Driven out of the EU

The doors to the EU are closing, and unlikely to open again in the foreseeable future

Editorial April 10, 2016
Migrants walk along a road towards a makeshift camp at the Greek-Macedonian border, near the Greek village of Idomeni, Greece March 4, 2016. PHOTO: REUTERS

Confusion, anger and crushing disappointment surrounds the deportation from Greece of a batch of more than 200 migrants, most of them Pakistanis. It is a part of an attempt by the European Union (EU) to slow or preferably halt the flow of humanity attempting to reach Europe and escape from the wars of the Middle East, primarily the war in Syria. The inflow has produced a crisis in Europe that has challenged one of the fundamentals of the EU, namely the Schengen Agreement that allows free movement across borders. A formula has now been devised whereby the EU will deport those that it terms illegal — essentially economic migrants — and those that it defines as bonafide refugees from war who will be allowed to stay pending the investigation of their asylum claims. The numbers deported will be reciprocated by an equal number currently in Turkey in one of the many camps there, and they will be allowed into the EU but only up to 72,000.

The reciprocal scheme has only been operating for a few days but it has been widely condemned by civil rights organisations in the EU and the Middle East. The streams of migrants are a mixture of those who are fleeing warfare or persecution, principally from Syria but also Iraq and Libya; and those from a range of other countries seeking a better life elsewhere. Significant numbers of those are from Pakistan and they make up a pool of ‘illegals’ in all of the EU states as well as the UK, which is not a Schengen signatory. The EU states have an elevated level of concern about terrorist entryism using the refugee stream as cover, and there is indeed evidence that this has happened already. Given the parlous state of Pakistan’s international reputation as a mother-lode of terrorism, it is unsurprising — though unfair and highly discriminatory — that Pakistanis are among the first to be deported to Turkey and then reportedly deported from Turkey back to Pakistan under an agreement ratified by the Turkish parliament as far back as 2010. The doors to the EU are closing, and unlikely to open again in the foreseeable future.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 11th,  2016.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.



Toti calling | 8 years ago | Reply The deal with Turkey is against the spirit of EU laws, but with people entering in large numbers, many locals were changing loyalties to extremist parties which would change the political culture. On top of that many asylum homes are being attacked and people molested. In Germany alone there were over 250 arsenal attacks and anybody looking like a foreigner is looked at with suspicion. In my view immigration in small number is fine, but not in unlimited numbers. And Pakistanis have no war to escape from only want to enter for economic gains. And EU does not allow entry for that reason and would return such people.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ