Pakistan should not move to electronic voting system before 2023: UN expert

Ronan McDermott advises country to give time to trial runs before switching completely

Irfan Ghauri February 11, 2016
Advises country to try out EVMs until 2023. PHOTO: AFP


A leading United Nations expert on electoral technology has advised Pakistan’s top polls supervisory body against completely moving to an electronic voting system before 2023.

Ronan McDermott was speaking on ‘Use of Technology in Elections’ — with particular focus on electronic voting machines (EVMs) and biometrics — jointly organised by the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) and the United Nations Development Programme.

Members of the parliamentary committee on electoral reforms attended the session, during which the UN expert presented a global view of the merits and demerits of the main electoral technologies, and shared comparative experience on their adoption.

Electoral reforms: ECP told to buy electronic voting machines by September

“My experience in election management in Pakistan and other countries leads me to recommend that Pakistan pilot a variety of EVMs over 2017 and in some 2018 general elections polling stations to determine which technology is most appropriate,” said McDermott.

Subject to successful pilots — and stakeholder acceptance — the ECP should gradually scale up the EVMs with a target date for full national rollout not earlier than 2023, he added.

On results technology, the specialist recommended that the result management system be given a solid legal framework and be used in all by-elections between now and 2018. “Transparent result management contributes to the ECP’s credibility. Trust is more important than technology itself.”

Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Justice Sardar Muhammad Raza outlined how the ECP, in consultation with the parliamentary sub-committee on electoral reforms, had piloted a range of innovative initiatives such as mobile results transmission, biometric voter identification and a geographic information system-enabled polling scheme.

The myth around electronic voting machines

“Before committing to a large technology purchase,” the CEC noted, “the ECP would carefully review its appropriateness to the context of Pakistan, and would also test it extensively in the field.”

Nadra blocks CNICs

The country’s top citizen registration body told a parliamentary panel that it had blocked 136,000 identity cards because of wrong information provided by the card holders.

During an in-camera session of a parliamentary sub-committee on electoral reforms, National Database & Registration Authority (Nadra) officials said they had also identified 15,247 people who had more than one computerised national identity card (CNIC).

The registration body is in the process of verifying another 9,000 CNICs with possibly wrong credentials, and is also investigating 72,000 CNICs issued to foreign nationals during the past few years.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 11th,  2016.

Facebook Conversations


doom | 4 years ago | Reply | Recommend This is all perfectly reasonable. Of course you should test it out in the next election in pilots, so that any issues can be sorted before going full scale. I would hope no one was actually thinking of abruptly switching over completely.
John B | 4 years ago | Reply | Recommend EVM must be field tested for sometime when they are introduced. All elections get legitimacy only if the people trust the system. Educational campaign about the EVM, Acceptance among public, introduction in select precincts and switching them once satisfied by the ECP. The great experiment went on in India and I am sure ECP and ECI shared their experiences. Unless ECP has absolute supremacy in the conduct of elections as in India, EVM can be percieved as cheating tool by the public. I am sure ECP is doing its best.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ