A Muslim woman in the UK

Published: May 17, 2010
The writer works as content manager for a travel website (samina.wahid@tribune.com.pk)

The writer works as content manager for a travel website (samina.wahid@tribune.com.pk)

First it was Barack Obama’s election as the US President and now it’s Sayeeda Warsi’s appointment as the first female Muslim cabinet minister in the British government. This year, and the one before it, appears to be all about celebrating racial diversity. Who would have thought they’d live to see the day when a black man, with a decidedly ambiguous Muslim origin, would be voted as the US president? Or to see a Muslim woman of Pakistani origin working for the British government? A woman who is, as reports indicate, “the daughter of an immigrant mill-worker in a mill town in Yorkshire” and “a northern, working-class roots mum” whose ancestors hail from a village called Pukka Khoo Bewal in Gujar Khan, Pakistan.

While critics are calling Warsi’s appointment a cosmetic measure by the Cameron government to be seen as oh-so-diverse and open-minded, there’s no denying the fact that it is still pretty great. Even today, most drawing-room discussions in Pakistan tend to indulge in relentless west-bashing. We criticise their inhuman foreign policies, depraved values and the unabashed racial discrimination that persists in their society. We also happen to think that we are better than them with our I-am-a-Muslim-so-that-automatically-makes-me-betterthan- you attitude. But we’re not. We’re not because no leader of ours in his/her right mind would appoint a ‘gora’ as cabinet minister, especially if his race/ethnicity is notorious for committing random, cruel, and often proven, acts of terror. And if that is his only known claim to fame in this day and age.

As an already disgruntled, disillusioned bunch of people, we love to hate the west, because we supposedly have our moral compass in place. But, let me tell you something, that compass doesn’t always point north, if you know what I mean. And we continue to live in denial about that. We have also inherited a painfully discriminatory mindset, admittedly from our colonial keepers, but we stubbornly refuse to say that we suffer from any such problems or dust off those demons in our closet and look them straight in the eye. You can label the west as being ‘racist’ and ‘bigoted’ all you want but they are still the first ones to admit their flaws and look into the business of making amends. They are willing to acknowledge what they’ve done wrong and may be do something about it — even if it is in another life. It is granted that they still have a long way to go and that Warsi’s appointment may not amount to much in the long run. Also granted is the fact that she does not have a portfolio and is an ‘unpaid’ minister, according to a report published in The Guardian this week. Yes, it may, after all, be yet another ‘soft image’ exercise on part of the Conservatives but it was still the right thing to do which, if nothing else, is a start. So more power to you Ms Warsi. May you prove all your critics wrong and be more than a mere shalwar kameez-wearing Muslim woman in Britain who just happens to be a politician.

Published in the Express Tribune, May 18th, 2010.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (6)

  • Waqas
    May 18, 2010 - 1:14AM

    Well well well- all this rant on the name of ‘we’. Please do not pigeonhole me into your single-facade view of the east. If Ms. Warsi did achieve something, it was her achievement. Please keep your emotions in check and do not lambast the whole community. I would also recommend doing some research and travelling before going on east-bashing. East or west, every society has ups and downs. Live and let live.Recommend

  • Daniyal Khursheed
    May 18, 2010 - 11:48AM

    The random ramblings of a travel writer, not to mention the sweeping and completely inaccurate imagined “most drawing room discussions” leave a little bad taste in mouth. Recommend

  • Sualiha
    May 18, 2010 - 9:31PM

    Oh wow! Not that I am against West but I have one query to ask the writer, SERIOUSLY?We hate west because of our I-am-a-muslim attitude?WOW. Want me to point out specific details of how the West has been bashing the East for centuries? Mention both sides of the story else it becomes one biased article.Recommend

  • Mubasher
    May 18, 2010 - 11:09PM

    Dear Samina, a lot of Pakistanis living in the UK think that Ms. Warsi is just a ‘Surgical appointment’ in the British Government. It was Ms. Warsi who was pelted with egss in Luton near London, a Pakistani-Muslim area, on her views on Afghan war by supporting what Americans and its allies are doing is right and just.

    I do appreceiate that she attained a special place in British history but, Ms.Samina, you should also know that it is the conservative party, as compared ot the Labour part, which is against strong asian community in the UK and is not popular with immigrants. Ms. warsi’s appointment is nothing to do with ‘woman or religious issue’.Recommend

  • May 19, 2010 - 1:29AM

    Mubasher makes a valid point. The press in Pakistan seems to be going overboard on the whole Syeda Warsi appointment. A couple of other points: Ms. Warsi’s father may have started out as a mill-worker but he currently is a factory owner with reported income in excess of £2 Million per year. As with politics everywhere, money talks. So the idea that she comes from some disadvantaged background is not entirely accurate.

    Further, Ms. Warsi has not been able to win her own constituency for much of the reasons Mubasher lists. Shahid Malik, the Labour MP, has previously defeated Ms. Warsi in her home constituency and Mr. Malik also won on the Labour ticket this time. Ms. Warsi is Cameron’s appointment. So I think we need to keep things in perspective.Recommend

  • Erfan Afghan
    Jun 27, 2010 - 6:15PM

    If a gora starts living here and adopts our values and work through our system, I bet he’ll get the chance to get into any post. How many Gora’s have tried to do this? So, we are just assuming that he (Gora) won’t have a chance.Recommend

More in Opinion