Aamir Khan sometimes cries – Get over it

We’re the only species deeming our own physiological bodily responses ‘improper’, in favour of a daft social construct

Faraz Talat August 26, 2015
In a rational universe, no man would ever be turned into an internet meme for doing what psychologically healthy humans are naturally predisposed to do cry.

Aamir Khan was widely forgiven for his first weeping offense after watching Bajrangi Bhaijan in July. The episode was popularly attributed to the film’s earnest portrayal of a man’s conquest of inter-religious strife, capable of making even grown men cry.

second tear-sighting within a month, was ostensibly too much for the public to shrug at. In an interview with NDTV, director Nikhil Advani revealed that Khan cried profusely during the screening of ‘Katti Batti’.

Photo: Express Tribune
 “The last 22 minutes and I literally had to sit and hold the tissue box for Aamir. He has copious tears! And he was crying and crying and crying…”

Let’s take Advani’s word for it. Let’s disregard the obvious hyperbole about him ‘literally’ holding a box of tissues for Khan during the final 22 minutes of movie, and assume that it actually happened. Let’s ignore the fact that Advani has figured out that Khan’s lacrimal secretions may grant Katti Batti the same added publicity that they magnanimously bestowed to Bajrangi Bhaijan. Because the ‘tear jerkiness’ of a Bollywood flick is now officially being gauged in millimetres of tears shed upon it by the star of PK.

Assuming the veracity of it all, why would a man’s appropriate tearfulness at an emotionally charged event – whether it be Floyd Mayweather at a press conference, or Chris Pine at the Oscars – invite such an intense reaction from the public?

Photo: News Buzz Daily

Photo: Daily Mail

I use these examples in particular to limn the universality of this phenomenon, where men are shamed for not repressing their emotions. John Boehner, Speaker of the United States House of Representatives, has been lampooned by essentially every American institution of comedy from Bill Maher to Saturday Night Live, for getting misty-eyed too frequently. Boehner offers comedians a cornucopia of political material to satirise, yet we’ve latched ourselves to the least joke-worthy thing about him.

Photo: Reuters

I’m at the cusp of having my own membership from the cult of manhood revoked, for the ease with which I’m personally driven to tears. I am known among friends for taking long drives for the explicit purpose of having a good cry, facilitated by a playlist including, but not limited to, ‘My Immortal’ and ‘The Sound of Silence’.

It’s not unmanly, juvenile, or even necessarily indicative of depression; it’s cathartic.

The association of emotional expressiveness with femininity partly explains society’s disapproval of it. Womanhood denotes weakness, and so does any characteristic archetypically linked to it. ‘Boys don’t cry’ is a meaningless canard in a natural order where boys, and even grown men, are clearly inclined to cry when traumatised. ‘Cats don’t meow’ means nothing, when we’ve established that they actually do that.

The social media’s inexplicably exuberant reaction to Khan’s teariness at the end of a genuinely sad flick probably has Madhuri Dixit rolling in tears of her own, along with the rest of the crew responsible for the heart-warming ‘Start With the Boys’ campaign.

You may remember the short film running on Indian channels starting last October, about the society browbeating boys into hiding their tears, until they emerge as the emotionally repressed zombies we expect them to be. The ritualistic clogging of Twitter with memes and jokes about Khan crying is evidence that we’ve learned little from that campaign.



We’re perhaps the only species deeming our own physiological bodily responses ‘improper’, in favour of a daft social construct that causes actual harm to our psychological wellbeing.

Men were not put on earth exclusively to play cricket and Grand Theft Auto and in the lucid intervals where they are not beating each other raw for ‘looking at them weird’, get together and laugh at girls for their allegedly labile emotional state.

There’s nothing to be gained by glorifying insensitivity and shaming all that makes us human.
Faraz Talat

The writer is a doctor based in Rawalpindi and writes about current affairs and societal issues.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Nana | 7 years ago | Reply I am a guy and I must say I have the hugest crush on you. It makes me cry..
Chitral wala | 7 years ago | Reply We all gone go and get a collection of towels. large size. And mail them to the blogger so he can forward them to Amir, to dry his tears. And all the perpetually whining Indians on this Pro Bharat ET can get some paper towels for their crocodile tears. Seems like the author has nothing better to do than write puke inducing blogs. He should be running pillar to post..polio vaccinations, medical care to IDP's, Free weekend clinics in FATA Free medical care to Afghan refugees, [still refugees after 35 years.] If the author has too much time he can move to Balochistan? Quetta? Beautiful area. Help the Shia Hazaras? Zikris? Just avoid Jundullah, And they will sing your praises there...the 'True Hakim' from Punjabi 'Pindi.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ