Bangladeshi family faces deportation from Australia over daughter's autism

Haque states health checks found Sumaya had a 'developmental delay' that would be a burden on Australian taxpayers

News Desk February 24, 2017
PHOTO: Dr. Nasreen Haque

The Australian immigration department has refused to give visa to Bangladeshi medical doctor Nasrin Haque and her autistic daughter because the latter failed an immigration 'health' check.

Haque's 16-year-old daughter Sumaya Bhuiyan has autism spectrum disorder. The family were rejected permanent residency in 2013. Haque states this was because the health checks found Sumaya had a 'moderate developmental delay' that would result in significant cost to Australian taxpayers.

Empathy not sympathy emphasised on International Day for Persons with Disabilities

Under Australia's 'one fails, all fail' visa rules for family applications, Haque and her 14-year-old son must leave the country along with Sumaya. They are, however, eligible to apply for temporary visas if they wish to stay on after Sumaya leaves.

The children have spent more than half their lives in Australia and have family in the country. Haque's sister, brother and parents are all Australian citizens.

"I still cannot believe how this could be happening. I cry every time I think she has to leave," Haque said while speaking to Sydney Morning Herald.

"My children have been doing well in school, they have a lot of friends. I'm working in two practices, I have a lot of patients. I have been doing everything I can, hoping to have a good result."

In a petition to immigration minister Peter Dutton, Haque pleads with the minister to reconsider her case, saying it would devastate her family. She outlines that her daughter is not a burden on the Australian taxpayers as Haque is capable of providing for her.

“Although she does attend a special school, she has not received any other support from the state during her eight years in Australia. Sumaya is an independent young girl with strong computer skills and manages all activities of daily living on her own. My full-time position as a GP allows me to financially support my family without assistance from the Australian state.”

Even though more than 36,000 people have signed the family's petition, a spokesperson for the department of immigration and border protection said, “The minister cannot be compelled to exercise his powers and he is not required to explain his decisions in any case.”

Busting myths about disability

There has been an outcry against the government's decision and many have spoken in favour of the family.

Brad Frankum, the president of the New South Wales branch of the Australian Medical Association called the decision“disgraceful”.

“It would take someone of immense callousness to split a family because one of the children is on the autism spectrum,” Professor Frankum said.

The CEO of Autism Awareness Australia, Nicole Rogerson, said the treatment of the family by the government carried a 'disgusting undertone' and the the policy was 'harsh' and 'heartless'.

“Deporting her family because she has a disability...think about what that does to her family, think about what it does to people’s view of disability," she added.


This article originally appeared in The Guardian


Chacha Jee | 5 years ago | Reply Cousin Marriage...right
ADNAN MUJIB | 5 years ago | Reply Australia should learn from our Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read