Panama Papers leaks: Two ex-judges decline to head PM’s inquiry commission

No former judge may show willingness in view of opposition’s reservations

Hasnaat Malik April 08, 2016
Nasirul Mulk, Sair Ali. PHOTO: FILE


The government is still unable to notify the high-level judicial inquiry commission announced by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in the wake of the Panama Papers leaks as two former members of the superior judiciary have refused to take up the task.

Nawaz’s two sons and a daughter have been named in the documents leaked from the Panama-based law firm Mossack Fonseca for owning offshore businesses. While denying any wrongdoing, the PM has announced a judicial probe into the allegations against his family.

PM Nawaz forms judicial commission to probe Panama Papers

A senior official told The Express Tribune two former Supreme Court judges – Justice (retd) Nasirul Mulk and Justice (retd) Sair Ali – have shown unwillingness to lead the high-level inquiry commission.

“Now the government officials are also contacting other
retired judges but no one has given a positive response to take up this task till now,” he said, while speaking on the condition of anonymity.

Sources said no credible retired judge will show willingness to be part of the probe in view of the opposition parties’ reservations over formation of the commission under retired judges.

While legal experts believe that it will be difficult for the incumbent superior judiciary to accept the government’s request to give a judge for probing the Panama Papers, the government, according to an official, is also not interested to form the commission under a serving judge.

“If a reasonable retired judge is not available then the government may consider the offer of the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) president Ali Zafar to probe the Panama Papers leaks,” he said, adding that a senior official had already consulted Zafar, seeking his point of view on the commission.

The SCBA president has also urged the judiciary to refrain from taking up the issue.

Imran Khan demands commission headed by CJP to probe Panama Papers revelations

Finance Minister Ishaq Dar, State Minister Zahid Hamid and Special Assistant to Prime Minister on Law Barrister Zafarullah are busy finalising the Terms of Reference (ToRs) of the proposed commission.

A senior lawyer associated with the ruling PML-N, however, expressed wonder over the prime minister’s announcement to form an inquiry commission, adding that the pronouncement was made in haste and now the ToRs should be made after overseeing all legal implications.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 9th, 2016.


salman | 8 years ago | Reply @Imran Qadri: That's the thing, I don't have to believe IK because i can read the audited report of hospital wwhich states the investment was retuned in full from HGB. I actually agreed with your first comment, there should be a commission to investigate SKMH and IK with depth forensic investigation, and thisshould cover eeveryone mentioned in Panamaleaks. Do you agree? Although i do have to wonder why govthas suddenly become concerned by SKMH the day after pPanamaleaks broke iinstead of the 3 years they have been in power. Regarding offshore companies - the issue is not offshoreccompanies, but source of funds that need clarification.
F Khan | 8 years ago | Reply Which judge of repute and conscience will take this challenge to investigate the issue when he knows that in case of honest report not favouring PTI & IK views they will be called bikao, corrupt and b team of PMLN from the top of a container for 6 months every hour every day.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ