Rumi wasn't yours: Afghan fury as Iran, Turkey claim Sufi poet

Rumi is one of the best-selling poets in the US, and his works have been translated into more than 23 languages

Afp June 30, 2016
Artistic depiction of Rumi, 1980. PHOTO: WIKIPEDIA

KABUL,: Who can lay claim to Rumi, the Sufi mystic who is one of the world's most beloved poets? A bid by Iran and Turkey to do so has exasperated Afghanistan, country of his birth eight centuries ago.

Tehran and Ankara asked to list the work of Jalal ud-Din Muhammad Rumi as their joint heritage on the UN's "Memory of the World" register in May.

The register, falling under the UN's cultural organisation UNESCO, was formed in 1997 to protect the world's documentary heritage -- archives, correspondence and writing -- especially in troubled or conflict-ridden areas.

8 non-white actors who’d make a better Rumi than Leonardo DiCaprio

But the Afghan government has denounced the bid, which mainly concerns the 25,600 verses of "Masnavi-i-Ma'navi", one of the most influential works in Persian literature.

He is one of the best-selling poets in the US, and his works have been translated into more than 23 languages. Hollywood is planning a Rumi biopic -- also mired in controversy after rumoured plans for Leonardo DiCaprio to play him were met with accusations of "whitewashing".

The poet and philosopher "was born in Balkh in Afghanistan and made us proud," the Ministry of Information and Culture insisted.

UNESCO "never asked us" about the proposal, Harron Haklimi, the ministry's spokesperson, said, acknowledging that Kabul had been beaten to the punch but hoping they can yet convince the organisation that Afghanistan has the better claim to the poet.

For Afghans, who learn his poems in primary school, Rumi is "Maulana Jalaludin Balkh", or "Maulana" (literally "our master"), or simply "Balkhi".

Most researchers agree he was born in Balkh, Afghanistan in 1207 -- though this too has been the subject of debate: a few argue he was born just across the border, in what is modern day Tajikistan, in a region also known as Balkh.

Today, the Afghan town of Balkh is a small provincial settlement, but back then it was an ancient religious capital and centre for Buddhist and Persian literature. It was sacked by Genghis Khan and his Mongal hordes in 1221.

Too white: DiCaprio not acceptable as Rumi

The young Rumi and his family fled to Turkey, where he spent most of his life -- he died in the city of Konya in 1273. It was there that his son founded the Order of the Whirling Dervishes to perpetuate his father's teachings.

But for Afghans, he remains a child of their country and it is still possible to visit the house in which they believe he was born.

The powerful governor of Balkh province, former warlord General Ata Mohammad Noor called on Afghanistan's representative to the United Nations to protest.

"By limiting Maulana to only two countries, we do not do justice to a global personality who is truly cherished and admired across the world," he said.

"He is considered an important part of the culture and identity of Afghanistan," writer and poet Sadiq Usyan, professor at the Balkh university in nearby provincial capital Mazar-i-Sharif, told AFP.

Separating the two is considered an "insult" and even a "threat" to Afghanistan, he said.

A UNESCO representative in Kabul argued there had been some "confusion".

"Any country, delegation or even individual can submit a request to be considered under this program," said spokesman Ricardo Grassi.

He noted the backlash, adding: "But this request has still to be considered."

Rumi so white: Hollywood filmmaker wants to cast Leo as Sufi mystic

To accede to it without mentioning Afghanistan would be unacceptable, said the director of Balkh's provincial cultural department, Salih Mohammad Khaleeq.

"Maulana belongs to Afghanistan."

Khaleeq has big plans for Balkh -- especially since Oscar-winning star DiCaprio was tipped to play Rumi in the new Hollywood film.

The unconfirmed rumour spread rapidly on social media with accusations of film industry "whitewashing", with the hashtag #RumiWasntWhite swiftly trending.

"So easy for Hollywood to find Muslims to play terrorists, but they can't cast a Muslim as Rumi?" read one typical tweet.

Another said: "remember when idris elba wasn't 'english enough' to play james bond, but it's chill if leo dicaprio plays rumi."

For Khaleeq, however, the film is an opportunity.

"We want this place to become a tourist site where tourists can come and visit," he said.

A large portrait of Rumi already greets visitors arriving in Balkh. However, his childhood home has been ravaged by time, badly weathered with its ochre-coloured mud walls collapsed, the interior open to the wind.

The controversy has warmed spirits in the region, with an online petition collecting nearly 6,000 signatures.

President Ashraf Ghani, who in mid-June hosted Turkey's foreign minister Mevlut Cavusoglu, has been carefully diplomatic, with a statement saying Rumi is "a shared pride of the two countries".

It added he was ready to register Rumi's works "as a shared heritage of Turkey and Afghanistan".

He made no mention of Iran.

Clues to what Rumi himself might have made of the dispute may lay in his writings.

In 2007, Afghanistan, Iran and Turkey came together with UNESCO to mark the 800th anniversary of his birth.

Then, the cultural organisation issued a medal in his honour while citing one of his famous couplets: "I do not distinguish between the relative and the stranger".


Saleem Mir,MD | 6 years ago | Reply At the end of Maulana Rumi festival in Konya Turkey in 1989 I was interviewed by Turkish international radio service representative and asked this pointed question; Iranian claim Maulana Rumi to be theirs whereas we Turks consider him ours. What is your thought on it? They were startled at my answer. "We in Pakistan believe he is ours." Then I forwarded my explanation. Maulana is a jewel like a brilliant star and adored by all nations in the region. He claimed to belong to no particular place,race,nation or even religion. He was part of the whole creation. How dare we imprison him in the one locale,people or nation? Ending my argument with a couplet of Ghalib "Hon harifoN say na khush magar zanan-e misr say/hay zulakha khush key mehve mahe kinaaN ho gaeiN" ( it is customary to be jealous of your Love's lover but Zulaikha is overjoyed that women of Egypt fell in fancy of Yusuf) Let us all rejoice that our beloved is star of every seeing eye!
Naeem | 6 years ago | Reply Just look at the people who fight on Rumi and belittle him to their own level. He conquered the world even after 8 hundred years, people of all cultures and countries Love him. If Rumi was alive, if had he selected any of these countries and people, those would be the most literate and peaceful.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read