The double standard

The new bill is designed to remove bureaucratic hurdles that normally make it impossible for women to file complaints

Anam Khan March 01, 2016
The writer is a communications professional who holds a BA in English Literature from Smith College and an MS in Communications Practice from Columbia University. She tweets @anamk10

Punjab Governor Rafique Rajwana recently approved the 2015 Protection of Women Against Violence Bill. The law criminalises all offences against women, including domestic violence, emotional abuse, psychological abuse, economic abuse, verbal abuse, stalking, abetment of an offence and cyber crimes. A toll free number will also be introduced to receive complaints, in addition to the creation of shelter homes that will provide boarding and lodging facilities to aggrieved women seeking protection.

The new bill is designed to remove bureaucratic hurdles that normally make it impossible for women to file complaints and access any form of justice. One only hopes that the classification of violence against women as a criminal act will make perpetrators fearful of a legal system that will no longer lean in their favour and allow them to go scot-free.

I’m eager to perceive the bill as a guaranteed sign of progress, but one question still troubles me. Does the bill necessarily eradicate the myopic thought process that singles out women for being at fault for harrowing assaults inflicted on them? Our society’s tendency to immediately blame a woman’s attire or character for triggering a man’s indecent behaviour only propagates Pakistan’s widespread rape culture, along with the double standards that give rise to more abusive behaviour.

In October 2015, the Council of Islamic Ideology (CII) announced that women are not required to cover their faces, hands or feet under Islamic Sharia law. Even though this judgment is considered encouraging, the CII also advised women to “follow ethics and have a careful attitude in society”. They went on to say that, “At the same time, it’s necessary to cover the face and adopt complete covering attire if there are threats of mischief”. The whole “boys will be boys” excuse is an old cliche that continues to prevail. It shouldn’t only be a woman’s job to be patient and calm. The onus shouldn’t only fall on a woman to dress ‘modestly’ and protect her self from a man’s intrusive gaze. Why is it utterly simple for men to receive the benefit of the doubt?

These poor, helpless men are apparently in danger of succumbing to temptation, which is why women must bring it upon themselves to spare them the trouble. Why can’t men ever be expected to exhibit any self-control? Why can’t they just find it in themselves to be a little more respectful and look away instead of trying to undress a woman with their eyes? It’s true that women should make an effort not to attract unnecessary attention, but how far will they have to go to protect themselves? It’s unbelievable how a woman’s choice of clothing is also called into question after she’s been assaulted or harassed.

Even though the new bill is a step in the right direction, it should also address the specific mindset that induces violent behaviour against women. Men should be expected to show some restraint instead of constantly rationalising their inappropriate conduct.

If there are any amendments made to the current bill, here is what they should include: “No matter what a woman is wearing, and no matter how much skin she’s revealing, that doesn’t justify a man’s indecent behaviour. Those actions on his part are not only illegal, but also immoral, disgusting and inexcusable.”

Published in The Express Tribune, March 2nd, 2016.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Arslan Mughal | 5 years ago | Reply I hail the idea that has been put or raised in favour of women because It is against the idealogoy of Islam.Islam forbids to commit violance over women.It provides the equal right to women as men bear.Because of the equality provided to Women by Islam , thousands of women across the Globe are accepting the Islam. I don't understand the born Muslims are trying to abandone the rules & the way of living , the way of dressing is being violated.Why? What absured is this to say that it isn't prerequisite for Muslim women to cover their faces.We are Muslims and Islam weilds & doesn't let us to violate the rules.By snubbing the religion , there is no progress.So what's going on in Pakistan in the name of Secularism , I don't know.Last day , Mumtaz Qadari was hanged just because he tried to secure the Islamic idealogoies.Is it really a Mislim country where all this is happening.
Parvez | 5 years ago | Reply Its not the total cure........but its a step in the right direction. as the saying goes ' Lets be thankful for small mercies '.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read