I am a doctor, but I don't work miracles

Doctors are labelled as selfish, arrogant and disengaged. Have people forgotten that they are also human?

Omar Chughtai May 17, 2011
Much is made these days about how callous doctors have become - how selfish, arrogant and disengaged they are from their patients. They charge exorbitant fees and pay only passing attention to their patients’ conditions. They get rich while the poor patients suffer.

All of that is partially true; it describes many doctors I know. In fact, in a general sense, it describes a lot of people I know. So I have concluded two things:

1. I should get to know better people.

2. Doctors are human. And they are a part of the same society we all are. They have the same qualities and the same faults that anyone else has.

Now, I have to admit that I am a little biased since I myself am a doctor.  But my biased view also gives me a close look at many of my colleagues who work hard to get it right. As a pathologist I regularly interact with several doctors in a day. Most of the doctors I talk to are not just interested in their patients’ diagnosis, they are also deeply moved by it. They try hard to get it right.

They are by no means perfect. But they are still a lot better than you might think.

Threats and accusations

Lately a doctor’s life has become rather dangerous. Every patient and every case has the potential to explode, and doctors find themselves living on the edge. Every day patients threaten their doctors with exposing them to the ‘media’.

Just yesterday, a patient threatened to break windows in my lab because he thought his results were incorrect. It has become common practice to cite ‘negligence’ by the doctor whenever a patient dies. Regardless of medical facts and circumstance, the cause of death in far too many cases these days is ‘the doctor.’ Never mind that the patient was 78 years old and had terminal cancer; or that the patient was brought to the doctor in critical condition, past the point of no return.

A few weeks ago a highly respected critical care physician was beaten up by the attendants of a deceased patient. And I am not talking about pushing and shoving. Him, his junior doctor, nurse and the ICU attendant were all beaten up. It was 2am and the doctor had been called in to the hospital in the middle of the night because the patient was considered critical. The doctor was at the bedside when the patient died. He did all he could, but he could not produce a miracle. And that was the reason they were all physically abused.

As a doctor, a Pakistani and as a human being, I think this is utterly disgusting.  I know that there are many sides to many stories, but aren’t some things off the table?

When did we become such barbarians?

This post was originally published here.
Omar Chughtai An avid reader of blogs who works as Lab Director at Chughtais Lahore Lab. Omar tweets @OmarChughtai.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Happy Man | 13 years ago | Reply @phatty: No worries, at-least you realized :D
phatty | 13 years ago | Reply @Happy Man: lol, woops. Yeah, I realized that after I posted my response :$
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ