Wouldn't want to repeat that experience ever: Karan Johar on ADHM controversy

Bollywood director subtly hints he wouldn't be open to be working with Fawad Khan in the future

News Desk January 18, 2017

In a fiery one-on-one session with two-time Academy Award-winner Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, Bollywood director Karan Johar subtly hinted that he wouldn't be open to be working with Fawad Khan (and presumably other Pakistani artists) in the future.

"You know what I went through and it was a tough time for me. I don't think would want to repeat that experience ever," said Karan, when Sharmeen said she hoped to watch Fawad Khan directed by him again.

At a session at the 47thWorld Economic Forum Annual Meeting in Davos, Switzerland, Karan said he really wishes Fawad finds the best platform to showcase his talents. "I have a great regard for talent and for Fawad Khan’s talent. So just like you [Sharmeen], I hope and wish Fawad finds the best platforms because he is a prolific actor."

A member of the audience then asked Sharmeen and Karan if they would ever consider making a film on whether Partition was a mistake.

On this, the Indian film-maker said he would never make a film on India-Pakistan in his 'sane' mind. "I think telling stories about today would make more sense than revisiting what has happened," he said.

Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy to hold one-on-one session with Karan Johar in Davos

"I would love to work on projects that show collaboration. A boundary doesn't make you an enemy. Our children live in more peaceful times."

Karan also went on to say that we are not fully aware of the facts about Partition and there were myriad of opinions about it.

"I would never say anything in history is a mistake. We weren't there at the time nor were we making the decisions. We don't know if we even have accurate facts," he said.

When asked again the same question, he replied with more conviction in his voice: "I will never make a film on Partition; I'll make love stories, all the problems you go through in romance and dysfunctionality of relationships."

In a bid to justify his stance of not treading the dangerous waters, Karan said he was being strong not "retardedly brave".

Sharmeen Obaid first-ever artist to co-chair World Economic Forum

"Telling stories about today about hope and aspiration will be better than narrating what has already transpired," he remarked.

Recalling the ordeal he went through when there was an acute stand-off between Pakistan and India and their artists, Sharmeen reminded Karan that the artist community needs to do things "that are true to our heart".

When Karan asked Sharmeen about how she felt about people saying she paints her country in a negative light, the two-time Oscar winner said she was either loved or hated by people back home, adding that she preferred that to indifference.

Sharmeen is the first documentary filmmaker to co-chair the forum. Established in 1971, the World Economic Forum is committed to improving the state of the world and its annual meeting in Davos-Klosters remains the foremost creative force engaging top leaders in collaborative activities.

This year, the forum is highlighting five distinct challenges: a breakdown in global collaboration; loss of identity; slow economic growth; a crisis in capitalism and preparing for the oncoming Fourth Industrial Revolution.

Correction: An earlier version of this article mistakenly reported Karan Johar as saying Fawad should find new platforms to showcase his talents. In actuality, Johar said he hopes Fawad finds the 'best' platforms. The error is regretted. 


Hasan | 5 years ago | Reply I would like to see Fawad Khan openly denounce any further association with anything Indian. That would make us proud of Fawad Khan. Indian politicians, sportsmen & even artists alike have blatantly and shamelessly engaged in propaganda against Pakistan for years. It is time Pakistan adopts a ZERO TOLERANCE POLICY for Indian terrorism on Pakistani Soil. Enough.
Giri | 6 years ago | Reply This episode again highlights dependence on Pakistani cinema and artists on Hindi film industry. When Dangal was not released in Pak people started blaming India again. On the one hand they say they do not want Indian movies but when Indians themselves do not release their movies they cry foul. This is childish and immature behaviour. Same is true with Fawad episode. If you do not like Indians and Indian film industry then why go there for job? Be firm and consistent like I see most Indians these days. No contact with Pakistanis means no contact at all. Let us not have any relationship. All the bus and train service between two countries also must be stopped immediately. Because it does not make sense when you otherwise cannot get along peacefully. It becomes hypocrisy then.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read