With infrastructure that is crumbling, along with a lack of ownership by the citizens, Karachi will surely descend into utter chaos if it rains heavily. PHOTO: PPI

If Lahore couldn't handle the rains, what hope does Karachi have?

When the immaculately-managed city of Lahore couldn’t bear the brunt of nature and was unprepared, how can Karachi?

Arsalan Faruqi July 22, 2018
Karachi has a love-hate relationship with the monsoon season. While Karachiites long for rain throughout the year, we shudder at the very thought of prolonged downpour, flooding, destruction and power outages that are inevitably associated with it.

The last time this city truly got to enjoy the rainy season was during Mustafa Kamal’s tenure, when despite drains heavily clogged with rainwater – especially the Gujjar Nala and Neher-e-Khayyam – alternate drainage arrangements were made and the citizens were spared the entire rain-related trauma.

Things are much, much different now. With monsoon rains that are imminent and expected any day now, infrastructure that is crumbling, a mayor in office with plenty of excuses to not do enough for the relief of Karachiites, along with a lack of ownership by the citizens, the city will surely descend into utter chaos if it rains heavily.

After all, the entire country witnessed the state of developed cities like Lahore and Islamabad during this monsoon season in Punjab. When a city like Lahore – with all possible funds spent for development and former Chief Minister Punjab Shehbaz Sharif’s personal attention to details – couldn’t bear the brunt of nature and was unprepared, how can Karachi – the disowned and severely ignored city – survive?

Karachi is home to immigrants from all over the country, who come down to this port city in search of jobs. Their uncontrolled influx has further choked the housing and infrastructure of the city, as they mostly settle down in encroached areas. Punjab, on the other hand, hasn’t experienced this influx as yet, and thus the common man on the streets owns the city and appreciates all the good work done by the government. Then how did the recent rains wreak havoc in the immaculately-managed city of Lahore?

Men watch a sinkhole form on Mall Road. Photo: M Shehzad/ Express

A man pushes his car on a flooded road in Lahore. Photo: M Shehzad/ Express

Water levels rise in a Lahore parking lot. Photo: M Shehzad/ Express

From where I view this, Shehbaz has created a facade by laying down an excellent road network, bridges, underpasses and advanced mass transit systems, but did not bother putting in extended effort on underground drainage systems, simply because they are not visible and could not translate into votes.

Back in the day, Kamal took the risk and worked on the underground infrastructure first, before moving to the ground level. However, the drainage system of Karachi today needs a complete overhaul, since the system hasn’t been maintained or repaired since Kamal left. From widening of existing drains to removal of encroachments, serious efforts are needed to keep devastation at bay from the city.

During Kamal’s era, he came to the rescue when Clifton was badly flooded, and despite not being responsible for areas falling under cantonments, he worked on footings and laid down a system that has kept Clifton from submerging in the years to come. Similarly, Gulistan-e-Jauhar is a neighbourhood that was ignored by all previous provincial as well as local governments. It was Kamal and his team that laid down a very effective drainage system which remains functional to date and has kept the area from flooding. What Karachi needs is similar leadership and ruthless accountability against all those who are involved in corruption and choose to do nothing while the city slowly nears its doom.

Throughout the world, drainage systems have a specific capacity, after which they cease to fulfil their purpose. Once the threshold is met, streets get flooded and evacuations have to take place. For instance, last year, we saw Hurricane Harvey bring destruction to several cities in Texas, mainly Houston. Even a developed country like the US, possessing state-of-the-art infrastructure, could not handle the intense rains, eventually causing massive flooding, evacuations, destruction of property and deaths. Nonetheless, the rescue services and city administration in Houston was fully functional and despite the havoc, order was soon restored, inquiries were initiated and compensations were made.

It may sound like a reach, but we need such efficient systems in place in a major metropolitan city like Karachi, where a single day of economic shutdown takes the entire country a few steps back. Ensuring proper drainage for rainwater is the only solution. In order to prepare for the upcoming monsoon spell, here are some basic steps the current caretaker government of Sindh should take:

1. Gujjar Nala is a major rainwater channel that has been heavily encroached. All previous governments could not address this issue due to “political” implications. Now is the chance to take the bull by its horns and get it cleared of all encroachments, which have led to it being narrowed to only a few feet.

2. All the rainwater drains running throughout the city must be cleaned and widened.

3. The government should start educating the masses through electronic and print media about the implications of encroaching on rainwater drains, and how it negatively affects the whole city.

On another note, we need civic awareness programs at a public level to make Karachiites realise that if they want a decent living style, they will have to own this city, avoid dumping trash in drains and more readily contribute towards a cleaner and greener Karachi.
Arsalan Faruqi An entrepreneur with a degree in computer engineering and an MBA from IBA Karachi. He tweets as @arsalanfaruqi (https://twitter.com/arsalanfaruqi)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Sane | 2 years ago | Reply Is Lahore a benchmark for good management?
sterry | 2 years ago | Reply I hope you realize that tales of Islamabad Airport being logged with rain and water was just false news and fake since people like me witnessed nothing wrong during that time when we were at the airport. Lahore's infrastructure and rain problems with the monsoon are also grossly exaggerated and most people understand that nature can never be tamed fully. That's why developed European cities like even in Germany have flooding and resultant deaths.
Patwari | 2 years ago Not so Humza, not so at all. It's almost pathetic the way you defend your ethnic provincials, overlords. Like a broken record. You keep repeating the same mantra, about the Qaid from Jati Umra and his cabal. People reading your strange, flaky out of touch, out of reality comments... are flabbergasted. They do not expect this gibberish from a Son of the Soil. See, it is not about taming nature, it is about building sewers, nullahs, drains, laying pipes, culverts, to minimize the effects of monsoons. It's called planning. Men, women and children are guaranteed, repeat, guaranteed to die in Lahore every each monsoon season. Is that acceptable to you? No accountability? The Shariff Bros. had 35 years to do this. Make Lahore, [and Punjab] the 'shining city on the hill'. But their greed and corruption and looting got the better of them. And now, it's time to pay the Piper. Here are a few under investigation, examples of corruption from the rulers of Punjab:- Saaf Paani scam. Qatari LNG contract scam. Ashianna Housing scam Narowal Sport Complex scam. Ephedrine scam [built a few hundred yards from Hindustani border!! DHA plot allotment scam. Within shelling range of Indian Bofors/mortars] CDA [Islamabad] allotments scam.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ