't mean the people cannot live decently," said Bhonsale. "With redevelopment, there is demolition and a move, and that can take longer to convince people of, with the men usually making the decision. But with an upgrade, the women make the decision very quickly by themselves."
Bottom up
Elsewhere, in Delhi's Savda Ghevra slum resettlement colony where about 30,000 people live, non-profit Marg taught women residents to demand their legal right to water, sanitation and transport. A group of women then filed Right to Information petitions, to improve their access to drinking water, buses and sanitation.
"The women bear the brunt of not having these amenities, and are therefore most motivated to do something about the situation," said Anju Talukdar, director of Marg.
"The leaders are the ones who show up for meetings, are engaged and keen to learn how to use the law to improve their lives," she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
Contrary to perceptions that slums are run by petty criminals who resist efforts to redevelop or upgrade, women leaders in Jadibanagar and Savda Ghevra are actively engaged in bettering everyone's lives.
Leaders often emerge from a bottom-up process, with reputations for getting things done - in particular, resisting evictions and securing basic services, according to research by Adam Auerbach at the American University and Tariq Thachil at Vanderbilt University.
"They are themselves ordinary residents, living with their families and facing the same vulnerabilities and risks as their neighbours; they too want paved roads, clean drinking water, proper sanitation, and schools for their children," they said.
Women leaders, while still a minority, are "rarely token figures" serving male heads of households, and are "just as active, assertive, and locally authoritative as their male counterparts", they said in an e-mail.
Rasid in Jadibanagar, whose two sons and their families live in homes alongside hers, is certain her leadership helped residents improve their homes and their lives.
"Everyone wants security and nicer homes, and they are willing to pay. Someone just has to get it done," she said. "I am illiterate, I cannot read, but I know now how to talk to officials and the developer and tell them what we want, and make sure they deliver."