What Obama didn't say to Pakistan

What message did Obama's speech send to Pakistan - a country that needs teachers, not troops?

Bryan Farris January 28, 2011
On Wednesday morning at 7AM in Pakistan, all eyes were on America.

As I cradled a steamy cup of coffee and willed the morning mental fog to drift away, I eagerly took in an invigorating State of the Union address from President Barack Obama.
"In America, innovation doesn’t just change our lives. It’s how we make a living"

I was inspired.  Had it not been for the morning cobwebs tying me down, I might have belted out a “Yes, we can!”
To every young person listening tonight who’s contemplating their career choice: if you want to make a difference in the life of our nation; if you want to make a difference in the life of a child – become a teacher. Your country needs you.

Now you’re talking!

The majority of the speech was a prescriptive account of the domestic hurdles the US needs to surmount; challenges that, if overcome, would truly be revolutionary for America.

Let me repeat that: for America. America needs innovation; America needs education; America needs a Sputnik moment.  But what about the rest of the world? As his speech went on about America’s greatness and the need to “win the future”, my pride morphed into embarrassment.

Progress is not a zero-sum game, I thought to myself. America’s best shot at greatness is not by out-competing the world, but by helping the world become great itself. A successful entrepreneur knows that it is better to have a smaller piece of a larger pie than to have a big piece of a small pie.  Obama’s speech seemed to lay claim to a diabetes inducing portion of the world economy (I guess our obesity problem has really gotten out of hand).

When Obama finally started talking about foreign issues, I inched a little lower in my seat.  America should be focused on moving forward, transitioning from an unenviable role as global police to the leader in global development.

Obama mentioned Pakistan once in his speech saying, “In Pakistan, al Qaeda’s leadership is under more pressure than at any point since 2001…we will not relent, we will not waver, and we will defeat you.”

Did I hear George W Bush? This does nothing but reinforce the misconception that Pakistan is a country of terrorists. There are a few terrorists in Pakistan, that much is certain, but the real issue in Pakistan is the literacy rate, which is at 55 per cent. Furthermore, violence cannot be quelled with violence; it is development and education that are needed, and if you think America’s education system needs an oil change, Pakistan’s needs a complete engine overhaul.  We should be sending in teachers, not troops.

The State of the Union is weak.  Obama is right to focus on domestic issues and to emphasise innovation and education while cutting the deficit (if that’s even possible), but America needs to re-think its outward perspective.

On Tuesday evening in Washington DC, the world was listening, pining to hear Obama say that America would support them. America does need to win the future, not for itself, but for the world.

The original post was published here.
Bryan Farris An Acumen Fund fellow in the class of 2011 who blogs at RisingPyramid.org.Bryan currently works at Ansaar Management Company in Lahore.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


G. Din | 13 years ago | Reply @Sabeen Masood "...I mean everything was safe here before we started “war on terror.”" You are being quite modest. Before the so-called "war on terror", Pakistan was frantically busy sowing seeds for the harvest you are reaping now. Aaah, those were the "good old days" when men and materi'al were flowing like water from US and Pakistanis were doing/assisting holy ehad against another the "Evil Empire", the USSR, You must not forget your history; it is a continuum. Now, that very superpower, transformed into Russia, is chuckling at both Pakistan and US from the sidelines. As they say, who laughs last has the best laugh!
Saadullah Awan | 13 years ago | Reply In 2009, Obama gave the promise of closing the inhumane Guantanamo Bay by the 22nd of January 2010. It is now the 29th of January 2011 and the base is still operating. For me, and all cynical people in this 'land of the pure', he is as bad as George W. Bush. Being a democrat or pushing for fewer tax cuts does not make him an angel in my eyes. He is the president of the USA, elected because he will always prefer USA national interests over the interests of the third world and more importantly for us, over the interests of Pakistan.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ