We should be grateful

Our politicians, leaders and people like myself should be thankful that we live in a country where the vast majority of those who suffer in poverty ask so little of us.

Nadir Eledroos August 23, 2010
We should be thankful. We should be thankful that we are a resilient nation, where those who had nearly nothing, have now lost everything, are probably better positioned then the state itself to recover from the floods.

Our politicians, generals, bureaucrats, landlords, industrialists and people like myself, should be thankful that we live in a country where the vast majority of those who suffer in poverty ask so little from people like us.

That I am able to sit in London and write this blog, to be published in an English language newspaper in a country where a small majority speaks English, says volumes of how people such as myself have divided and fragmented society between the haves and have not’s. Regardless of the best of my intentions, I can by no means come close to claiming to understand the suffering of the 20 million or so for whom the floods are an ongoing calamity.

Pakistan seems to have become a hornet’s nest of terrorism, militancy, political instability, infighting and natural disasters. In this chaotic flux it’s not surprising that our government has come up short in offering relief. What is surprising is that society in general has come up short in helping their fellow Pakistani’s.

Years of conspiratorial twists and religious intolerance seems to have shredded the notion of the “fellow Pakistani”. After all, for many Ahmedi’s deserve death rather than full citizenship, Christians deserve to be deprived of relief goods, Punjabi’s are superior to Sindhi’s, those in uniform are better Pakistani’s then everyone else. The divisions and fractions have been magnified by the intolerance spewed in the media, around our dinner tables and in our schools.

Years of blaming everyone for our problems, years of pointing fingers at the nefarious and malicious designs of the CIA, RAW, Mossad and MI6 combined, has projected globally an image of Pakistan that is hostile to the West, its neighbours and anyone that offers an opportunity to shift Pakistan’s problems upon. Is anyone surprised then that people in America have not overwhelmingly supported Secretary Clinton’s donation appeals? And this isn’t the first time; a similar appeal to help IDP’s from Swat was also met with similar disinterest.

That we would rather toy with the lives of millions of people rather than accept aid from India, speaks volumes of the disconnect between those making decisions and those who have to bear the consequences of such callousness. Could someone elaborate as to how Pakistan was better served by dilly dallying over whether to be choosy on whose aid to receive? If security is an issue, we should have nothing to be worried about. As an online “rating” site has claimed, the ISI is the best intelligence agency in the world and RAW is only at number nine. We have nothing to fear, even if the Indian donation adds up to something nefarious.

As for people like me, we are part of the problem rather than the solution. We uphold a system which treats flood victims as political props and backdrops for photo calls. We uphold a system which calls for breaching dykes dependent on the political affiliation of the inhabitants of the area rather than common sense.

Most importantly, we uphold a system that is neither compassionate not empathetic. That in the face of terrorism or natures fury, the best we can do is to call on international support to act as a bulwark against militancy, rather than a humanitarian concern we ourselves frame aid as a security concern. The human side of this tragedy is lost on us, as we have little in common with those who suffer, those who are homeless, those who have lost their possessions.

For that we should be thankful. We should be thankful that we have a resilient population, while we call for international aid and debate why its not forthcoming; that while donor conferences are planned, and politicians and military leaders survey the damage cocooned within their security bubble, the people of Pakistan will go on living their lives, helping each other and make the most of what little aid they receive.

We should expect little of our elite. For whatever they do pales in comparison with the efforts people like the truck drivers who volunteer for days driving Edhi ambulances, the nurses who work a week with a few hours of rest, the overwhelmed doctor doing his best to offer support, and more importantly hope, students who travel great distances to offer support, the young men who wade through chest high water to gather what little food they can to bring back to their stranded community. At the end of the day we should be thankful for such people, for they save us the embarrassment of looking at ourselves in the mirror. We probably would not like what we see.
Nadir Eledroos Nadir teaches Economics at Bellerbys College, London and is interested in Pakistani politics and current affairs. He tweets @needroos (https://twitter.com/needroos)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Feza Khan Yusufzai | 11 years ago | Reply You summed up everything very well, and Yes we are indeed part of the problem and responsible of everything thats going on, and unless we do our part, its unfortunately gonna stay this way.
Syed Nadir El-Edroos | 11 years ago | Reply Continuing on the same theme: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-11040132 US help has come just as the local population were deciding not to wait for government help to start rebuilding bridges and clear roads. Bridges and hotels were wrecked by the devastating floods Malik Ghazan Khan, head of local volunteers, told the BBC that they knew if they looked to the government it could take months or even years. "We are doing it on the basis of self-help because who else can assist us at this moment, except God?" he says. "The chief minister has told us they can't do it immediately. He said they had to go through processes and procedures, so it takes time. "So we have decided to do it ourselves. I salute the brave people of Kalam, they have so far reconstructed six bridges. We have made 18km to 20km road useable now." http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-11056510
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ